Plagiarism

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: Plagiarism

Post by cards2468 »

sighyoung wrote: The college office will keep a file on her until graduation. In some schools, one instance will get you kicked out. At mine, two instances and she's gone.

At least the dean's office has my back. A lot of faculty don't even bother to report it. I hope she learns something from it, besides plagiarizing more subtly. At the very least, I shouldn't ever see her again, which makes it worthwhile. She'll also tell her friends not to take my classes, which thins out the riff-raff a bit. It may make my classes a bit smaller. Sometimes it's good to have the reputation of a jerk, even though I'm not one.

Finally, like I've said, this student is arrogant and spoiled, and really, really bad news. I don't want anyone like that teaching anyone's children. I wish she would find something else to do for a living.
I had a professor who was tough as nails. Easily the hardest class I took was with him, but I learned a lot and worked my ass off. He and I are really good friends now and talk almost daily. He tells me about some of the [expletive] he sees students do and he said he won't bend at all for them. I told him I hope he never loosens up, because when he weeds out trash and makes people work for their grades, he keeps the value of my degree up. I think professors owe it to their past students to make sure trash doesn't devalue their degrees.

User avatar
JackofDiamonds
Bringer of Boston Baked Blue Balls
Posts: 15010
Joined: April 16 06, 9:15 pm

Re: Plagiarism

Post by JackofDiamonds »

So my gf was just accused of "flirting with plagiarism" for a paragraph in a paper from a professor at UChicago. The section under question is only a few sentences long out of a 20 page paper, but the professor is accusing her of paraphrasing a section of an article by the professor. The GF is mortified, never has/never would intentionally plagiarize, and doesn't know what to do.

Caveat 1) She still received a B+ in the class
Caveat 2) She had the same professor last semester and earned an A in that class
Caveat 3) She felt that this was the best work she'd done all year and was expecting an A in the class and was going to ask the professor for a letter of recommendation for PhD admissions.
Caveat 4) The B+/plagiarism issue pretty much ends the PhD option (she was looking Harvard/Yale/Princeton/UChicago) and life as she was planning is possibly ruined


She wants to meet with the professor to talk and:
1) Apologize for confusion about her (professor's) article and reiterate that she would have never knowingly plagiarized and did not use the article to write the paper.
2) Say that she's concerned about the grade and that she know's this is graduate school but would like to give her another draft with a replacement paragraph, and even if she isn't willing to consider her grade, the GF would still like to share another draft with her.

Does that seem out of line? This was a professor, who a few hours ago, the GF was going to ask to be on her dissertation committee.

Advice?
Last edited by JackofDiamonds on June 14 11, 2:26 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Jocephus
99% conan clips
Posts: 64992
Joined: April 18 06, 5:14 pm

Re: Plagiarism

Post by Jocephus »

sleep with the professor

User avatar
JackofDiamonds
Bringer of Boston Baked Blue Balls
Posts: 15010
Joined: April 16 06, 9:15 pm

Re: Plagiarism

Post by JackofDiamonds »

Jocephus wrote:sleep with the professor
I don't think I'll get there in time.

Online
User avatar
cardinalkarp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 18750
Joined: May 4 06, 8:44 am

Re: Plagiarism

Post by cardinalkarp »

with the hope she's into some girl on girl action??

In all honesty it really sounds like your GF should speak w/ the professor. If she was looking to get a recommendation from her & this is the second class she's had w/ her I'm assuming she's built some type of relationship w/ her.

I would hope once you get to that level of your educational process & is looking to get in a top notch school like you stated I would hope there is enough respect between the student/teacher that they can sit down and talk about an issue like this. It sounds as if your GF feels the grade she received could possibly keep her from fulfilling her life dreams. If I were in her position there's no way I could just stay quiet, especially if I didn't intentionally try to plagiarize anything & especially when it sounds like she's been an exceptional student up to this point. It's almost weird the teacher wouldn't have spoken to her in private about the situation when she was in question about the plagiarism.

User avatar
sighyoung
Mayor of GRB
Posts: 38643
Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
Location: Louisville

Re: Plagiarism

Post by sighyoung »

JackofDiamonds wrote:
She wants to meet with the professor to talk and:
1) Apologize for confusion about her (professor's) article and reiterate that she would have never knowingly plagiarized and did not use the article to write the paper.
2) Say that she's concerned about the grade and that she know's this is graduate school but would like to give her another draft with a replacement paragraph, and even if she isn't willing to consider her grade, the GF would still like to share another draft with her.

Does that seem out of line? This was a professor, who a few hours ago, the GF was going to ask to be on her dissertation committee.

Advice?
Two major points. First, she should definitely speak with the professor about the problem and ask for clarification. She should definitely come prepared with the materials she did use for the paper. In this instance, it's not a case of passing someone's words off as her own, but a concern that she needed to properly cite the professor's ideas. Did some of this come from a lecture she gave? If so, she might explain that, and figure out how to cite the ideas in the paper--they may have seemed like common knowledge.

Second point--a B+ doesn't kill off anyone's chances to get in grad school. She's not in bad shape there at all, so she shouldn't even worry about it. In fact, the professor may simply be emphasizing that, say, ideas in a lecture should also be properly cited. She's being a stickler, not necessarily an accuser of malfeasance. Nobody would throw a book at someone for what she MAY have done, but scholars would rigorously insist on proper attribution.

The letter of recommendation, however, may be a problem. She should ask if the professor would still feel comfortable with writing her a letter. I suspect that things aren't as bad as they seem. I really don't.
Last edited by sighyoung on June 14 11, 7:04 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
sighyoung
Mayor of GRB
Posts: 38643
Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
Location: Louisville

Re: Plagiarism

Post by sighyoung »

Oh--two more things that I thought about.

1) Is she a Master's student or undergraduate? As a grad student, she might have been expected to know about the article--in which case, she still needs to be humble, and acknowledge that she should have and will consult the article.

2) A B+ for a grad class isn't great, but again, it's not career ending by any stretch. Not at all. She should move forward with her plans. At the same time, yeah, she should think about whether or not she wants to work with the professor in the future. But that's the future, right?

I really think this will be in her rear-view mirror sooner rather than later.

User avatar
JackofDiamonds
Bringer of Boston Baked Blue Balls
Posts: 15010
Joined: April 16 06, 9:15 pm

Re: Plagiarism

Post by JackofDiamonds »

1) Thanks for responding, I gave similar advice but it's good to hear it from insiders.
2) She's a grad student, this was her last non-dissertation grade.
3) She sent the professor an e-mail requesting to meet and discuss the situation. She's in shock right now, but I am with you guys that: with good intentions, a reputation for being an engaged student with academic integrity, and an existing relationship with the professor - this can be resolved positively.

User avatar
G. Keenan
Sucking on the Rally Nipple
Posts: 23719
Joined: April 16 06, 6:03 pm
Location: Chicago

Re: Plagiarism

Post by G. Keenan »

Is your girlfriend in MAPH or MAPSS?

User avatar
AdmiralKird
MBA, CPA, CFA, CFP, JD, PE, MD
Posts: 10179
Joined: March 7 07, 4:50 pm
Location: Tycho Crater, Luna

Re: Plagiarism

Post by AdmiralKird »

Any chance you can get an excerpt from the paper and the section of the journal she supposedly plagiarized? It's hard to help formulate any defense when we haven't seen the evidence for the allegations.

My best blind argument is it would be really incredibly stupid for a grad student to knowingly plagiarize their own professor. So outstandingly dumb that it wouldn't make sense, especially someone with her proximity to the teacher. If your intention is to plagiarize you do it from a relatively obscure article with a little known writer.

Post Reply