Page 9 of 12
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 17 09, 11:48 pm
by docellis
I don't care about the dogs. I care about the fact that someone could be capable of electrocuting or hanging anything. I am not talking about who dies. I am talking about who kills.
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 17 09, 11:48 pm
by cardsfansince82
I don't think anyone thinks what Vick did wasn't savage. But at the end of the day a dog's life will never even approximate a human's life. And I say that as someone who loves dogs as much as any rational person. He paid a fair, if not excessive price. He lost everything he owns, is bankrupt, spent two years of his life in prison, had over $100 million in future earnings cancelled, and is still being jerked around about whether he will even be allowed to play. I promise I won't ever like him as a person but just let the guy be/earn a living/prove his remorse.
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 17 09, 11:50 pm
by docellis
cardsfansince82 wrote:I don't think anyone thinks what Vick did wasn't savage. But at the end of the day a dog's life will never even approximate a human's life. And I say that as someone who loves dogs as much as any rational person. He paid a fair, if not excessive price. He lost everything he owns, is bankrupt, spent two years of his life in prison, had over $100 million in future earnings cancelled, and is still being jerked around about whether he will even be allowed to play. I promise I won't ever like him as a person but just let the guy be/earn a living/prove his remorse.
I agree with all of this.
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 17 09, 11:50 pm
by PujolJunkie
cardsfansince82 wrote:I don't think anyone thinks what Vick did wasn't savage. But at the end of the day a dog's life will never even approximate a human's life. And I say that as someone who loves dogs as much as any rational person. He paid a fair, if not excessive price. He lost everything he owns, is bankrupt, spent two years of his life in prison, had over $100 million in future earnings cancelled, and is still being jerked around about whether he will even be allowed to play. I promise I won't ever like him as a person but just let the guy be/earn a living/prove his remorse.
I can't possibly say it any better.
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 17 09, 11:52 pm
by ghostrunner
Just getting back to the culture thing, does anybody think kids who grow up in the Klan or some similar group are racist because they're born that way? Influences and upbringing matter. It's weird that you have people talk about how important family values and morals are, but in the absence of those things a person is just supposed to grow up with a perfect moral compass. I don't know why we have to be so hard-assed about that.
I understand tying to be firm and principled, but it's not always a logical way to look at the situation. There has to be some allowance that a person deserves the chance to be educated so they and we don't end up going through all this again.
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 17 09, 11:52 pm
by docellis
G. Keenan wrote:docellis wrote:
But it is not nonsense to expect human beings to refrain from taking lives, brutally, with their hands.
Of course they should refrain from that but that's not what you've been saying in this thread. The implication of what you're saying is that violently killing a goldfish is worse than painlessly murdering a human.
Come on. That isn't what I am saying. I am saying that planning to kill a dog in an extremely violent way is worse than accidentally killing a person.
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 17 09, 11:53 pm
by InvincibleCakeEater
I forgot to tell you guys, but I'm going to be gone this winter to work on a Japanese whaling boat.
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 17 09, 11:54 pm
by Arthur Dent
docellis wrote:Come on. That isn't what I am saying. I am saying that planning to kill a dog in an extremely violent way is worse than accidentally killing a person.
How about planning to kill a goldfish in an extremely violent way?
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 17 09, 11:54 pm
by InvincibleCakeEater
docellis wrote:G. Keenan wrote:docellis wrote:
But it is not nonsense to expect human beings to refrain from taking lives, brutally, with their hands.
Of course they should refrain from that but that's not what you've been saying in this thread. The implication of what you're saying is that violently killing a goldfish is worse than painlessly murdering a human.
Come on. That isn't what I am saying.
I am saying that planning to kill a dog in an extremely violent way is worse than accidentally killing a person.
wow
I just don't get it I guess.
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 17 09, 11:56 pm
by G. Keenan
Arthur Dent wrote:G. Keenan wrote:What's legal and what's moral don't overlap perfectly. I think vehicular homicide is just as immoral as first degree murder but for practical purposes it can't be punished as harshly legally.
Very few people would agree. I think this is a refusal to recognize distinctions. You can argue that as a practical matter, only outcomes matter, but morally motivation counts too. It's a distinction we recognize in all social interactions.
I recognize the distinction between intentions and accidents but when it comes to drunk driving I think this is a matter of being habituated to something dangerous. You're already operating a dangerous object that you can easily lose control of sober. Add excessive amounts of alcohol and kill someone and it's like saying you're not guilty for letting your tiger of the leash at the park.