I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
cpebbles
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8829
Joined: August 30 07, 12:28 pm

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by cpebbles »

thrill wrote:So what do you think is the determining moral factor? That's all I want to know.
I think it comes down to whether society has the right to compel a woman to go through childbirth. I actually think it's a little ridiculous that the moral question for either side comes down to the hypothetical question of "If this thing came out right this instant, what odds are we giving it to live?" There are very real practical differences between a first trimester fetus and a late second trimester one, but I find it hard to believe that people think this through and determine that there are stark differences in their value or the concrete morality of aborting them.

But apparently I'm wrong, because this is all hypothetical and legally there is that difference.

User avatar
G. Keenan
Sucking on the Rally Nipple
Posts: 23719
Joined: April 16 06, 6:03 pm
Location: Chicago

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by G. Keenan »

I'm of the opinion that while the fetus always has some moral rights, which increase as it grows, as long as it is inside an adult woman that woman has greater moral rights. Not to the extent that she should be able to abort a baby at 8 months because she decides she doesn't want it anymore, but if her life is at stake if the pregnancy continues then she should have the right to terminate the fetus and save her own life.

Online
User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30871
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by ghostrunner »

I'm generally pro-choice, but what kind of a scenario is there where actually aborting the baby in the last trimester is necessary vs. just delivering it alive via C-section?

Same question about partial birth abortion.


I'm genuinely asking, because I think neither one makes a whole lot of sense to the layperson. I think the suspicion is that doctors are fudging on the "life of the mother" thing out of some compassion for the mother who's emotionally pleading her case to get rid of it. That's definitely the perception with partial birth abortions. From what I've heard/read from impartial sources about the procedure, I can't see how it could ever be medically necessary to abort the fetus. I think the perception is that as soon as you start talking about these issues, pro-choice folks just throw up the "life of the mother" card to shut down discussion.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by Arthur Dent »

I'd be suspicious of any publication claiming to be impartial that uses the term "partial birth abortion".

planet planet
http://tinyurl.com/2e4x5hy
Posts: 24904
Joined: April 15 06, 6:25 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by planet planet »

cpebbles wrote:
thrill wrote:So what do you think is the determining moral factor? That's all I want to know.
I think it comes down to whether society has the right to compel a woman to go through childbirth. I actually think it's a little ridiculous that the moral question for either side comes down to the hypothetical question of "If this thing came out right this instant, what odds are we giving it to live?" There are very real practical differences between a first trimester fetus and a late second trimester one, but I find it hard to believe that people think this through and determine that there are stark differences in their value or the concrete morality of aborting them.

But apparently I'm wrong, because this is all hypothetical and legally there is that difference.
I think you nailed what should be the crux of the moral argument. Thrill, I'm curious as to what practical reasons you refer when you explain your pro-choice stance. I'm thinking they are if you make abortion illegal, do you get rid of the problem of black market abortions? When you compel a woman to go through child birth, how do you enforce that the woman doesn't take drugs or imbibe alcohol to the extreme? Once you compel the birth to term through legal means, how do you ensure responsible choices?

User avatar
cpebbles
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8829
Joined: August 30 07, 12:28 pm

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by cpebbles »

"Partial birth abortion" is the only procedure I know of which can be used to abort late-term pregnancies. It is obviously less intrusive than C-section, and from everything I've read it was only used in fetuses so profoundly deformed that a normal spontaneous vaginal delivery was not even an option for it to be compared to.

But once again we're considering what I would call an aesthetic question instead of the moral one, and now it's from an even more hypothetical scenario, because the procedure went from practically unused to totally unused back when it was made illegal.

Spider John
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 10952
Joined: May 18 06, 10:09 pm
Location: East of the middle of West Tennessee

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by Spider John »

Just to give an idea of some of the reasons behind later term abortions. This is from 1987, but I'm sure the reasons still apply today, if not the percentages:
In 1987, the Alan Guttmacher Institute collected questionnaires from 1,900 women in the United States who came to clinics to have abortions. Of the 1,900 questioned, 420 had been pregnant for 16 or more weeks. These 420 women were asked to choose among a list of reasons they had not obtained the abortions earlier in their pregnancies. The results were as follows:[3]

71% Woman didn't recognize she was pregnant or misjudged gestation
48% Woman found it hard to make arrangements for abortion
33% Woman was afraid to tell her partner or parents
24% Woman took time to decide to have an abortion
8% Woman waited for her relationship to change
8% Someone pressured woman not to have abortion
6% Something changed after woman became pregnant
6% Woman didn't know timing is important
5% Woman didn't know she could get an abortion
2% A fetal problem was diagnosed late in pregnancy
11% Other
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_term_abortion

Online
User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30871
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by ghostrunner »

Arthur Dent wrote:I'd be suspicious of any publication claiming to be impartial that uses the term "partial birth abortion".
It's usually in quotes, or "'so-called' partial birth abortion."


I respect that it's perhaps exceedingly rare, but I don't see why that means it shouldn't be addressed and maybe treated differently than an early term abortion. The fact that something is hypothetical doesn't mean it's not a valid question, particularly on a topic that is so important to a large part of the population. The law covers all sorts of seemingly odd contingencies.

And I'm still unclear why partially delivering the fetus and aborting is medically preferable to just delivering it alive. Every story I hear about this, they go into little detail about the medical issues involved, which is frustrating. If we're down to nothing but illegal procedures, what sort of late term abortions was this doctor performing?

Like thrill, I'm more or less apathetic on the issue. But I do get the feeling that for whatever reason, we never get in depth reporting on what these late term procedures are. The specific reporting I have heard on partial birth abortions (I don't know what else you should call it) states that the baby is delivered except for the head, which is then essentially destroyed. Is that an incomplete description? Whether or not the fetus is deformed, I don't get why that has any bearing on whether it needs to be aborted instead of simply removed alive. In any case, that's the first time I've heard anything about deformity being a reason for the procedure. Not suggesting it isn't the case, just pointing out that there's a huge lack of information on this that should be coming from the pro-choice side if they believe those procedures are reasonable.

I guess I could do more research on the issue. I'm just trying to explain the position of most people who aren't that familiar with the specifics. Opponents of late term abortions are glad to give you a description of what's involved, whereas people who want to keep the option don't want to say much of anything about the procedures or why they're necessary. It's easy to see why abortion opponents have more widespread support on these issues.

I could also flip the question back on those against only late term abortions and ask why a 6 month old fetus is more "valid" than one that's 3 months old.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by thrill »

ghostrunner wrote:I could also flip the question back on those against only late term abortions and ask why a 6 month old fetus is more "valid" than one that's 3 months old.
I've come from being a little kid who's mom dragged him to "Life Walks," aka anti-abortion protests, once or twice a year to being pro choice. The reason I've done that has nothing to do with how developed the fetus is, but I do see the validity in the concept. If my kid is a toddler, goes into a coma and the doctor tells me it's basically brain dead, I'm pulling the plug. I can see how terminating a fetus before it becomes developmentally advanced enough to have any semblance of consciousness or chance at viability is seen as more acceptable. It's an ugly thing though.
planet pujolsian wrote:Thrill, I'm curious as to what practical reasons you refer when you explain your pro-choice stance. I'm thinking they are if you make abortion illegal, do you get rid of the problem of black market abortions? When you compel a woman to go through child birth, how do you enforce that the woman doesn't take drugs or imbibe alcohol to the extreme? Once you compel the birth to term through legal means, how do you ensure responsible choices?
All of these as well as the fact that I think there are very valid reasons for abortion. Rape, incest or health concerns. Valid reasons, but I think if you legalize it for that, you can't draw the line there. It's such an extreme and polarizing subject that you really do need to either open the door all the way or close it all they way, and if you close it, you do so knowing that it's still going to happen in large numbers but it'll happen in an unregulated, ungoverned and dangerous setting. It's very much like the war on drugs.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31088
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: I disagree with abortion so I'm going to KILL SOMEONE!

Post by Popeye_Card »

thrill wrote: I've come from being a little kid who's mom dragged him to "Life Walks," aka anti-abortion protests, once or twice a year to being pro choice.
Ooo. Please tell me that you got to hold the sign that said, "I wouldn't be here if my mom aborted me."

Post Reply