AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:IMO 'shocked and outraged' is pretty in line with the NFL's penalties
So your issue is with the punishments doled out this? That's an even more subjective discussion. I think it's probably a bit extreme, and Goodell has made a name for himself on some rather draconian punishments. I do, however, think the punishments did need to be severe to keep this behavior limited and eliminated if possible. It is in the leagues best interest for every star to be healthy. This (as you point next) is a task for Sisyphus. It is possible though to stop players from trying to hurt each other. I think that intent does matter in these cases. Blowing a knee because you landed on it wrong from a good tackle is bad luck. A concussion cause a guy wants to crack his helmet in to yours can be avoided. It doesn't make every helmet-to-helmet a malicious, fineable, egregious offense. Doesn't mean you can eliminate it all either.
But it's akin to throwing a jaywalker in jail for 5 years. Everyone does it, it happens. Even if they don't do it, the game is no safer which is what people are now trying to claim.
I don't think it's quite the same. We don't have evidence that other teams are rewarding players for injuring other players. It's also hardly as harmless as jaywalking. This isn't like holding. I can't even come up with a good analogy because there is intent to harm here. It's more like, an 'enforcer' goes out to check a guy but he whacks him with his stick then gets arrested for assault.
vinsanity wrote:It is possible though to stop players from trying to hurt each other.
because there is intent to harm here.
And we've come full circle. There will always be intent to harm, malicious or not, it's the lifeblood of the NFL.
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:
It's the fact that they are bad mother [expletive] who want to hit other bad mother [expletive] harder than anyone has ever hit them before and get on SportsCenter and NFL Big Hit highlight reels and, in general, be the baddest of the bad mother [expletive].
... the simple truth above is why the NFL is dangerous as [expletive]. 280 lb balls of muscle running sub 5 second 40 yard dashes turning themselves into torpedoes.
I for one would feel no safer playing in an NFL game tomorrow .... because of those human torpedoes. Not because I might get hit a second late.
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:It's the fact that they are bad mother [expletive] who want to hit other bad mother [expletive] harder than anyone has ever hit them before.
Yes. I agree. And sometimes that's going to cause injuries. It's going to happen and no one is disputing that. That is all good, legal and within the rules of the game. I think the criticism for encouraging injury is still valid.
It's like with Posey, it was a bang/bang play and a guy got hurt. Sucks. Part of the game. But if Edwin Rodriguez had offered $1k to get Posey injured and Cousin's ran over Posey when he wasn't in the base path that'd be wrong.
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:IMO 'shocked and outraged' is pretty in line with the NFL's penalties:
Year suspension for the head coach
Indefinite suspension for the DC
8 game suspension for the GM
6 game suspension for the asst. coach
loss of 2nd round draft pick in 2012
loss of 2nd round draft pick in 2013
That's not a straw man, that's the NFLs reaction which can easily be characterized as 'shocked and outraged' or over the top or bull [expletive] or whatever you want to put in.
Rather or not the saints were right or wrong isn't the issue, they were pretty clearly wrong. But it's akin to throwing a jaywalker in jail for 5 years. Everyone does it, it happens. Even if they don't do it, the game is no safer which is what people are now trying to claim. And, if it is safer, it's a [expletive] hair safer. Like saying you took a your salsa from a 855,000 on the scoville scale to a 850000.
Well, congratulations, you should probably pat yourself on the back, Roger!
How the hell are they A) supposed to make the point that illegal hits are illegal/illegal payments are illegal and B)decrease their liability as it relates to lawsuits from former players if they don't dole out serious punishments?
Jocephus wrote:i think the live (at stadium/ballpark) experience is much better with MLB than NFL.
You've never been to a titans game at lp field.
i've been to arrowhead. i think what i meant was that, i'd rather watch a nfl game at home. HD, all different camera angles, can hear the hits, live look ins, multiple games on one day. whereas baseball, while it also has all those things on TV too, it would be more enjoyable in person.
Well, sure, if we're just trying to make some lawsuits go away, then by all means continue with the farce.
How come the Raiders aren't in trouble if late hits and unnecessary roughness are threatening the NFL as they had just as many as the Saints? Just the fact that they only paid their players thier 2 million dollar salary instead of 2 million dollars plus a 10K bounty?
I get that its illegal and why it's bad in the media. I just don't buy that what they did was 1) all that different than what is going on in the NFL already and 2) exposed players to much if any more risk.
Jocephus wrote:i think the live (at stadium/ballpark) experience is much better with MLB than NFL.
You've never been to a titans game at lp field.
i've been to arrowhead. i think what i meant was that, i'd rather watch a nfl game at home. HD, all different camera angles, can hear the hits, live look ins, multiple games on one day. whereas baseball, while it also has all those things on TV too, it would be more enjoyable in person.