I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by Arthur Dent »

thrill wrote:a late term abortion for non-medical reasons
Can we find actual cases of this? It seems to be firmly in the realm of the hypothetical problem invented for political reasons.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by thrill »

Arthur Dent wrote:
thrill wrote:a late term abortion for non-medical reasons
Can we find actual cases of this? It seems to be firmly in the realm of the hypothetical problem invented for political reasons.
Then answer it hypothetically. Like I said I'm asking more as an intellectual exercise than looking to discuss it's real-world uses or implications.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by Arthur Dent »

thrill wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:
thrill wrote:a late term abortion for non-medical reasons
Can we find actual cases of this? It seems to be firmly in the realm of the hypothetical problem invented for political reasons.
Then answer it hypothetically. Like I said I'm asking more as an intellectual exercise than looking to discuss it's real-world uses or implications.
The whole point of inventing these scenarios is to get people to think they have something to do with the real word. The "ticking time bomb" terrorist you have to torture is another great example of this. That's fine if we're in a philosophy seminar, but when people are shooting non-hypothetical doctors, I think it would be best to stay in the real world.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by thrill »

Arthur Dent wrote:
thrill wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:
thrill wrote:a late term abortion for non-medical reasons
Can we find actual cases of this? It seems to be firmly in the realm of the hypothetical problem invented for political reasons.
Then answer it hypothetically. Like I said I'm asking more as an intellectual exercise than looking to discuss it's real-world uses or implications.
The whole point of inventing these scenarios is to get people to think they have something to do with the real word. The "ticking time bomb" terrorist you have to torture is another great example of this. That's fine if we're in a philosophy seminar, but when people are shooting non-hypothetical doctors, I think it would be best to stay in the real world.
Then feel free to not participate.

User avatar
cpebbles
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8829
Joined: August 30 07, 12:28 pm

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by cpebbles »

First, I'd like it explained why we are being asked to defend a hypothetical situation which is clearly against the law.

But to dive into this hypothetical situation, I honestly don't agree that viability of the fetus is really the determining factor in whether abortion is moral, and I don't think these situations that anti-abortionists love to pretend are at the heart of the issue occur often enough to impose restrictions on abortions when most people agree that they are acceptable.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by thrill »

cpebbles wrote:First, I'd like it explained why we are being asked to defend a hypothetical situation which is clearly against the law.
Like I said. I'm just curious. I'm not asking anyone to defend anything. Just asking if anyone felt like volunteering their reasons. If you feel defensive then it shouldn't be because of what I posted, but again, back to the off-putting reactions by both sides of this argument and the main reason little intelligent give-and-take ever takes place.
cpebbles wrote:But to dive into this hypothetical situation, I honestly don't agree that viability of the fetus is really the determining factor in whether abortion is moral, and I don't think these situations that anti-abortionists love to pretend are at the heart of the issue occur often enough to impose restrictions on abortions when most people agree that they are acceptable.
So what do you think is the determining moral factor? That's all I want to know.


Personally, I'm more apathetic than pro-choice, but if it came down to it, I'd vote pro-choice with stringent regulations. It's such murky territory with extreme rhetoric on both sides, but overall I don't think it's fair to repeal a law using scare tactics, terrorism or sensationalism. It's an unrealistic Utopia in which every woman who gets pregnant does so in a healthy way and is able to provide a stable, loving environment for their child. Unfortunately, most children who are aborted may well be better off dead. My real opinion is that we need to do a better job spreading birth control methods, specifically more affordable birth control pills, contraceptives and the morning after pill. You also can't know where to draw the line. Just rape, incest and health threatening abortions? What about the sad state of foster care, orphanages or the environment these kids would otherwise be raised in? The easiest thing to say is that everyone is responsible for their own choices, but that's unrealistic and often a drain on society.

Since it's obviously a situation with no real answer, I get apathetic and just kind of dismiss it as an unfortunate reality and move on. The reason I asked the question is because I'm interested in more reasoned, scientific reasons for both sides than just my attitude of throwing my hands up and walking away.

planet planet
http://tinyurl.com/2e4x5hy
Posts: 24904
Joined: April 15 06, 6:25 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by planet planet »

thrill wrote:What about the sad state of foster care, orphanages or the environment these kids would otherwise be raised in? The easiest thing to say is that everyone is responsible for their own choices, but that's unrealistic and often a drain on society.
You omit the most favorable choice for everyone involved which is adoption. I wish there were ways to encourage adoption for unwanted babies. I understand that's a steep sacrifice (for lack of a better word) for the mother, but that's why fewer are choosing that route today. There are waiting lists five years long for legal domestic adoptions, filled with families perfectly willing to pay whatever it takes and provide loving homes.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by thrill »

planet pujolsian wrote:
thrill wrote:What about the sad state of foster care, orphanages or the environment these kids would otherwise be raised in? The easiest thing to say is that everyone is responsible for their own choices, but that's unrealistic and often a drain on society.
You omit the most favorable choice for everyone involved which is adoption. I wish there were ways to encourage adoption for unwanted babies. I understand that's a steep sacrifice (for lack of a better word) for the mother, but that's why fewer are choosing that route today. There are waiting lists five years long for legal domestic adoptions, filled with families perfectly willing to pay whatever it takes and provide loving homes.
My brother is adopted. I am VERY pro-adoption. I plan to do it myself someday as long as whoever I'm with is on board. I'd probably adopt even if I never got married actually.

Unfortunately it's not easy to get qualified and not enough children who should be put up for adoption are put up. They bounce from their unhealthy birth family to their unhealthy foster situation multiple times.

planet planet
http://tinyurl.com/2e4x5hy
Posts: 24904
Joined: April 15 06, 6:25 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by planet planet »

How old was your brother when he was adopted? It seems there are mostly issues in finding homes for older kids (teenagers). I wasn't insinuating you didn't consider it, I just wish more could be done to make adoption a reality for these moms who don't feel like they have choices.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by thrill »

planet pujolsian wrote:How old was your brother when he was adopted? It seems there are mostly issues in finding homes for older kids (teenagers). I wasn't insinuating you didn't consider it, I just wish more could be done to make adoption a reality for these moms who don't feel like they have choices.
He was 1 and a half. His grandparents had his mom declared unfit when she was sent to prison and they could no longer afford him due to health problems and then my parents adopted him from them.

Post Reply