Page 4 of 4
Posted: April 4 07, 11:40 am
by TruffleShuffle
boiseCardsFan wrote:Hey - I didn't know Borat was in that band!
And someone remind me - what was Teddy Ballgames ERA again? And how many WS games did he win?
Teddy was the greatest hitter of them all, but the Babe is the greatest player ever hands down.
Ugh, how I hate this argument.
I voted for Ted Williams because I have multiple books about him, and my grandfather got his autograph in a restaurant back when I was a baby and gave it to me as a present. Babe Ruth is the best player of all-time, but if y'all can vote for Bob Gibson over Roger Clemens, then I can vote for Teddy Ballgame.
Posted: April 4 07, 1:22 pm
by redbirdjazzz
RC21 wrote:And the Splinter was a man's man. The dude oozed testosterone.
Are you saying the Babe didn't? He was known to sleep with every woman in a brothel in one night, then wake up and eat an 18 egg omelet!
Good point about the Yankee thing, though.
Posted: April 4 07, 2:16 pm
by cardinalkarp
Good point about the Yankee thing, though
Thing is, I may despise the Red Sox MORE than the Yankess at this point.
Posted: April 4 07, 2:18 pm
by TimeForGuinness
RC21 wrote:In a move that will be akin to voting for Ralph Nader, I'm going to throw my vote away and vote on the Splinter.
I know it's wrong.
I don't really believe that he was the better player.
But I'm doing it on general principle alone.
And how is this different than voting for Gibson over Clemens
Posted: April 4 07, 2:30 pm
by maddash
TimeForGuinness wrote:RC21 wrote:In a move that will be akin to voting for Ralph Nader, I'm going to throw my vote away and vote on the Splinter.
I know it's wrong.
I don't really believe that he was the better player.
But I'm doing it on general principle alone.
And how is this different than voting for Gibson over Clemens
RC21 wrote:Fat Strat wrote:
RC probably hates me for putting his boy Clemens against Gibson. It's a great matchup, but I could see Gibson winning this thing on this board.
And there's absolutely no way that should happen.
This is a no-brainer.
Clemens has SEVEN Cy Youngs AND an MVP. Gibson has 2 and 0.
Clemens has almost 100 more wins. His winning % is .070 better than Gibson's.
Clemens has 1500 more K's and a better K/9 (i.e. it's not all about his having more IP than Gibson).
Clemens' BB/9 is better.
Clemens' WARP1, WARP2, and WARP3 advantages are very sizable (ranging from 60 to 80).
It's absolutely ridiculous that it's 10-9 as of this post.
Posted: April 4 07, 10:46 pm
by Michael
Congrats to the Babe!
Thanks for playing everyone!
Posted: April 5 07, 7:47 am
by JL21
TimeForGuinness wrote:RC21 wrote:In a move that will be akin to voting for Ralph Nader, I'm going to throw my vote away and vote on the Splinter.
I know it's wrong.
I don't really believe that he was the better player.
But I'm doing it on general principle alone.
And how is this different than voting for Gibson over Clemens
You'll note later that I say:
AND if everyone can vote for Bob Freakin' Gibson over Roger Clemens, then I can vote for the Splinter over the Babe.
Posted: April 5 07, 8:25 am
by fanforever
The Babe did something Ted Williams could not do. Win a World Series as a member of the Red Sox