Page 4 of 9

Re: Plagiarism

Posted: May 6 11, 11:06 am
by G. Keenan
Uh oh, a counterargument:
Its not really plagiarism as it was exactly what I was going to write anyway.

Re: Plagiarism

Posted: May 6 11, 11:08 am
by cards2468
G. Keenan wrote:Uh oh, a counterargument:
Its not really plagiarism as it was exactly what I was going to write anyway.
great minds think alike

Re: Plagiarism

Posted: May 6 11, 11:55 am
by Hungary Jack
I made the mistake once of sending a fully-polished article to The Economist to see if they would publish it.

They did.

Re: Plagiarism

Posted: May 6 11, 1:49 pm
by TGantz
When I worked in a private library months ago, the librarian told me about the time her sister got caught plagiarizing.

She was in a sorority, and was running out of time, so she re-typed and handed in a paper that he found in the sorority's extensive collection of old papers and exams.

Well, the professor called her in, and told her that she knew the student had plagiarized. "Didn't you ever check the name on the paper?" she asked. Turned out that the professor had gone to the same school, had pledged to the same sorority--and that was her old paper. It was so pathetic that she let the student re-write the assignment.

Re: Plagiarism

Posted: May 6 11, 3:59 pm
by 2nd Timer
TGantz wrote:When I worked in a private library months ago, the librarian told me about the time her sister got caught plagiarizing.

She was in a sorority, and was running out of time, so she re-typed and handed in a paper that he found in the sorority's extensive collection of old papers and exams.

Well, the professor called her in, and told her that she knew the student had plagiarized. "Didn't you ever check the name on the paper?" she asked. Turned out that the professor had gone to the same school, had pledged to the same sorority--and that was her old paper. It was so pathetic that she let the student re-write the assignment.
Image

Re: Plagiarism

Posted: May 6 11, 4:26 pm
by Leroy
I will have to admit, I haven't plagiarized anything. But when I was in high school, I was really lazy about classes. I didn't study at all and coasted through. When my ACT score came back I actually got in trouble because my grades should have been much better, but I didn't care. Then they put me in this extra reading class because my aptitude was so high. I had to read like ten books and report on them. Screw that. I read the back cover of each one, wrote a report on them, and received an A on each one (obviously the teacher didn't read them either).

I was rewarded for my laziness when I thought I could get by with that in college and ended up dropping out.

Re: Plagiarism

Posted: May 6 11, 5:40 pm
by sighyoung
I just posted grades, and immediately received an e-mail entitled "Plaigerism!!" (yes, that's how the student spelled it) in which she swears that she would never do such a thing, and is a completely honest person. She writes that she included a bibliography with her final exam naming her sources--she didn't, and one of the "sources" was an online paper whose wording she cut-and-pasted without any attribution.

I just wrote back and politely told her that the decision is final, and that she has the right to appeal the grade, and told her whom to contact. I'm sure this isn't over yet.

Re: Plagiarism

Posted: May 6 11, 6:37 pm
by G. Keenan
Who do people think they're kidding when they try to pull something like this? Does she really think you'll fall for such BS?

Re: Plagiarism

Posted: May 6 11, 7:24 pm
by sighyoung
G. Keenan wrote:Who do people think they're kidding when they try to pull something like this? Does she really think you'll fall for such BS?
I really do think she does, because I'm a nice person. That bothers me. But I suspect she's tried to pull this before, and if she isn't corrected, will do it again. The "Oops! I didn't attach the bibliography" routine is old, lame, and makes no sense. I also didn't tell her what sources I'd found, so she's hoping that I didn't catch the online paper she cribbed.

As a matter of principle, I would just turn this over for others to deal with to simplify things. But I'm also protecting myself. There's something so phony about this student that it's disturbing. I think she'd throw me in front of a car if it would save her.

All that's going to happen is she gets an 'F', and the dean's office will create a file that documents the offense. If she's done it before, however, she's in deep doo-doo.

Re: Plagiarism

Posted: May 6 11, 9:08 pm
by TGantz
You're not even going to acknowledge my joke, sigh?