Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who died

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Locked
Fat Strat
Official GRB Sponsor of Larry Bigbie
Posts: 28010
Joined: April 17 06, 9:16 pm
Location: No. 16 on the Cards Top 15 Prospect List

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by Fat Strat »

jim wrote:I was expecting an answer along the lines that we as humans we are flawed etc... and can't quite grasp what our faith tells us. Even in your story about the people in the hospital, so what? Friends/family - they will be fine. 50, 75 years here and then eternity in paradise. That's a constant amount of time over in infinite amount of time. And constant/infinity = 0. So even if it's really really bad here without you, no worries.

I know pure logic isn't a good fit for religious discussions, but you can kind of see where it just all breaks down from a logical point of view. I guess from a logical point of view the only thing that makes sense from a religious point of view is that nothing matters here. Just a quick entrance exam.
Well, yes and no. I do get what you're saying (at least I think I do) and you're right that your 75 years here are nothing compared to eternity in terms of time. But, I think viewing this life as a "quick entrance exam" takes away from the responsibilities that God has for us in this life and the character development that's part of it.

We are the living embodiment of God on earth. We're the tool that God has chosen to use to display his love, his salvation, his grace, his mercy, his compassion, his power, his truth (you get the idea) to the world. So, what we do in that 75 years (our constant) can have significantly large implications for how we and others experience the infinite # of years.

What's a scientific way of looking at this? Everything in the universe is made up of elements, which are made up of atoms, which are made up of subatomic particles, etc. If you were to change one part of that -- one atom or one particle -- at the right moment in the system, say 1 millisecond before the Big Bang, everything that happened after that for billions of billions of years across the entire universe would have changed.

Ok, so, my science is not so good, but do you see what I mean? Our 75 years has the significance to dramatically change the infinite # of years.

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by TimeForGuinness »

wart57 wrote:Te expect God to take care of everything is denying the free will he has given us. It is up to us to end the atrocities happening around the globe, but we are too damn busy only caring about our own little part of the world.
You bring up an interesting point.

It has always seemed like this "free will" comes with caveats. You can do whatever you want, unless it's something God told you not to do...then hell.

Now, I'm playing devil's advocate here (sorta pun intended), because I personally don't believe in the literal meaning of the Bible...or any other holy book for that matter...but a lot of people throw these terms around not realizing that they're contradicting each other. So I'll raise the point here, is "free will" really "free" from your perspective?
Last edited by TimeForGuinness on May 1 12, 1:29 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by lukethedrifter »

[/youtube]

Preacher man don't tell me
Heaven is under the earth
I know you don't know
What life is really worth
It's not all that glitters is gold
Half the story has never been told
So now you see the light
Stand up for your rights


---

Most people think
Great good will come from the skies
Take away everything
And make everybody feel high
But if you know what life is worth
You would look for yours on earth
And now you've seen the light
You stand up for your rights

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by TimeForGuinness »

wart57 wrote:Strat and Joe put it a it better than I did, but conveyed my thoughts as well. It is up to us to make the world a better place, that is why we were put here.
Can you define what "better" means to you? And why were we put here to make it better? We, as a species, have been around for a few hundred thousand years...a blip in time with respect to the Earth's age...so I'm confused as to your meaning of our species being here to "make the world a better place".

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by TimeForGuinness »

Joe Shlabotnik wrote:
IMADreamer wrote:
wart57 wrote:Te expect God to take care of everything is denying the free will he has given us. It is up to us to end the atrocities happening around the globe, but we are too damn busy only caring about our own little part of the world.

Oh so, God protected a suburban family form hail, but not some kid getting murdered in an African genocide? Got it. Hell even God's priorities are [expletive] up then.
I'm not blaming God for the choices I make. It sucks that children are being put into armies in Africa. Did God do that? No, other humans did that.

But I don't see God as an old guy with a beard either. God, to me is the unexplainable force that drives the whole universe. For some reason we humans have a need to know. We strive to understand everything around us. It separates us from the other creatures here. Why? Damned if I know and I think damned if anyone will EVER know. I think we were put here to strive to better ourselves and our world. And adversities are part of the existence gig. I think there is truth to "whatever doesn't kill you (can) make you stronger. And I think that striving and the way we handle our successes and our failures prepare us for whatever is after our time here. Why? Damned if I know. But I think that's the way it is. At least that helps me to live my life the way I feel it should be lived.
How do we know it separates us from other creatures? We were put here to better ourselves? What does this mean? So is the whole point of existence a test to see if we can get it right (whatever "right" means)? If so, we, as a species, are doing a piss-poor job of it.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

TimeForGuinness wrote:
wart57 wrote:Te expect God to take care of everything is denying the free will he has given us. It is up to us to end the atrocities happening around the globe, but we are too damn busy only caring about our own little part of the world.
You bring up an interesting point.

It has always seemed like this "free will" comes with caveats. You can do whatever you want, unless it's something God told you not to do...then hell.

Now, I'm playing devil's advocate here (sorta pun intended), because I personally don't believe in the literal meaning of the Bible...or any other holy book for that matter...but a lot of people throw these terms around not realizing that they're contradicting each other. So I'll raise the point here, is "free will" really free from your religious perspective?
tHIS Doesn't answer your question, but I'll add on to it. And, I'll say this is why I have trouble accepting any religous explanation regarding a loving god.

You have to believe God either has a plan for you or you believe he has given humans the power of free will and do whatever they want.

If you believe God has a plan for everyone, then I simply don't see how you can get past the things that people like dreamer bring up (why is God ignoring the genocide and children and sex trafficking etc).

If you don't believe he has a plan and you and I are creating our own lives making imperfect decisions in an imperfect world because we are imperfect, then why do people pray for X,Y or Z? If God truly does exist and truly doesn't care what we do, why waste your time asking him for a winning lottery ticket?

So, following this path, you either come to the conclusion that he either does care and does intervene which brings you back to the points Dreamer brings up and God being a real a-hole or he doesn't care....in which case your entire religion just doesn't work because it's based on an all knowing all loving all powerful God....that oh by the way doesn't care.

Fat Strat
Official GRB Sponsor of Larry Bigbie
Posts: 28010
Joined: April 17 06, 9:16 pm
Location: No. 16 on the Cards Top 15 Prospect List

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by Fat Strat »

TimeForGuinness wrote:It has always seemed like this "free will" comes with caveats. You can do whatever you want, unless it's something God told you not to do...then hell... So I'll raise the point here, is "free will" really free from your religious perspective?
I think that first part is something of an oversimplification. We are all going to do things that God told us not to do -- both those who are "saved" and those who are "damned". What matters more than the individual act of one sin is the greater exercise of our free will to choose God... in our hearts, do we choose to desire to do God's will, even though we fall short? Or do we choose to desire our own will, regardless of what God says about the issue?

Here are your definitions...
FREE WILL -- God gives us the freedom to choose to accept God's will as more important than our will.
OR
FREE WILL -- the freedom to choose to accept our will as more important than God's.

In that choosing, God gives us what we've asked for. Eternity where his will reigns -- we've chosen him. Or eternity where his will does not reign -- we've chosen ourselves. Now, that might be an oversimplification of what we call heaven and hell, but it's probably the right way to look at it in terms of a "free will" conversation.

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by TimeForGuinness »

Fat Strat wrote:
TimeForGuinness wrote:It has always seemed like this "free will" comes with caveats. You can do whatever you want, unless it's something God told you not to do...then hell... So I'll raise the point here, is "free will" really free from your religious perspective?
I think that first part is something of an oversimplification. We are all going to do things that God told us not to do -- both those who are "saved" and those who are "damned". What matters more than the individual act of one sin is the greater exercise of our free will to choose God... in our hearts, do we choose to desire to do God's will, even though we fall short? Or do we choose to desire our own will, regardless of what God says about the issue?

In some ways, free will is that God gives us the freedom to choose to accept God's will as more important than our will. And free will is the freedom to choose to accept our will as more important than God's.

In that choosing, God gives us what we've asked for. Eternity where his will reigns. Or eternity where his will does not reign. Now, that might be an oversimplification of what we call heaven and hell, but it's probably the right way to look at it in terms of a "free will" conversation.
Do you believe that God is all-knowing and all-powerful? If so, how do you feel that conflicts or compliments the topic of "free will".

User avatar
IMADreamer
Has an anecdote about a townie he overheard.
Posts: 12911
Joined: December 6 10, 1:09 am
Location: Illinois

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by IMADreamer »

My problem with the free will side of things and the idea that was brought up that we choose our lives or to live in God's image or whatever is that many people don't have a choice. They are born into [expletive] and will always live in it. Some kid in some village in Africa has no choice at all but to live an existence that may take him on a path to slaughter. So that brings me back to God simply not caring about his creations. He clearly can't. There is no way possible that he can love the poor African kid who will starve his whole life until some warlord comes in and slaughters his village as much as he loves Mitt Romney who has never wanted for a damn thing in his whole life. We don't even have to use Mittens though, there is no way you can argue that the kid in Africa got anything remotely close to the fair shake that I got in life.

BTW I'm not saying any of this to be argumentative. I'm saying it because I want to know. I need to know, because I can not reconcile this stuff in my head.

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by TimeForGuinness »

Fat Strat wrote:
TimeForGuinness wrote:It has always seemed like this "free will" comes with caveats. You can do whatever you want, unless it's something God told you not to do...then hell... So I'll raise the point here, is "free will" really free from your religious perspective?
I think that first part is something of an oversimplification. We are all going to do things that God told us not to do -- both those who are "saved" and those who are "damned". What matters more than the individual act of one sin is the greater exercise of our free will to choose God... in our hearts, do we choose to desire to do God's will, even though we fall short? Or do we choose to desire our own will, regardless of what God says about the issue?

Here are your definitions...
FREE WILL -- God gives us the freedom to choose to accept God's will as more important than our will.
OR
FREE WILL -- the freedom to choose to accept our will as more important than God's.

In that choosing, God gives us what we've asked for. Eternity where his will reigns -- we've chosen him. Or eternity where his will does not reign -- we've chosen ourselves. Now, that might be an oversimplification of what we call heaven and hell, but it's probably the right way to look at it in terms of a "free will" conversation.
What is your definition of God's will, aren't there many different interpretations of it? Is it clearly black and white to you...or is it shades of gray? If people refuse to do your version of God's will, how do you view them?

If there are many different interpretations of God's will, then is it clearly defined? If it isn't clearly defined, then why choose to follow?

I find this topic fascinating, I know no answers, but my outlook is completely different from fats/warts/Joes...and yet, if viewed from 50,000 feet, we'd all be viewed as pretty good people (I think). So why do all the details matter?
Last edited by TimeForGuinness on May 1 12, 1:55 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Locked