You know, after seeing all the replays over and over again, if NE would have had a time out left, they may have won a challenge and gotten the first down. It really looked like his foot came down with possession with a first down but was immediately driven backwards.Popeye_Card wrote:Honestly, I think Bill B. made the right percentage move. Pats have something like 76% success rate in the Brady Era on 4th and 2 or shorter. You are giving yourself an excellent chance of winning the game.
The alternative is stopping Peyton Manning in a 70-ish yard 2 minute drill. Do you have a greater than 76% chance of doing that? I don't think so. Even by going for it, you are giving your D a chance to win the game if they can stop them. They didn't.
Good call, IMO. Just didn't quite execute.
NFL WEEK 10
- Swingingbunt
- All-Star
- Posts: 2904
- Joined: April 4 08, 9:49 am
- Location: Indianapolis
Re: NFL WEEK 10
- skmsw
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 6340
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:12 pm
- Location: The Hub
Re: NFL WEEK 10
Yeah, I was going to point that out too . . . he did bobble the ball, but had control of it with both feet down before being pushed forward . . . should have been forward progress and a first down.Swingingbunt wrote:You know, after seeing all the replays over and over again, if NE would have had a time out left, they may have won a challenge and gotten the first down. It really looked like his foot came down with possession with a first down but was immediately driven backwards.Popeye_Card wrote:Honestly, I think Bill B. made the right percentage move. Pats have something like 76% success rate in the Brady Era on 4th and 2 or shorter. You are giving yourself an excellent chance of winning the game.
The alternative is stopping Peyton Manning in a 70-ish yard 2 minute drill. Do you have a greater than 76% chance of doing that? I don't think so. Even by going for it, you are giving your D a chance to win the game if they can stop them. They didn't.
Good call, IMO. Just didn't quite execute.
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31100
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: NFL WEEK 10
Freed, I go the opposite way in a game where a field goal loses it. If that is the case, you punt and hope to hold rather than give them the ball in field goal range.
It is two yards. If you can't gain those 2 yards in fear that the other team could move the ball 30, then you don't deserve to win. People are way too big of pussies in football on 4th down, all for 40 yards of field position.
It is two yards. If you can't gain those 2 yards in fear that the other team could move the ball 30, then you don't deserve to win. People are way too big of pussies in football on 4th down, all for 40 yards of field position.
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31100
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: NFL WEEK 10
Note that I hate the Pats and I am glad they lost. I just don't agree with conventional football wisdom, when that wisdom is not even close to being backed up by odds.
-
Freed Roger
- Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
- Posts: 26073
- Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
- Location: St. Louis
Re: NFL WEEK 10
Not sure how conclusive the pics were on the first down question. probably too close to overturn the call on the field.Popeye_Card wrote:Freed, I go the opposite way in a game where a field goal loses it. If that is the case, you punt and hope to hold rather than give them the ball in field goal range.
It is two yards. If you can't gain those 2 yards in fear that the other team could move the ball 30, then you don't deserve to win. People are way too big of pussies in football on 4th down, all for 40 yards of field position.
I like aggressive coaching, and going for it on 4td down when the time is ripe, and not a big fan of settling for field goals either...-but 2 yards is a big diff from 1 yard. 1 yard you can get a number of ways, 2 is pretty much a quick pass into traffic. lots of 2 point conversions don't get made if you notice.
What is too [expletive] is conceding that you can't stop Manning from going 70 yards, when you had decent success doing it all game. 40 yards of field position is a lot considering Colts had only 1 TOL? Dungy didn't mince words, he said to effect you have to at least force Manning to make some plays.
Yeah there's a decent chance Manning still would have scored, but as La Genius says, thats when you tip your cap...
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31100
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: NFL WEEK 10
Let's say I give you the option of putting a ball from 5 feet away for $100, and if you miss I get to putt in your miss from 2 feet. Or, I get to putt from 10 feet and you don't get a chance to putt in my miss. Which would you choose?
Me, I want to control my destiny. I putt from 5.
Me, I want to control my destiny. I putt from 5.
- TheoSqua
- Next Gen Wart
- Posts: 8951
- Joined: April 22 06, 6:53 pm
- Location: St. Louis
- Contact:
Re: NFL WEEK 10
Manning had 2+ minutes, 3 time outs, and the 2 minute warning. I'd have gone for it too.
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: NFL WEEK 10
Yeah but you wanted to draft Rey Mauuuulaaaguaau with the first pick.Popeye_Card wrote:Let's say I give you the option of putting a ball from 5 feet away for $100, and if you miss I get to putt in your miss from 2 feet. Or, I get to putt from 10 feet and you don't get a chance to putt in my miss. Which would you choose?
Me, I want to control my destiny. I putt from 5.
- skmsw
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 6340
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:12 pm
- Location: The Hub
Re: NFL WEEK 10
I thought that the replay from the front showed pretty clearly that he caught the ball, bobbled it, and grabbed ahold with both feet on the ground -- THEN was shoved forward, already having gotten control of the ball. From the back it was inconclusive, but from the front it was pretty clear he had the first down.Freed Roger wrote:Not sure how conclusive the pics were on the first down question. probably too close to overturn the call on the field.
I have a hard time calling it "decent success" up to that point. In the fourth quarter alone, the colts got the ball on their own 21, and scored a touchdown in 5 plays and 2:04; then, got the ball on their own 20 and scored in 6 plays and 1:49. That's after a first quarter in which they scored touchdowns of 90 yards in 3:28 and 80 yards in 3:02. Sure, throughout the game there were a handful of punts and a turnover or two, but it was Manning we're talking about -- a quick-strike quarterback who already had half a dozen big pass plays.What is too [expletive] is conceding that you can't stop Manning from going 70 yards, when you had decent success doing it all game.
If Coach looked at his defense, looked at the adjustments Manning made in the 4th quarter to shred it, and decided that his chances were better of converting the 4th-and-2 with his offense than they were of preventing Manning from using half a dozen plays to make a fifth trip down the field --- I don't think I can fault it.
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: NFL WEEK 10
You also need to take into consideration that teams play offense differently when they basically have nothing to lose.skmsw wrote:I thought that the replay from the front showed pretty clearly that he caught the ball, bobbled it, and grabbed ahold with both feet on the ground -- THEN was shoved forward, already having gotten control of the ball. From the back it was inconclusive, but from the front it was pretty clear he had the first down.Freed Roger wrote:Not sure how conclusive the pics were on the first down question. probably too close to overturn the call on the field.
I have a hard time calling it "decent success" up to that point. In the fourth quarter alone, the colts got the ball on their own 21, and scored a touchdown in 5 plays and 2:04; then, got the ball on their own 20 and scored in 6 plays and 1:49. That's after a first quarter in which they scored touchdowns of 90 yards in 3:28 and 80 yards in 3:02. Sure, throughout the game there were a handful of punts and a turnover or two, but it was Manning we're talking about -- a quick-strike quarterback who already had half a dozen big pass plays.What is too [expletive] is conceding that you can't stop Manning from going 70 yards, when you had decent success doing it all game.
If Coach looked at his defense, looked at the adjustments Manning made in the 4th quarter to shred it, and decided that his chances were better of converting the 4th-and-2 with his offense than they were of preventing Manning from using half a dozen plays to make a fifth trip down the field --- I don't think I can fault it.


