Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who died

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Locked
Fat Strat
Official GRB Sponsor of Larry Bigbie
Posts: 28010
Joined: April 17 06, 9:16 pm
Location: No. 16 on the Cards Top 15 Prospect List

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by Fat Strat »

IMADreamer wrote:There is no way possible that he can love the poor African kid who will starve his whole life until some warlord comes in and slaughters his village as much as he loves Mitt Romney who has never wanted for a damn thing in his whole life. We don't even have to use Mittens though, there is no way you can argue that the kid in Africa got anything remotely close to the fair shake that I got in life.
OK, I think I get what you're saying and you're certainly not alone in thinking this way. I'm going to have to try to answer you in a couple different ways.

First, I've been around a little and been with some people -- both here in the states and overseas -- where there was significant suffering. Not exactly the the extremes that you're mentioning, but not like the relative wealth that all of us have around here. Their way of life was awful by our standards and they had little hope of escaping it. These people that I've met in these situations have a kind of faith that puts me to shame.

It kind of goes back to what Jim was saying. These people don't spend any time wondering why they're stuck in what we would consider squalor. They're living the best they can and giving everything they have to God and looking forward to the next life. Rather than being envious of our lives (and bitter because of their lot in life) they have a kind of faith that puts just about every American Christian that I've ever met -- including myself -- to shame. Seriously, I'm a Christian pastor and I'm literally embarrassed by my level of faith compared to what Ive seen from the average church-goer overseas. The American church should be embarrassed by their faith and the consumerist lives that they live.


Second, I try not to give you guys cheesy Sunday School answers, but here one fits. How can a loving God allow his people to suffer? That's the question, right? From a Christian point of view, God doesn't ask us to go through anything that he himself did not experience. Christians believe that God actually took human form. He came to this world and lived in it -- in poverty, in squalor. He went to one of the smallest, poorest nations in the world -- Israel. He was born and lived in one of the most impoverished and backwater parts of that small poor nation -- Nazareth. He came at a time when all the world was under the boot of the most tyrannical empires in the history of the world -- Rome. God came and lived and experienced the worst that this world has to offer. He tried to spread hope, love, healing, truth and life but he was violently rejected by his own people. He was called a liar and a heretic. He performed miracles and was accused of consorting with demons. On several occasions people from his own religion tried to stone him to death. Then, though completely innocent of any crime, he was found guilty of the worst crimes -- heresy and treason. He was beaten within an inch of his life. He was hung up on a cross to be executed in one of the most brutal and barbaric fashions that man has ever invented.

Christians believe that Jesus was the son of God. He was completely God who came and took the form of a man -- fully a man at the same time that he was fully God. How could a loving God allow his people to suffer? Well, God himself came down here on this earth and experienced first hand all the suffering that any person could ever endure. How could a loving God send his own son to suffer worse than what we will suffer?

Christians believe that God gets it. He understands and empathizes with our suffering in ways that many people cannot. He bore the brunt of that suffering so that we would have way to escape that suffering ourselves.

Cheesy Sunday School answer, I know. But, suffering is just part of the deal. It's the result of our ready willingness to live for ourselves rather than to live for God. But, it does not mean God has given up on us. Far from it! Instead, he's taken it all on himself to give us the hope for a better future in the life to come.

User avatar
wart57
just can't quit you.
Posts: 25076
Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
Location: Lost

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by wart57 »

There comes a point in every Parents life when they have to let the kids go off and live their own lives. We are all Gods children, and we need to make our own way.

Fat Strat
Official GRB Sponsor of Larry Bigbie
Posts: 28010
Joined: April 17 06, 9:16 pm
Location: No. 16 on the Cards Top 15 Prospect List

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by Fat Strat »

TimeForGuinness wrote:Why give a choice if you already know the answer? Why allow pain & suffering if you can prevent it?

Even if you believe God chooses to not force himself on us, how (and I'll use my Catholic upbringing) do you resolve the vengeful, violent God of the Old Testament? If you believe in the literal/abstract version of the creation story (I'm sorry to say I don't), why would God punish independent thought, curiosity, and free will over an choice that he chose to give you?
Wow, TFG. Lot's of questions that require dissertation level answers.

1. Why give a choice? The scape goat answer would be that you would have to ask God. He's the one who is all-knowing. It's pretty foolish of me to think I can understand his thoughts and reasons fully. But, I won't give you the scape goat answer. So, here goes: God found it better for all of us and himself to create us with that choice all while knowing we would exercise that choice and that it would cause all kinds of serious issues. Are you not glad to be alive and have the ability to make choices, to love and feel emotions, and live and yes, even die?

2. Why allow pain and suffering if you can prevent it? I feel like I've already addressed that pretty thoroughly. One additional thought -- I don't think that God views our suffering the same way that we view suffering. He sees the full picture far clearer than we can see it. As I've already mentioned, we lack the perspective to understand our full lives. How many people get to the end and say, "boy did I suffer. It wasn't worth it to live at all." I can't speak for everyone, but that seems to be an extremely uncommon view.

3. how do you resolve the vengeful, violent God of the Old Testament? No short answer to this one. I don't know if I can even summarize it into brief thoughts that would serve here at all. Can I leave it for another day without everyone assuming I'm avoiding the issue? It is my birthday and I have surf and turf to grill and a cake to eat. Sorry, but that takes precedent over explaining the nuances of progressive and natural revelations, the avalanche effect, and the what salvation really is on an anonymous internet forum...

4. why would God punish independent thought, curiosity, and free will over an choice that he chose to give you? First, you're making some vital assumptions here. You're assuming that he punishes those things or that he at least doesn't value them. I would definitely argue that he doesn't punish them and that he values them tremendously. Second, you're almost assuming that all thought, curiosity, and free will are good things. They're not. Should we not be punished for exploring our curiosity to murder someone? To sleep with our neighbor's wife? To lie or steal?

We try to make this into an extremely cut and dried issue -- believe in Jesus or burn forever. You have to know the name of Jesus and pray a very specific prayer with a pastor at an altar and say a certain ## of prayers or it doesn't count. But, I'll tell you, this thing is just not that simple. The implication is that if you're a good person and you sincerely seek God, God will reject you anyway unless you follow a specific religious pattern. Prevenient grace (big word, I know) asserts that God gives you enough grace, enough love, enough revelation of himself that you know what you're doing. The Bible is pretty clear... sincerely seek God during this life and you're going to find him. But, we all have enough "natural revelation" and "attractive grace" to understand what we're rejecting when we pick another path.


Edit: And I ended up alluding to those issues #4 that I mentioned in #3 without fully explaining them. Sorry. Just take a few seminary classes on Theology. Should clear things up for you. :wink:

User avatar
JCShutout
MacGyver of Underwear
Posts: 13369
Joined: April 18 06, 7:53 am
Location: South City

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by JCShutout »

Well this thread exploded, and I'll admit to being too lazy to read the last 4 pages. I'll respond to the first few posts after my last.

I'm not saying the guy thinks God plays favorites, or at least he doesn't think he does. I'm not saying he is glad someone else died instead of his family. (funny how its wrong for me to make assumptions based on words of a guy who I was a groomsman for, but its okay for you all to make assumptions based on my words)

I am saying that language is important, and little discrepancies can say a lot about how you see the world, even if you don't realize it.

I know more than a handful of churchgoing female friends who have suffered rape, or church friends in accidents or who were born disabled, who have been hurt by their fellow churchgoers for attitudes like this. They have ranted to me about it. It hurts people.

You can just say "Thank God I'm alive", and that's way different than "God protected me (and by implication, not you)". You would be shocked at how language hurts people. Spend some time with abuse victims.

I'm not claiming that there is something wrong with being thankful for being alive. I'm saying there is a difference between that, and saying that God chose to protect you. Even when I was conservative religious, this attitude bugged me.

My dad doesn't think he's racist or sexist. He really doesn't. He thinks those things are bad (or he thinks that he does). But when he is telling me about a car salesman I should try, and he recounts his first meeting with the guy and says "so I see this black guy walking towards me and I think, okay, everyone deserves a chance" he doesn't see the discrimination in his thought process. When, 3 years ago (?) I ranted about some friends who would not go out with me, I didn't intend to criticize introverts and video game enthusiasts, (and I didn't realize that I was until a few pages into the tread) but I did, and I was wrong. Sometimes people don't realize what their words and ideas can lead to, and what they can imply.

I think this comic is related.
[SHOW]
http://xkcd.com/828/
Image
And TFG, take some seminary classes where they focus on Process Theology. :wink:
Last edited by JCShutout on May 1 12, 7:16 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by Socnorb11 »

JC - I think the wording could have been better. And I can see how someone who did lose a loved one could be offended, even if that wasn't the intent.

This has been a good discussion.

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by vinsanity »

Fat Strat wrote:How many people get to the end and say, "boy did I suffer. It wasn't worth it to live at all." I can't speak for everyone, but that seems to be an extremely uncommon view.
Not to be flippant, but one person commits suicide every 40 seconds. So more people hold that view than should. For every one that succeeds, 20 more attempt it. That's one every other second.
2. Why allow pain and suffering if you can prevent it? I feel like I've already addressed that pretty thoroughly.

How can a loving God allow his people to suffer? That's the question, right? From a Christian point of view, God doesn't ask us to go through anything that he himself did not experience. Christians believe that God actually took human form. He came to this world and lived in it -- in poverty, in squalor.
I mixed and mashed here because I think this paragraph was where you felt you addressed #2. Again, without trying to be flippant, why did God have to take human form? To absolve man of original sin, correct? Original sin was beings he created exercising the choice he gave them, no? So because of this, all of mankind was endowed with original sin. So, to save us from his own wrath, he takes human form to willfully suffer as a sacrifice to himself so that he could choose to not punish us for something our ancestors did?

I understand the what, but not the why. If God is so powerful to create the universe, create and breath life in to clay, flood the Earth at will, rise others and himself form the dead and live eternally, why create man? Why does a perfect being need to be worshipped by a creation? Why give that creation a choice to make a mistake that will force you to punish them? Why do you have to come to this world and live in poverty and squalor so you can forgive them for making the wrong choice, that you gave them? I think the problem of evil can't be waved off by saying "Well God suffered for you, too." If he's so powerful, why would he have to suffer to save us from him?
It's the result of our ready willingness to live for ourselves rather than to live for God. But, it does not mean God has given up on us. Far from it! Instead, he's taken it all on himself to give us the hope for a better future in the life to come.
How can you say suffering is a result of our choices, but that our creator is taken it all on himself? If it's our fault we suffer, he's putting at least some of it on us.

To the point of the thread; I don't think anyone actually means how it comes across. Semantics cross wires all the time. People, believers or not, always look for patterns and meaning in something. It's why Our Lady of Guadalupe shows up in tortilla's and St. Patrick is often found in the foam of spilled Guinness or old ladies will sit at their 'lucky' slot machine or Pujols thinks he's due to hit a home run. It's human nature to try and see and find patterns and meaning in things that may be meaningless.

It is, however, something to consider. Much like thanking God instead of the heart surgeon who saved your dad from a heart attack or the oncologist who saved your kid from cancer. Maybe next time, say your prayer before bed, have your moment of silence in your head but also consider the family who lost someone. The implication of statements such as those is that God loves your family, but maybe not the ones who suffered. I don't think it's intentional or meant that way, but some could feel like it.

User avatar
haltz
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22630
Joined: November 9 06, 6:45 am
Location: a proud midwestern metropolis

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by haltz »

wart57 wrote:I guess God does not love me very much, because he didn't stop me from reading this thread.
Hahahaha

One of the main reasons people join clubs is for protection. I mean, it's explicitly stated that believers will be protected from eternal damnation - that's sort of the whole idea. Unions, frats, gangs, religion, etc, all have their dues and benefits. This attitude should be expected, but it doesn't make it malicious.

Although, to be fair, it also feels good to be the one who paid your dues and be the one to reap the rewards. You earned it, after all.

User avatar
wart57
just can't quit you.
Posts: 25076
Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
Location: Lost

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by wart57 »

Luke 12:48

But the one who does not know and does things deserving punishment will be beaten with few blows. From everyone who has been given much, much will be demanded; and from the one who has been entrusted with much, much more will be asked.
Luke 20:45-21:4

[45] While all the people were listening, Jesus said to his disciples, [46] "Beware of the teachers of the law. They like to walk around in flowing robes and love to be greeted in the marketplaces and have the most important seats in the synagogues and the places of honor at banquets. [47] They devour widows' houses and for a show make lengthy prayers. Such men will be punished most severely."

[21:1] As he looked up, Jesus saw the rich putting their gifts into the temple treasury. [2] He also saw a poor widow put in two very small copper coins. [3] "I tell you the truth," he said, "this poor widow has put in more than all the others. [4] All these people gave their gifts out of their wealth; but she out of her poverty put in all she had to live on."

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by TimeForGuinness »

Fat Strat wrote:
TimeForGuinness wrote:Why give a choice if you already know the answer? Why allow pain & suffering if you can prevent it?

Even if you believe God chooses to not force himself on us, how (and I'll use my Catholic upbringing) do you resolve the vengeful, violent God of the Old Testament? If you believe in the literal/abstract version of the creation story (I'm sorry to say I don't), why would God punish independent thought, curiosity, and free will over an choice that he chose to give you?
Wow, TFG. Lot's of questions that require dissertation level answers.

1. Why give a choice? The scape goat answer would be that you would have to ask God. He's the one who is all-knowing. It's pretty foolish of me to think I can understand his thoughts and reasons fully. But, I won't give you the scape goat answer. So, here goes: God found it better for all of us and himself to create us with that choice all while knowing we would exercise that choice and that it would cause all kinds of serious issues. Are you not glad to be alive and have the ability to make choices, to love and feel emotions, and live and yes, even die?

2. Why allow pain and suffering if you can prevent it? I feel like I've already addressed that pretty thoroughly. One additional thought -- I don't think that God views our suffering the same way that we view suffering. He sees the full picture far clearer than we can see it. As I've already mentioned, we lack the perspective to understand our full lives. How many people get to the end and say, "boy did I suffer. It wasn't worth it to live at all." I can't speak for everyone, but that seems to be an extremely uncommon view.

3. how do you resolve the vengeful, violent God of the Old Testament? No short answer to this one. I don't know if I can even summarize it into brief thoughts that would serve here at all. Can I leave it for another day without everyone assuming I'm avoiding the issue? It is my birthday and I have surf and turf to grill and a cake to eat. Sorry, but that takes precedent over explaining the nuances of progressive and natural revelations, the avalanche effect, and the what salvation really is on an anonymous internet forum...

4. why would God punish independent thought, curiosity, and free will over an choice that he chose to give you? First, you're making some vital assumptions here. You're assuming that he punishes those things or that he at least doesn't value them. I would definitely argue that he doesn't punish them and that he values them tremendously. Second, you're almost assuming that all thought, curiosity, and free will are good things. They're not. Should we not be punished for exploring our curiosity to murder someone? To sleep with our neighbor's wife? To lie or steal?

We try to make this into an extremely cut and dried issue -- believe in Jesus or burn forever. You have to know the name of Jesus and pray a very specific prayer with a pastor at an altar and say a certain ## of prayers or it doesn't count. But, I'll tell you, this thing is just not that simple. The implication is that if you're a good person and you sincerely seek God, God will reject you anyway unless you follow a specific religious pattern. Prevenient grace (big word, I know) asserts that God gives you enough grace, enough love, enough revelation of himself that you know what you're doing. The Bible is pretty clear... sincerely seek God during this life and you're going to find him. But, we all have enough "natural revelation" and "attractive grace" to understand what we're rejecting when we pick another path.


Edit: And I ended up alluding to those issues #4 that I mentioned in #3 without fully explaining them. Sorry. Just take a few seminary classes on Theology. Should clear things up for you. :wink:
Thanks for taking the time to answer my questions. I know my questions were rudimentary, but I wanted to ease into the topic, as politely as I could, to see what others thought/believed before a flamewar broke out. I hope I didn't offend anyone with my questions, and I'd love to keep talking about it over PM if/when you have time. There are a lot of definitions that need to be addressed, like "good" or "right", that may not jive with everyone else's opinion...even if they seem simple to define at first glance.

I've spent my whole life in Catholic/Jesuit schools, but my religion or spirituality has evolved into more of a philosophy closely tied to nature & the sciences. I've been able to "make it blend", but I find it doesn't agree with most religions. Like I said earlier, from the 50,000 foot view, I think we're all pretty close in our thoughts and beliefs of trying to do good and be good. The "why" and the details are where most differ, but as long as people don't force their views/beliefs on others then I will have respect. The judging, yelling, and demonizing of others beliefs...I can do without as long as those beliefs aren't harming others. (I realize I might be a hypocrite making this statement as I am guilty of making rash judgements sometimes)

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by Socnorb11 »

TimeForGuinness wrote: I've spent my whole life in Catholic/Jesuit schools, but my religion or spirituality has evolved into more of a philosophy closely tied to nature & the sciences. I've been able to "make it blend", but I find it doesn't agree with most religions. Like I said earlier, from the 50,000 foot view, I think we're all pretty close in our thoughts and beliefs of trying to do good and be good. The "why" and the details are where most differ, but as long as people don't force their views/beliefs on others then I will have respect. The judging, yelling, and demonizing of others beliefs...I can do without as long as those beliefs aren't harming others. (I realize I might be a hypocrite making this statement as I am guilty of making rash judgements sometimes)

No offense, but if you've spend your whole life in church, and still have serious doubts and objections, maybe it's time to change churches??

Locked