NFL Week 8

A forum for non-baseball sports
Post Reply
User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by lukethedrifter »

cpebbles wrote:The #1 overall pick produces the best players. The gap between the #1 overall pick and the #2 overall pick is bigger than between any other two positions in the draft. There is absolutely no way you can look at studies of draft value and deny that the Rams' prospects for improvement get better with the #1 pick.

I'm not saying that the players on the Rams should tank, just that the fewer cheap wins they pick up the better. This team sucks and is a few seasons away from competing even in a weak conference.
I don't dispute your findings. But I can look back over the years at the teams holding the first overall pick and tell you that that is not how solid franchises are built. Sure it wouldn't hurt but there are a lot of factors, many of which are more important. Spags is learning on the job how to be a head football coach and I value that over however much you'd increase your odds of landing a HOFer.

I for one don't really care about the Gatorade shower other than in this era had he not gotten one it would have meant he'd lost his team.

/I don't mean that

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by Freed Roger »

Wow. Rams won.

on that #1 - #1 draft pick doesn't mean that much to a team that needs upgrades at nearly every position. I'm not saying that a lower pick is better than #1, but that #1 has some downside - the main one being he will demand #1 money and will use up more cap than a lower pick. You never know -a #1 could also refuse to sign with the Rams.

For the future, I'd rather see the younger players get to experience what victory is like. how good is it for Laurinitis to go 0-16. 4-12 teams, or 3-13 can conceivably make the playoffs within year(s) -but 0-16 teams can not.

Just finished the Vikes Pack game on DVR. Somewhat like their first encounter IMO. Favre was impressive, mainly in avoiding mistakes. (also very fortunate at times too.) He's a huge upgrade over Tavaris Jackson. He clearly plays on the better of the two teams. As in the first Vike Pack game, the outcome of this game would not have been any different if they traded QBs for the day. It probably would have been more lopsided.
If Packers fans feel betrayed by anyone, it should be their O and D Lines.

User avatar
epinephrine
Veteran Player
Posts: 772
Joined: August 4 09, 9:24 pm
Location: 815, IL

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by epinephrine »

Freed Roger wrote:Wow. Rams win.

on that #1 - #1 draft pick doesn't mean that much to a team that needs upgrades at nearly every position. I'm not saying that a lower pick is better than #1, but that #1 has some downside - the main one being he will demand #1 money and will use up more cap than a lower pick. You never know -a #1 could also refuse to sign with the Rams.

For the future, I'd rather see the younger players get to experience what victory is like. how good is it for Laurinitis to go 0-16. 4-12 teams, or 3-13 can conceivably make the playoffs within year(s) -but 0-16 teams can not.
They can do that? I know draft picks can not sign (like idiot Crabtree), but I thought the #1 usually signs with the team before the draft even happens... a la Matt Stafford this year with the Lions. Assuming they had the #1 pick and wanted a certain guy, wouldn't they know before draft day that they won't sign him?

Good point about the 0-16 thing, wins for the young guys is a good confidence booster. The Rams had arguably the toughest schedule in the NFL this year except for maybe Tampa Bay, and next year's schedule is a lot more forgiving. Having said that, I think they'll win another game this year. The schedule would indicate otherwise, but last year they played over their heads and got a win against the Cowboys, and 2 weeks ago the Raiders managed to horribly upset the Eagles. I think they'll beat somebody else.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by Freed Roger »

epinephrine wrote:
Freed Roger wrote:Wow. Rams win.

on that #1 - #1 draft pick doesn't mean that much to a team that needs upgrades at nearly every position. I'm not saying that a lower pick is better than #1, but that #1 has some downside - the main one being he will demand #1 money and will use up more cap than a lower pick. You never know -a #1 could also refuse to sign with the Rams.

For the future, I'd rather see the younger players get to experience what victory is like. how good is it for Laurinitis to go 0-16. 4-12 teams, or 3-13 can conceivably make the playoffs within year(s) -but 0-16 teams can not.
They can do that? I know draft picks can not sign (like idiot Crabtree), but I thought the #1 usually signs with the team before the draft even happens... a la Matt Stafford this year with the Lions. Assuming they had the #1 pick and wanted a certain guy, wouldn't they know before draft day that they won't sign him?

Good point about the 0-16 thing, wins for the young guys is a good confidence booster. The Rams had arguably the toughest schedule in the NFL this year except for maybe Tampa Bay, and next year's schedule is a lot more forgiving. Having said that, I think they'll win another game this year. The schedule would indicate otherwise, but last year they played over their heads and got a win against the Cowboys, and 2 weeks ago the Raiders managed to horribly upset the Eagles. I think they'll beat somebody else.
I'm not sure about the legalities, but they can't be forced to sign a deal. They can sit out and wait to be redrafted like Crabtree was doing. Or they can just wait and force a deal. Being drafted by Rams isn't exactly a ticket to football heaven right now-uncertainties abound, and for a QB or RB, plan on getting pummelled often. Eli Manning refused to play for Chargers and the draft day deal was made with Giants. it went fairly smooth. John Elway was drafted by Baltimore Colts and refused to sign, threatened to play baseball, and had to be traded to Denver. St. Louis Cardinals signed some girl named Kelly Stouffer, with an early pick and (s)he refused.

User avatar
epinephrine
Veteran Player
Posts: 772
Joined: August 4 09, 9:24 pm
Location: 815, IL

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by epinephrine »

That's interesting. Well, I don't think the Rams will have the #1 pick, so we shouldn't have to worry about it. About the Rams not being exactly "football heaven," I would hope that a team drafting #1 isn't a ticket to football heaven, haha. Sure, teams can trade up to #1 if they desperately want somebody, but more-often-than-not the team drafting #1 is drafting there for a reason. Players projected to go #1 overall should have a pretty good idea of the situation they're entering (not that that will stop them from being picky).

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by Freed Roger »

who is the coveted #1 draft prospect as of now anyway?

Online
Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by Socnorb11 »

Freed Roger wrote:who is the coveted #1 draft prospect as of now anyway?
Tim Tebow

I loved Sam Bradford before his injury-plagued season.

I don't know what the Rams would be looking for specifically. I think the safety from Tennessee (Eric Berry) and the DT from Oklahoma (Gerald McCoy) are pretty highly regarded. I think it's a pretty weak field, from a skill position standpoint. But I'm no expert.

User avatar
epinephrine
Veteran Player
Posts: 772
Joined: August 4 09, 9:24 pm
Location: 815, IL

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by epinephrine »

That is a really good question. Walterfootball.com always predicts Jimmy Clausen will go first (but that entirely depends who drafts first, ex: the Bucs drafted a QB in the 1st round last year) but I've heard Ndamukong Suh as a possibility. Since the Bradford injury, I really haven't heard any surefire predictions for the #1 pick.

edit: http://walterfootball.com/draft2010.php -- if anybody was interested. He updates it every Thursday ... I enjoy looking at it.

User avatar
cpebbles
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8829
Joined: August 30 07, 12:28 pm

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by cpebbles »

I don't follow college football but Claussen wasn't even in the discussion for #1 overall before Bradford got reinjured, and I don't agree that QB is the overwhelming position of need. Passing up a franchise LT or a dominating tackle in order to send a message about Bulger's poor play would be idiotic.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by lukethedrifter »

Clausen? Hell, no. I hope the Rams win out.

Post Reply