Page 5 of 12

Re: People protesting signing Vick

Posted: August 17 09, 8:48 pm
by cardsfansince82
I learned a long time ago that putting athletes up on a pedestal and hoping for anything from them beyond being entertaining on the field usually ends in disappointment. Vick paid a heavier price than any of us that has common sense ever will and I'm willing to give him a second chance.

Re: People protesting signing Vick

Posted: August 17 09, 8:54 pm
by wart57
cardsfansince82 wrote:I learned a long time ago that putting athletes up on a pedestal and hoping for anything from them beyond being entertaining on the field usually ends in disappointment. Vick paid a heavier price than any of us that has common sense ever will and I'm willing to give him a second chance.
I am not saying he does not deserve a second chance, I am saying I understand why people are protesting. Also, people know that humans have a voice and can attempt to protect themselves, dogs don't.

Re: People protesting signing Vick

Posted: August 17 09, 8:59 pm
by docellis
InvincibleCakeEater wrote:
wart57 wrote:
InvincibleCakeEater wrote:
wart57 wrote:
dexter wrote:oddly, stallworth had my immediate support while i was immediately against vick. then again stallworth was pretty much a class act while vick was out spreading herpes.
Stallworth made one bad decision that cost a man his life in a terrible accident. Vick made the same choice over and over and it resulted the deliberate death and torture of hundreds of dogs
IMO
big difference, in real life and the court system
drinking and driving is a choice, not an accident

1 human life > 1 thousand dogs lives

IMO
20 years ago it was legal to drink and drive.
Drinking and driving was wrong then too, right?

Murdering an animal with your hands is different than being too impaired to make a good decision.

Re: People protesting signing Vick

Posted: August 17 09, 9:01 pm
by G. Keenan
wart57 wrote:
cardsfansince82 wrote:I learned a long time ago that putting athletes up on a pedestal and hoping for anything from them beyond being entertaining on the field usually ends in disappointment. Vick paid a heavier price than any of us that has common sense ever will and I'm willing to give him a second chance.
I am not saying he does not deserve a second chance, I am saying I understand why people are protesting. Also, people know that humans have a voice and can attempt to protect themselves, dogs don't.
I understand why people are protesting as well. Vick is a symbol of animal cruelty for good reason. Unfortunately he is just one tiny instance of the cruelty perpetrated against dogs and cats. The cruelty perpetrated against other animals is unfathomable in the scale on which it occurs and most people don't blink an eye. These protesters should direct their energy to the ongoing cruelty against animals and not at one guy who has done the time for his crime.

To further Joeybomb this thread, one of the signs held up said "Everyone deserves a second chance. Burger King is hiring." I can't help but think that the middle aged white people who constituted the particular protest I saw wouldn't hold up such signs if the guy in questions wasn't a big scary black man.

Re: People protesting signing Vick

Posted: August 17 09, 9:05 pm
by ghostrunner
If only Vick had gone to jail or something.

Re: People protesting signing Vick

Posted: August 17 09, 9:12 pm
by wart57
G. Keenan wrote:
wart57 wrote:
cardsfansince82 wrote:I learned a long time ago that putting athletes up on a pedestal and hoping for anything from them beyond being entertaining on the field usually ends in disappointment. Vick paid a heavier price than any of us that has common sense ever will and I'm willing to give him a second chance.
I am not saying he does not deserve a second chance, I am saying I understand why people are protesting. Also, people know that humans have a voice and can attempt to protect themselves, dogs don't.
I understand why people are protesting as well. Vick is a symbol of animal cruelty for good reason. Unfortunately he is just one tiny instance of the cruelty perpetrated against dogs and cats. The cruelty perpetrated against other animals is unfathomable in the scale on which it occurs and most people don't blink an eye. These protesters should direct their energy to the ongoing cruelty against animals and not at one guy who has done the time for his crime.

To further Joeybomb this thread, one of the signs held up said "Everyone deserves a second chance. Burger King is hiring." I can't help but think that the middle aged white people who constituted the particular protest I saw wouldn't hold up such signs if the guy in questions wasn't a big scary black man.
Don't be so hard on them, racism is a cultural thing....

Re: People protesting signing Vick

Posted: August 17 09, 9:14 pm
by InvincibleCakeEater
wart57 wrote:
G. Keenan wrote:
wart57 wrote:
cardsfansince82 wrote:I learned a long time ago that putting athletes up on a pedestal and hoping for anything from them beyond being entertaining on the field usually ends in disappointment. Vick paid a heavier price than any of us that has common sense ever will and I'm willing to give him a second chance.
I am not saying he does not deserve a second chance, I am saying I understand why people are protesting. Also, people know that humans have a voice and can attempt to protect themselves, dogs don't.
I understand why people are protesting as well. Vick is a symbol of animal cruelty for good reason. Unfortunately he is just one tiny instance of the cruelty perpetrated against dogs and cats. The cruelty perpetrated against other animals is unfathomable in the scale on which it occurs and most people don't blink an eye. These protesters should direct their energy to the ongoing cruelty against animals and not at one guy who has done the time for his crime.

To further Joeybomb this thread, one of the signs held up said "Everyone deserves a second chance. Burger King is hiring." I can't help but think that the middle aged white people who constituted the particular protest I saw wouldn't hold up such signs if the guy in questions wasn't a big scary black man.
Of course, it must be racism. That is the only way anybody would be against a man who did this.
I think you're missing his point. He's talking about what the sign said. I doubt the same sign would be held if were Steve Jobs who got caught dog fighting.

Re: People protesting signing Vick

Posted: August 17 09, 9:16 pm
by wart57
InvincibleCakeEater wrote:
wart57 wrote:
G. Keenan wrote:
wart57 wrote:
cardsfansince82 wrote:I learned a long time ago that putting athletes up on a pedestal and hoping for anything from them beyond being entertaining on the field usually ends in disappointment. Vick paid a heavier price than any of us that has common sense ever will and I'm willing to give him a second chance.
I am not saying he does not deserve a second chance, I am saying I understand why people are protesting. Also, people know that humans have a voice and can attempt to protect themselves, dogs don't.
I understand why people are protesting as well. Vick is a symbol of animal cruelty for good reason. Unfortunately he is just one tiny instance of the cruelty perpetrated against dogs and cats. The cruelty perpetrated against other animals is unfathomable in the scale on which it occurs and most people don't blink an eye. These protesters should direct their energy to the ongoing cruelty against animals and not at one guy who has done the time for his crime.

To further Joeybomb this thread, one of the signs held up said "Everyone deserves a second chance. Burger King is hiring." I can't help but think that the middle aged white people who constituted the particular protest I saw wouldn't hold up such signs if the guy in questions wasn't a big scary black man.
Of course, it must be racism. That is the only way anybody would be against a man who did this.
I think you're missing his point. He's talking about what the sign said. I doubt the same sign would be held if were Steve Jobs who got caught dog fighting.
I completely disagree. I think if Jobs had been dog fighting Apple would go bankrupt.

Re: People protesting signing Vick

Posted: August 17 09, 9:23 pm
by cardsfansince82
Wart is just trying to be the voice of reason among all the sheep here.

Re: People protesting signing Vick

Posted: August 17 09, 9:24 pm
by wart57
cardsfansince82 wrote:Wart is just trying to be the voice of reason among all the sheep here.
Somebody has to go against the liberal slant of this board... :cool: