Page 4 of 4
Re: Chris Cornell "Scream"
Posted: July 30 09, 11:11 am
by JL21
TheoSqua wrote:When Johnny Cash does a cover of something you wrote, that pretty much solidifies that you're a decent musician.
It solidifies that you were a decent songwriter one time.
Re: Chris Cornell "Scream"
Posted: July 30 09, 11:30 am
by ghostrunner
I'm kind of with JL here. I can't claim to be very familiar with NIN after say, 1996, but mostly that's because what I heard didn't impress me much. And in retrospect, Pretty Hate Machine doesn't hold up well at all. Downward Spiral was just sort of okay with a couple of highlights. The singles I know of since then "Perfect drug" and "Star_uckers" - not so good. Everybody goes on about "Hurt" but to me if I want to feel like a depressed self-pitying junkie, I'll take "The Needle and the Damage Done"
I like him better when it comes to his criticisms of music industry and his willingness to buck convention on that front.
Having said all that, I have to agree he's never done anything as bad as that Cornell song.
Re: Chris Cornell "Scream"
Posted: July 30 09, 11:50 am
by stlouie_lipp
ghostrunner wrote:Having said all that, I have to agree he's never done anything as bad as that Cornell song.
This can't be denied.
Re: Chris Cornell "Scream"
Posted: July 31 09, 1:44 am
by dexter
for the record, reznor is a one man band with stage hands. he is also an egomaniac that believes he is way smarter than he really is. the condescending attitude is old.
hes made a handful of great songs and helped pioneer and popularize that industrial sound but i would hesitate to put him in the upper echelon of modern musicians. i wouldnt hesitate to put him above cornell though.
the nin sound is played out imo. every song has become a slight variation of
"i can feel it...INSIDE OF ME!!!"
synthy instrumental breakdown, loop for 3-5 minutes.
and its easy to crap on the music industry after you sucked it dry.
Re: Chris Cornell "Scream"
Posted: July 31 09, 8:37 am
by lukethedrifter
I don't really know that much about Trent Reznor's personality other than what I heard in a recent half hour interview. He sounded like a decent, intelligent and straightforward guy. Of course, he's not a drug addict anymore so that may have something to do with it, I dunno.
/I realize this has little to do with his music itself, most of which I am discovering now
Re: Chris Cornell "Scream"
Posted: July 31 09, 8:44 am
by JL21
dexter wrote:helped pioneer and popularize that industrial sound
This is similar to saying "Kip Wells helped pioneer giving up three run homeruns".
Re: Chris Cornell "Scream"
Posted: July 31 09, 8:58 am
by ghostrunner
JL21 wrote:dexter wrote:helped pioneer and popularize that industrial sound
This is similar to saying "Kip Wells helped pioneer giving up three run homeruns".
You're on your own now, sir.
Re: Chris Cornell "Scream"
Posted: July 31 09, 9:34 am
by JackofDiamonds
The music I like is better than the music you like. Your favorite band is not very good. I would not pay to see them live, or to hear their music recorded. If that genre was to be overheard on a radio I did not own, I would ask that person to change the station. If they do not, I will leave the vicinity, but not before telling them that their choice in music is poor. Whereas my genre is beloved by all, especially highly regarded people. Attractive females prefer me because of my musical taste, specifically my ability to notice emerging artists within my favored genre before the masses are told to like them.
In the end, I am well liked and listen to good music. You should like what I like, and if you do not, you are wrong.
Re: Chris Cornell "Scream"
Posted: July 31 09, 9:51 am
by JL21
Yeah, yeah, yeah...
Look, to each their own and all that. Why don't I just put it this way- I'd rather listen to someone mercilessly [expletive] a cat in the butthole with a splintery baseball bat than industrial music or anything Trent Reznor has ever done. If you enjoy it, more power to you. I will miss Trent Reznor's bus.
Re: Chris Cornell "Scream"
Posted: July 31 09, 10:29 am
by lukethedrifter
JL21 wrote:Yeah, yeah, yeah...
Look, to each their own and all that. Why don't I just put it this way- I'd rather listen to someone mercilessly [expletive] a cat in the butthole with a splintery baseball bat
It's not all that it's cracked up to be.
I will miss Trent Reznor's bus.
I think we all will now that he's given up touring.