Cheddar Tom wrote:I don't find it to be an overreaction to believe the Cubs have surpassed the Cardinals...even if they do get Grichuk/Holliday back. The Cubs have a more dynamic lineup and if the starting pitching falters or if they need a bullpen game they STILL win. They are 40-21 since the ASB despite Jason Hammel, Kyle Hendricks and Daren Haren posting 5.43, 5.29 and 5.00 ERAs respectively. Jake Arrieta has a 0.95 ERA in the 2nd half and there are only 2 pitchers in the NL who are on his level. Both play in LA. The Cubs sat Fowler, Schwarber, Coghlan and Russell today and still pounded Wacha.
The Cards simply can't match the Cubs lineup depth and the offense is so feeble they can't even get the job done against Wood or Cahill. I would love to believe this is a mirage...but I don't see it.
The Cubs have a slightly better lineup, Cubs have a better 1-2 punch, but the Cardinals have more depth in the rotation, and Cardinals have a better bullpen. I don't think there's much separation between the Cards/Cubs/Pirates, if any at all. Hell, honestly, I think all the teams in the NL playoffs this season Dodgers, Mets, Cards. Cubs, Pirates are pretty much all equal. I don't see any big difference between the 5. Some might be better in categories then others, but yeah. At full strength, I think the Cards/Pirates are probably the two best teams top to bottom, but the other teams might be more dynamic offensively or just have a stronger 1-2 punch in the rotation then the Cards and Pirates.