Oh but we are way more advanced than those people, aren't we?JL21 wrote:Some societies have done just that, historically. Not the elderly, but children with birth defects.wart57 wrote:Well then to take your point further, why isn't it ok to kill elderly people with dimentia or alzheimers? The last time I checked, human lives were seen differently than animals and flowers and insects.
Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown
- wart57
- just can't quit you.
- Posts: 25076
- Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
- Location: Lost
Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown
-
TimeForGuinness
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 20007
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm
Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown
...but it's still a life by your definition.wart57 wrote:Well then to take your point further, why isn't it ok to kill elderly people with dimentia or alzheimers? The last time I checked, human lives were seen differently than animals and flowers and insects.TimeForGuinness wrote:By that definition, then I agree with you...flowers, animals, mammals, etc...their "lives" begin at conception.wart57 wrote:I have no proof of when life begins. I believe life begins at the time of conception.TimeForGuinness wrote:I asked you first...since you want to go deeper with this topic. I'll give you my answer after you give me yours.wart57 wrote:Define not a life.TimeForGuinness wrote:define life.wart57 wrote:If you believe that there is a life being lost during an abortion, how can it be a choice?
So why is it ok to kill flowers, animals, and mammals?
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown
Not that I'm suggesting offing old folks is a good idea, under the conditions I see many of them living that might be a better option.wart57 wrote:Well then to take your point further, why isn't it ok to kill elderly people with dimentia or alzheimers? The last time I checked, human lives were seen differently than animals and flowers and insects.TimeForGuinness wrote:By that definition, then I agree with you...flowers, animals, mammals, etc...their "lives" begin at conception.wart57 wrote:I have no proof of when life begins. I believe life begins at the time of conception.TimeForGuinness wrote:I asked you first...since you want to go deeper with this topic. I'll give you my answer after you give me yours.wart57 wrote:Define not a life.TimeForGuinness wrote:define life.wart57 wrote:If you believe that there is a life being lost during an abortion, how can it be a choice?
So why is it ok to kill flowers, animals, and mammals?
- JL21
- NPR & THT Contributor
- Posts: 36109
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
- Location: Chocolate City
Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown
In some regards, sure. But I wouldn't assume that we are in all regards.I don't think anyone would say that the ancient Greeks weren't advanced, relatively speaking.wart57 wrote:Oh but we are way more advanced than those people, aren't we?JL21 wrote:Some societies have done just that, historically. Not the elderly, but children with birth defects.wart57 wrote:Well then to take your point further, why isn't it ok to kill elderly people with dimentia or alzheimers? The last time I checked, human lives were seen differently than animals and flowers and insects.
- wart57
- just can't quit you.
- Posts: 25076
- Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
- Location: Lost
Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown
Yes it is a life. But taking a human life is morally different. We put dogs and cats to sleep all the time when their quality of life is poor, yet we, as a society, don't think it is morally right to do this to people who are suffering.TimeForGuinness wrote:...but it's still a life by your definition.wart57 wrote:Well then to take your point further, why isn't it ok to kill elderly people with dimentia or alzheimers? The last time I checked, human lives were seen differently than animals and flowers and insects.TimeForGuinness wrote:By that definition, then I agree with you...flowers, animals, mammals, etc...their "lives" begin at conception.wart57 wrote:I have no proof of when life begins. I believe life begins at the time of conception.TimeForGuinness wrote:I asked you first...since you want to go deeper with this topic. I'll give you my answer after you give me yours.wart57 wrote:Define not a life.TimeForGuinness wrote:define life.wart57 wrote:If you believe that there is a life being lost during an abortion, how can it be a choice?
So why is it ok to kill flowers, animals, and mammals?
-
TimeForGuinness
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 20007
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm
Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown
Why should it be morally different?wart57 wrote:Yes it is a life. But taking a human life is morally different. We put dogs and cats to sleep all the time when their quality of life is poor, yet we, as a society, don't think it is morally right to do this to people who are suffering.TimeForGuinness wrote:...but it's still a life by your definition.wart57 wrote:Well then to take your point further, why isn't it ok to kill elderly people with dimentia or alzheimers? The last time I checked, human lives were seen differently than animals and flowers and insects.TimeForGuinness wrote:By that definition, then I agree with you...flowers, animals, mammals, etc...their "lives" begin at conception.wart57 wrote:I have no proof of when life begins. I believe life begins at the time of conception.TimeForGuinness wrote:I asked you first...since you want to go deeper with this topic. I'll give you my answer after you give me yours.wart57 wrote:Define not a life.TimeForGuinness wrote:define life.wart57 wrote:If you believe that there is a life being lost during an abortion, how can it be a choice?
So why is it ok to kill flowers, animals, and mammals?
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown
The absolutist position that life begins at conception- no ifs ands or buts- and must be preserved at all costs puts one in a tricky position to argue.
Ectopic pregnancies? IVF selection? Extreme and nonviable birth defects? Mother's health?
Ectopic pregnancies? IVF selection? Extreme and nonviable birth defects? Mother's health?
- wart57
- just can't quit you.
- Posts: 25076
- Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
- Location: Lost
Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown
So for me to prove my point, I have to explain why we as humans view human life as different than the animals and flowers?TimeForGuinness wrote:Why should it be morally different?wart57 wrote:Yes it is a life. But taking a human life is morally different. We put dogs and cats to sleep all the time when their quality of life is poor, yet we, as a society, don't think it is morally right to do this to people who are suffering.TimeForGuinness wrote:...but it's still a life by your definition.wart57 wrote:Well then to take your point further, why isn't it ok to kill elderly people with dimentia or alzheimers? The last time I checked, human lives were seen differently than animals and flowers and insects.TimeForGuinness wrote:By that definition, then I agree with you...flowers, animals, mammals, etc...their "lives" begin at conception.wart57 wrote:I have no proof of when life begins. I believe life begins at the time of conception.TimeForGuinness wrote:I asked you first...since you want to go deeper with this topic. I'll give you my answer after you give me yours.wart57 wrote:Define not a life.TimeForGuinness wrote:define life.wart57 wrote:If you believe that there is a life being lost during an abortion, how can it be a choice?
So why is it ok to kill flowers, animals, and mammals?
- wart57
- just can't quit you.
- Posts: 25076
- Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
- Location: Lost
Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown
My mother was told to have an abortion when she was pregnant with me because of a high birth defects, but mostly because she could very well have died carrying me to full term. She believed that I was alive, and that to have an abortiuon would be to murder me. If she had not believed this, I would not be here today.lukethedrifter wrote:The absolutist position that life begins at conception- no ifs ands or buts- and must be preserved at all costs puts one in a tricky position to argue.
Ectopic pregnancies? IVF selection? Extreme and nonviable birth defects? Mother's health?
-
TimeForGuinness
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 20007
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm
Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown
I'm just using your definition. Life begins at conception...well a lot of life forms act this way, so I'm wondering why you prefer to limit it to humans as morally wrong to take a life?wart57 wrote:So for me to prove my point, I have to explain why we as humans view human life as different than the animals and flowers?TimeForGuinness wrote:Why should it be morally different?wart57 wrote:Yes it is a life. But taking a human life is morally different. We put dogs and cats to sleep all the time when their quality of life is poor, yet we, as a society, don't think it is morally right to do this to people who are suffering.TimeForGuinness wrote:...but it's still a life by your definition.wart57 wrote:Well then to take your point further, why isn't it ok to kill elderly people with dimentia or alzheimers? The last time I checked, human lives were seen differently than animals and flowers and insects.TimeForGuinness wrote:By that definition, then I agree with you...flowers, animals, mammals, etc...their "lives" begin at conception.wart57 wrote:I have no proof of when life begins. I believe life begins at the time of conception.TimeForGuinness wrote:I asked you first...since you want to go deeper with this topic. I'll give you my answer after you give me yours.wart57 wrote:Define not a life.TimeForGuinness wrote:define life.wart57 wrote:If you believe that there is a life being lost during an abortion, how can it be a choice?
So why is it ok to kill flowers, animals, and mammals?
Do you believe in justified killings? Death penalty? War?
Those are lives too.

