Page 5 of 9
Re: 8/19 GDT: Cardinals(McGreevy) @ Marlins(Cabrera) 5:40 PM CT
Posted: August 19 25, 6:17 pm
by sighyoung
CardsofSTL wrote: ↑August 19 25, 6:16 pm
st.lewis11 wrote: ↑August 19 25, 6:12 pm
Although I've spent many years playing & watching baseball, I've never been clear on when a batter is allowed to advance to first on a missed 3rd strike, and what situations when he's not.
If 1st base is not occupied; the catcher must catch the ball to complete the out. If 1st base is occupied with less than 2 outs; the batter is out. If the ball is dropped with two outs; then the runners all try to advance and the catcher must tag or throw out the batter--which is why if the bases are loaded with 2 outs; the catcher can just step on the plate.
++
Re: 8/19 GDT: Cardinals(McGreevy) @ Marlins(Cabrera) 5:40 PM CT
Posted: August 19 25, 6:18 pm
by CardsofSTL
McGreevy has a nice fifth inning after the poor defense in the 4th and we are on to the sixth.
Re: 8/19 GDT: Cardinals(McGreevy) @ Marlins(Cabrera) 5:40 PM CT
Posted: August 19 25, 6:20 pm
by st.lewis11
CardsofSTL wrote: ↑August 19 25, 6:16 pm
st.lewis11 wrote: ↑August 19 25, 6:12 pm
Although I've spent many years playing & watching baseball, I've never been clear on when a batter is allowed to advance to first on a missed 3rd strike, and what situations when he's not.
If 1st base is not occupied; the catcher must catch the ball to complete the out. If 1st base is occupied with less than 2 outs; the batter is out. If the ball is dropped with two outs; then the runners all try to advance and the catcher must tag or throw out the batter--which is why if the bases are loaded with 2 outs; the catcher can just step on the plate.
So to clarify, batter can advance to first if it’s not occupied unless there’s 2 outs? In which case batter can advance also?
Re: 8/19 GDT: Cardinals(McGreevy) @ Marlins(Cabrera) 5:40 PM CT
Posted: August 19 25, 6:21 pm
by CardsofSTL
st.lewis11 wrote: ↑August 19 25, 6:20 pm
CardsofSTL wrote: ↑August 19 25, 6:16 pm
st.lewis11 wrote: ↑August 19 25, 6:12 pm
Although I've spent many years playing & watching baseball, I've never been clear on when a batter is allowed to advance to first on a missed 3rd strike, and what situations when he's not.
If 1st base is not occupied; the catcher must catch the ball to complete the out. If 1st base is occupied with less than 2 outs; the batter is out. If the ball is dropped with two outs; then the runners all try to advance and the catcher must tag or throw out the batter--which is why if the bases are loaded with 2 outs; the catcher can just step on the plate.
So to clarify, batter can advance to first if it’s not occupied unless there’s 2 outs? In which case batter can advance also?
Yes; if 1st base is unoccupied with less than 2 outs; or occupied with 2 outs.
Re: 8/19 GDT: Cardinals(McGreevy) @ Marlins(Cabrera) 5:40 PM CT
Posted: August 19 25, 6:23 pm
by st.lewis11
CardsofSTL wrote: ↑August 19 25, 6:21 pm
st.lewis11 wrote: ↑August 19 25, 6:20 pm
CardsofSTL wrote: ↑August 19 25, 6:16 pm
st.lewis11 wrote: ↑August 19 25, 6:12 pm
Although I've spent many years playing & watching baseball, I've never been clear on when a batter is allowed to advance to first on a missed 3rd strike, and what situations when he's not.
If 1st base is not occupied; the catcher must catch the ball to complete the out. If 1st base is occupied with less than 2 outs; the batter is out. If the ball is dropped with two outs; then the runners all try to advance and the catcher must tag or throw out the batter--which is why if the bases are loaded with 2 outs; the catcher can just step on the plate.
So to clarify, batter can advance to first if it’s not occupied unless there’s 2 outs? In which case batter can advance also?
Yes; if 1st base is unoccupied with less than 2 outs; or occupied with 2 outs.
Thanks
Re: 8/19 GDT: Cardinals(McGreevy) @ Marlins(Cabrera) 5:40 PM CT
Posted: August 19 25, 6:29 pm
by CardsofSTL
McGreevy gives up a lead off single to Edwards to start the sixth.
Re: 8/19 GDT: Cardinals(McGreevy) @ Marlins(Cabrera) 5:40 PM CT
Posted: August 19 25, 6:33 pm
by booger71
Mason dropped the ball
Re: 8/19 GDT: Cardinals(McGreevy) @ Marlins(Cabrera) 5:40 PM CT
Posted: August 19 25, 6:33 pm
by CardsofSTL
Ramirez stretches a hit into RC into a double; would have been out at 2nd but Winn got the ball on a hop into the heel of his glove and drops the throw.
Re: 8/19 GDT: Cardinals(McGreevy) @ Marlins(Cabrera) 5:40 PM CT
Posted: August 19 25, 6:33 pm
by Joe Shlabotnik
The whole dropped-third-strike thing is to prevent an easy double play. Just like infield fly. In case that helps make sense of it.
In both cases, ask yourself "If the ball is dropped would there be an easy DP?" If the answer is yes, then the batter is out and the ball remains live.
Re: 8/19 GDT: Cardinals(McGreevy) @ Marlins(Cabrera) 5:40 PM CT
Posted: August 19 25, 6:34 pm
by CardsofSTL
Marlins have 2nd and 3rd with 1 out as McGreevy faces the clean up man for the Marlins.