GDT 10/12/11-Brewers (Gallardo) @ Cards (Carpenter) 7:05 CDT

[go birds]

How's about slappin the ole radar screenshot on here?

[heyzeus]

Unless more develops, most of the rain should stay to the southeast of STL. Play ball!

[NDark]

Lineup:

Furcal 6
Jay 8
Pujols 3
Holliday 9
Berkman 7
Molina 2
Freese 5
Punto 4
Carp 1

[Cronos]

Lineup:

Furcal 6
Jay 8
Pujols 3
Holliday 9
Berkman 7
Molina 2
Freese 5
Punto 4
Carp 1

Brewers Lineup:

Hart RF
Kotsay CF
Braun LF
Fielder 1B
Weeks 2B
Hairston 3B
Betancourt SS
Lucroy C
Gallardo P


Kind of surprised there's no Nyjer Morgan tonight. I figured Roenicke would have him in there in the hopes that he distracts or otherwise messes with Carpenter. Maybe he wanted more defense with Kotsay, anticipating a pitcher's duel?

[Bo Hart]

Kind of surprised there's no Nyjer Morgan tonight. I figured Roenicke would have him in there in the hopes that he distracts or otherwise messes with Carpenter. Maybe he wanted more defense with Kotsay, anticipating a pitcher's duel?

Defensive metrics don't really like Mark Kotsay anymore. I think the decision is based on small sample histories of the two players: Kotsay is 4-11 against carpenter (.364), while Morgan is just 4-23 (.174). Whether those stats are meaningful at all is a discussion in itself, but I bet that's what the decision was based on.

[HomeBrew]

Kind of surprised there's no Nyjer Morgan tonight. I figured Roenicke would have him in there in the hopes that he distracts or otherwise messes with Carpenter. Maybe he wanted more defense with Kotsay, anticipating a pitcher's duel?

Not the reason. Kotsay is a terrible OF, especially in Center. I would have been happy with Gomez out there as he has swung the stick well lately and is exceptional on D. This is just a horrendous decision by Roenicke. He will cost the Crew at least 1 run in the field.

[Spider John]

Lineup:

Furcal 6
Jay 8
Pujols 3
Holliday 9
Berkman 7
Molina 2
Freese 5
Punto 4
Carp 1

Brewers Lineup:

Hart RF
Kotsay CF
Braun LF
Fielder 1B
Weeks 2B
Hairston 3B
Betancourt SS
Lucroy C
Gallardo P


Kind of surprised there's no Nyjer Morgan tonight. I figured Roenicke would have him in there in the hopes that he distracts or otherwise messes with Carpenter. Maybe he wanted more defense with Kotsay, anticipating a pitcher's duel?

I wonder if it's because Nyjer's focus might be more on being the center of attention instead of the game.

[Jmodene]

Kind of surprised there's no Nyjer Morgan tonight. I figured Roenicke would have him in there in the hopes that he distracts or otherwise messes with Carpenter. Maybe he wanted more defense with Kotsay, anticipating a pitcher's duel?

Not the reason. Kotsay is a terrible OF, especially in Center. I would have been happy with Gomez out there as he has swung the stick well lately and is exceptional on D. This is just a horrendous decision by Roenicke. He will cost the Crew at least 1 run in the field.

We can only hope.

[Cronos]

Not the reason. Kotsay is a terrible OF, especially in Center. I would have been happy with Gomez out there as he has swung the stick well lately and is exceptional on D. This is just a horrendous decision by Roenicke. He will cost the Crew at least 1 run in the field.

Cool, thanks for checking in with this. I had no clue about Kotsay's defense, I just figured there had to be some reason for Roenicke to use him. Looks like there pretty much isn't. Good news.

(watch him have a crucial hit in the game now)

[AWvsCBsteeeerike3]

I have no idea if this is right or not, but according to fangraphs, Gomez>Morgan>>>>Kotsay on D.

Morgan is a 4 WAR guy this year according to fangraphs as well....