Derrick Rose

A forum for non-baseball sports
Post Reply
User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by thrill »

Popeye_Card wrote:EDIT: And NBA players don't have to go to college. They just have to wait a year after high school graduation and turn 19. They can play overseas. They can twiddle their thumbs for a year. They can play XBox. Whatever they want. But college is probably a good way to boost your draft stock (and probably make a few bucks if you play for Calipari).
Yeah, I'm guessing Calipari pays similar to Besiktas or Locomotiv Moscow. All without being an 18 year old kid from one of the worst, most culturally insulated (trying to find a non-racist sounding way to describe cultural ignorance due to poverty) neighborhoods in America having to find himself in an alien environment.

The biggest reason for a kid like Derrick to go to a Memphis type school is future endorsements. Brandon Jennings and D Rose had similar profiles coming out of HS, but Jennings spent a year in Italy and Derrick made a run to the National Championship. I'm betting Derrick's endorsement opportunities were better than Jennings when they declared for the draft just as a result of having a higher profile in the States.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by lukethedrifter »

Popeye_Card wrote:
Spider John wrote:
It's a ridiculous system. Nobody makes a golfer, a tennis player or a computer programmer go to school. But people who dunk basketballs can't survive without college. The idea is laughable on its face. .
http://www.commercialappeal.com/news/20 ... lebration/
Um, what? Clearly this guy hasn't heard of PGA Q school, or is aware that most white collar professions on this planet require college degrees. That paragraph is laughable on its face.
I am having a hard time seeing what you find so ludicrous. Baseball players do not have to go to Okie State or Georgia Tech to play MLB.

I can't tell if you are kidding about Q school or not. I hope you were.

Spider John
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 10952
Joined: May 18 06, 10:09 pm
Location: East of the middle of West Tennessee

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by Spider John »

Popeye_Card wrote:
bobby bo wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:
Spider John wrote:
It's a ridiculous system. Nobody makes a golfer, a tennis player or a computer programmer go to school. But people who dunk basketballs can't survive without college. The idea is laughable on its face. .
http://www.commercialappeal.com/news/20 ... lebration/
Um, what? Clearly this guy hasn't heard of PGA Q school, or is aware that most white collar professions on this planet require college degrees. That paragraph is laughable on its face.
You misunderstood. He's saying that you don't make people fill requirements that have nothing to do with their field. To be a pro golfer etc, you don't have to go to college. Just like you don't make an engineer play at least one year of organized basketball before they can make a paycheck engineering things.
Oh, I understood. His point is still pretty dumb. MLB has a requirement that you have to be at least 18 years old to be drafted. Being born 18 years ago has nothing to do with being able to play professional baseball.

EDIT: And NBA players don't have to go to college. They just have to wait a year after high school graduation and turn 19. They can play overseas. They can twiddle their thumbs for a year. They can play XBox. Whatever they want. But college is probably a good way to boost your draft stock (and probably make a few bucks if you play for Calipari).
Regardless what they do with that year, it still remains that they can't go straight to the NBA, which is the point the columnist is making.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by thrill »

Spider John wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:
bobby bo wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:
Spider John wrote:
It's a ridiculous system. Nobody makes a golfer, a tennis player or a computer programmer go to school. But people who dunk basketballs can't survive without college. The idea is laughable on its face. .
http://www.commercialappeal.com/news/20 ... lebration/
Um, what? Clearly this guy hasn't heard of PGA Q school, or is aware that most white collar professions on this planet require college degrees. That paragraph is laughable on its face.
You misunderstood. He's saying that you don't make people fill requirements that have nothing to do with their field. To be a pro golfer etc, you don't have to go to college. Just like you don't make an engineer play at least one year of organized basketball before they can make a paycheck engineering things.
Oh, I understood. His point is still pretty dumb. MLB has a requirement that you have to be at least 18 years old to be drafted. Being born 18 years ago has nothing to do with being able to play professional baseball.

EDIT: And NBA players don't have to go to college. They just have to wait a year after high school graduation and turn 19. They can play overseas. They can twiddle their thumbs for a year. They can play XBox. Whatever they want. But college is probably a good way to boost your draft stock (and probably make a few bucks if you play for Calipari).
Regardless what they do with that year, it still remains that they can't go straight to the NBA, which is the point the columnist is making.
And it's a greedy, dumb rule made to make sure that companies like Nike and Adidas make hundreds of millions of dollars on NCAA Basketball gear.

User avatar
cardsfansince82
is shooing asian children away from his fridge.
Posts: 27776
Joined: May 17 06, 10:23 pm
Location: at the gettin' place

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by cardsfansince82 »

bobby bo wrote:
Spider John wrote:Regardless what they do with that year, it still remains that they can't go straight to the NBA, which is the point the columnist is making.
And it's a greedy, dumb rule made to make sure that companies like Nike and Adidas make hundreds of millions of dollars on NCAA Basketball gear.
Am I missing something here? What does David Stern care about any of that? The NBA made the rule to protect the quality of their own product. It was getting to where 10 kids a year were told they were good enough to make it. Only 1-2 of them were actually worth drafting that early in their career. Now they have to go prove themselves for at least a year in college. Some of them flameout or get exposed, some of them make it. If you can't make it in college you would be a trainwreck as a pro anyway. It has raised the caliber of both the college game and the pro game. I love the rule as a fan of both.
Last edited by cardsfansince82 on January 16 12, 2:23 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31097
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by Popeye_Card »

bobby bo wrote:
Spider John wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:
bobby bo wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:
Spider John wrote:
It's a ridiculous system. Nobody makes a golfer, a tennis player or a computer programmer go to school. But people who dunk basketballs can't survive without college. The idea is laughable on its face. .
http://www.commercialappeal.com/news/20 ... lebration/
Um, what? Clearly this guy hasn't heard of PGA Q school, or is aware that most white collar professions on this planet require college degrees. That paragraph is laughable on its face.
You misunderstood. He's saying that you don't make people fill requirements that have nothing to do with their field. To be a pro golfer etc, you don't have to go to college. Just like you don't make an engineer play at least one year of organized basketball before they can make a paycheck engineering things.
Oh, I understood. His point is still pretty dumb. MLB has a requirement that you have to be at least 18 years old to be drafted. Being born 18 years ago has nothing to do with being able to play professional baseball.

EDIT: And NBA players don't have to go to college. They just have to wait a year after high school graduation and turn 19. They can play overseas. They can twiddle their thumbs for a year. They can play XBox. Whatever they want. But college is probably a good way to boost your draft stock (and probably make a few bucks if you play for Calipari).
Regardless what they do with that year, it still remains that they can't go straight to the NBA, which is the point the columnist is making.
And it's a greedy, dumb rule made to make sure that companies like Nike and Adidas make hundreds of millions of dollars on NCAA Basketball gear.
At it's core it is an age requirement. No different than MLB and the NHL's age 18 requirement, only that it's 19 instead. Yes, it was directed at pointing more kids towards college (yes, with a money grab in mind), in an effort to not have so many kids jumping straight into the pros at such a young age. Hardly any 18 year old kids start in MLB because of the minors. There's a few in the NHL, but most go back to juniors, college, or the AHL.

The argument he made was dumb. "The idea is laughable on its face." No it isn't. Every job in this country has its requirements. The NBA's requirements are now 19 years old and a year out of high school. Sorry we are so oppresive to them that most get a free year of education (ha) in the meantime.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by thrill »

Popeye_Card wrote:The argument he made was dumb. "The idea is laughable on its face." No it isn't. Every job in this country has its requirements. The NBA's requirements are now 19 years old and a year out of high school. Sorry we are so oppresive to them that most get a free year of education (ha) in the meantime.
The rule makes a joke out of the concept of the "student athlete" by forcing young men who have no intentions to become a dedicated student to pretend they are, ties up a scholarship that might otherwise go to a different player who would value the free education and make the most of it, prevents an adult from pursuing their chosen profession that they have the skills and training to perform at a professional level, fosters a culture of scofflaws and puts programs that abide by the rules at a competitive disadvantage.

It is, for many reasons, an idea that is laughable.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31097
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by Popeye_Card »

bobby bo wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:The argument he made was dumb. "The idea is laughable on its face." No it isn't. Every job in this country has its requirements. The NBA's requirements are now 19 years old and a year out of high school. Sorry we are so oppresive to them that most get a free year of education (ha) in the meantime.
The rule makes a joke out of the concept of the "student athlete" by forcing young men who have no intentions to become a dedicated student to pretend they are, ties up a scholarship that might otherwise go to a different player who would value the free education and make the most of it, prevents an adult from pursuing their chosen profession that they have the skills and training to perform at a professional level, fosters a culture of scofflaws and puts programs that abide by the rules at a competitive disadvantage.

It is, for many reasons, an idea that is laughable.
There is a very small minority of Div 1 athletes in football and basketball who are there for any sort of educational gain. I guess there's a chance that the 2 kids who are actually good enough to jump to the NBA level at 18 could gobble up one of the scholarships that one of the 12 kids who actually want an education could have used.

I think I could have gone pro in my chosen profession at 18. But there were requirements. I could have graduated college without a lot of the useless courses I took. But there were requirements. I could have done on-the-job training with my current employer and been much more efficient (both for me and them) in lieu of college. But my chosen profession, just like all chosen professions, have requirements. Some more valid than others.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by thrill »

Popeye_Card wrote:
bobby bo wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:The argument he made was dumb. "The idea is laughable on its face." No it isn't. Every job in this country has its requirements. The NBA's requirements are now 19 years old and a year out of high school. Sorry we are so oppresive to them that most get a free year of education (ha) in the meantime.
The rule makes a joke out of the concept of the "student athlete" by forcing young men who have no intentions to become a dedicated student to pretend they are, ties up a scholarship that might otherwise go to a different player who would value the free education and make the most of it, prevents an adult from pursuing their chosen profession that they have the skills and training to perform at a professional level, fosters a culture of scofflaws and puts programs that abide by the rules at a competitive disadvantage.

It is, for many reasons, an idea that is laughable.
There is a very small minority of Div 1 athletes in football and basketball who are there for any sort of educational gain. I guess there's a chance that the 2 kids who are actually good enough to jump to the NBA level at 18 could gobble up one of the scholarships that one of the 12 kids who actually want an education could have used.

I think I could have gone pro in my chosen profession at 18. But there were requirements. I could have graduated college without a lot of the useless courses I took. But there were requirements. I could have done on-the-job training with my current employer and been much more efficient (both for me and them) in lieu of college. But my chosen profession, just like all chosen professions, have requirements. Some more valid than others.
Your argument is essentially, "It is what it is, so don't change a bad rule, also, jocks don't care about school anyway."

Come on.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31097
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by Popeye_Card »

bobby bo wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:
bobby bo wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:The argument he made was dumb. "The idea is laughable on its face." No it isn't. Every job in this country has its requirements. The NBA's requirements are now 19 years old and a year out of high school. Sorry we are so oppresive to them that most get a free year of education (ha) in the meantime.
The rule makes a joke out of the concept of the "student athlete" by forcing young men who have no intentions to become a dedicated student to pretend they are, ties up a scholarship that might otherwise go to a different player who would value the free education and make the most of it, prevents an adult from pursuing their chosen profession that they have the skills and training to perform at a professional level, fosters a culture of scofflaws and puts programs that abide by the rules at a competitive disadvantage.

It is, for many reasons, an idea that is laughable.
There is a very small minority of Div 1 athletes in football and basketball who are there for any sort of educational gain. I guess there's a chance that the 2 kids who are actually good enough to jump to the NBA level at 18 could gobble up one of the scholarships that one of the 12 kids who actually want an education could have used.

I think I could have gone pro in my chosen profession at 18. But there were requirements. I could have graduated college without a lot of the useless courses I took. But there were requirements. I could have done on-the-job training with my current employer and been much more efficient (both for me and them) in lieu of college. But my chosen profession, just like all chosen professions, have requirements. Some more valid than others.
Your argument is essentially, "It is what it is, so don't change a bad rule, also, jocks don't care about school anyway."

Come on.
I don't think it is that bad of rule.

My point was that his paragraph was silly.
1.) All jobs have requirements.
2.) Going to college isn't even a requirement. Being 19 is.

His argument was basically that if you're good at basketball, then you should be able to play in the NBA whenever you choose. Life doesn't work that way for most professions. The NBA isn't really different in that regard.

Post Reply