Page 4 of 8

Re: Rant: "Criminal Destruction of Property"

Posted: May 6 10, 4:53 pm
by The Third Man
No sweat. I just can't believe that happened. I've gotten tickets for some dumb [expletive] before, that I deserved, but that tree just collapses and [expletive] me in the ass out of nowhere.

Re: Rant: "Criminal Destruction of Property"

Posted: May 6 10, 4:58 pm
by Arthur Dent
If the branch came off that easily, it was almost certainly going to fall off pretty soon anyway. What a stupid thing for police to get involved in.

Re: Rant: "Criminal Destruction of Property"

Posted: May 6 10, 8:21 pm
by stlouie_lipp
The Third Man wrote:So where are the resident lawyers? I'm assuming a tree branch is worth less than $500.
Don't know the law in MO, but if that's an element of the crime ($500 in damage) I think the state will have a hard time proving-up those damages. There should also be a mens rea (state of mind) element in the statute. I'm guessing it's "knowingly" caused damage. In most states, "knowingly" means that you at least should have known your actions would result in the damage. The statute under which you are charged is probably on the ticket and should be easy to look up. Set the damn thing for trial.

Re: Rant: "Criminal Destruction of Property"

Posted: May 6 10, 8:28 pm
by The Third Man
The $500 thing, from what I've been able to find, is the difference between it being a misdemeanor and a felony. I've been wondering about the "knowingly" part myself, because who the hell would expect that to happen from a tug on a branch? Argh.

Re: Rant: "Criminal Destruction of Property"

Posted: May 6 10, 8:32 pm
by The Third Man
Here's the meat of it:

Code: Select all

14-302 CRIMINAL DAMAGE TO PROPERTY.

No person shall engage in criminal damage to property. Criminal damage to
property is by means other than fire or explosive:

(A) Intentionally injuring, damaging, mutilating, defacing, destroying, or
substantially impairing the use of any property in which another has an
interest without the consent of such other person; or
(B) Injuring, damaging, mutilating, defacing, destroying or substantially impairing
the use of any property with intent to injure or defraud an insurer or
lienholder.

Criminal damage to property is a misdemeanor if the property damaged is of the
value of less than $500.00 or is of the value of $500.00 or more and is damaged
to the extent of less than $500.00. (Ord. 5051, Sec. 1; Ord. 5516, Art. 3; K.S.A.
21-3720)

14-303 CRIMINAL DAMAGE TO PROPERTY; HARMING PLANTS.

No person shall willfully injure or destroy any plant, tree, vine or flower, the property
of another, standing on or attached to the land of another, or shall pick, destroy or
carry away therefrom or in any way interfere with any part of the flowers or fruit
thereof. (Code 1979, 14-302; Ord. 5516, Art. 3)

Re: Rant: "Criminal Destruction of Property"

Posted: May 6 10, 8:45 pm
by stlouie_lipp
14-303 CRIMINAL DAMAGE TO PROPERTY; HARMING PLANTS.

No person shall willfully injure or destroy any plant, tree, vine or flower, the property
of another, standing on or attached to the land of another, or shall pick, destroy or
carry away therefrom or in any way interfere with any part of the flowers or fruit
thereof. (Code 1979, 14-302; Ord. 5516, Art. 3)
Seriously? That's a crime? Was it a state charge or ordinance violation you were charged with?

Willfully means a lot more that knowingly....so that's good for you. Willfully usually means you did it on purpose with the intent to (in your case) "destroy" the tree. Maybe since heyzues has lived in Missouri he can offer a bit more guidance.

Re: Rant: "Criminal Destruction of Property"

Posted: May 6 10, 8:47 pm
by Hungary Jack
A new tree measuring 10 - 15 ft tall might cost $500 - $2000 depending on the species. A broken branch is obviously much different. I don't think you have to worry about a damage estimate in excess of $500.

Re: Rant: "Criminal Destruction of Property"

Posted: May 6 10, 8:53 pm
by stlouie_lipp
Hungary Jack wrote:A new tree measuring 10 - 15 ft tall might cost $500 - $2000 depending on the species. A broken branch is obviously much different. I don't think you have to worry about a damage estimate in excess of $500.
Based on what he posted, and on what I'm guessing he's charged with, I don't think the value of the property matters anymore.

Re: Rant: "Criminal Destruction of Property"

Posted: May 6 10, 8:53 pm
by lukethedrifter
stlouie_lipp wrote:
14-303 CRIMINAL DAMAGE TO PROPERTY; HARMING PLANTS.

No person shall willfully injure or destroy any plant, tree, vine or flower, the property
of another, standing on or attached to the land of another, or shall pick, destroy or
carry away therefrom or in any way interfere with any part of the flowers or fruit
thereof. (Code 1979, 14-302; Ord. 5516, Art. 3)
Seriously? That's a crime? Was it a state charge or ordinance violation you were charged with?

Willfully means a lot more that knowingly....so that's good for you. Willfully usually means you did it on purpose with the intent to (in your case) "destroy" the tree. Maybe since heyzues has lived in Missouri he can offer a bit more guidance.

This is the crime that John Mozeliak was accused of this past offseason.


/somebody had to make a low hanging fruit joke

Re: Rant: "Criminal Destruction of Property"

Posted: May 6 10, 9:04 pm
by The Third Man
stlouie_lipp wrote:
14-303 CRIMINAL DAMAGE TO PROPERTY; HARMING PLANTS.

No person shall willfully injure or destroy any plant, tree, vine or flower, the property
of another, standing on or attached to the land of another, or shall pick, destroy or
carry away therefrom or in any way interfere with any part of the flowers or fruit
thereof. (Code 1979, 14-302; Ord. 5516, Art. 3)
Seriously? That's a crime? Was it a state charge or ordinance violation you were charged with?

Willfully means a lot more that knowingly....so that's good for you. Willfully usually means you did it on purpose with the intent to (in your case) "destroy" the tree. Maybe since heyzues has lived in Missouri he can offer a bit more guidance.
That's from the Lawrence city code (this is in Kansas). The citation # written on my ticket is the 14-302 one, not 14-303. If anybody's interested enough to dig around, the code in full is here. Thanks for the feedback.