Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
docellis
America's Most Beloved Twitter Joke Thief
Posts: 24741
Joined: April 18 06, 6:54 pm

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by docellis »

wart57 wrote:
docellis wrote:
wart57 wrote: I never siad it was always the case. I guess since I am not a woman I can't have an opinion. Sorry to be a bother to all you women out there.
Well, it is pretty consistent for you to take a statement to the extreme.
I dissagree with you. You did say since I was not a woman I could not understand. That seems pretty extreme to me.
So you DO understand what it is like to be a woman?

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by lukethedrifter »

AdmiralKird wrote:
Simbagal23 wrote:
TimeForGuinness wrote:
What about miscarriages? How is that different from an abortion? Because nature saw fit to end the babies life instead of a human? Well if that is ok, then why do we spend so much money trying to save people on life support? Why don't humans let nature take it's course?

But I am getting distracted from the original argument. I just wanted a clear definition from wart about what his definition of "life" was...I felt his definition was flimsy and I wanted more from it. I never attacked him, I was mainly asking him questions about it. I want to know why he thinks it is morally ok to defend certain "lives" (human or non-human) than any other "life" by his definition.
FYI, miscarriages aren't always caused by nature. Just sayin.
Director's Cut of the Butterfly Effect.

---

Hypothetically, I think it would be interesting to see if some county was given exemption from Roe v. Wade and outlawed abortion. They'd have to set up a special adoption facilities, orphanages, etc designed to handle this greater influx of children and then a study would be performed on them every five years. I wonder where they'd be at age twenty...
And then we'd have to wonder why that hadn't been done for all the poor, hungry, homeless and/or in the state system children we have today.

User avatar
haltz
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22630
Joined: November 9 06, 6:45 am
Location: a proud midwestern metropolis

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by haltz »

JL21 wrote:In some regards, sure. But I wouldn't assume that we are in all regards.I don't think anyone would say that the ancient Greeks weren't advanced, relatively speaking.
Speaking of ancient beliefs and the Greeks, maybe JC can answer this. Isn't delayed animation an ancient Greek idea? What is the church history here? What's the idea behind forbidding contraception?

I think I have a vague idea of the answers here, but someone who knows weighing in would interest me. I find myself in the camp that isn't bothered much by, let's say, first trimester abortions.

And good stuff from AD and maddash.

User avatar
heyzeus
Everday Unicorn
Posts: 43331
Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
Location: Austin, TX

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by heyzeus »

Arthur Dent wrote:Isn't defining "life" just semantic? The word can be formally defined to be whatever you like. The real question is what forms deserve protection and at what point. People don't agree on that, and defining life is really no help.

Personally, I don't see an unfertilized egg as completely different than a fertilized one. Both represent potential babies. Fertilization is just one of the many steps in the continuous development process. I really don't know if there is any well defined point where a group of cells turn into something that must be protected.
I agree with you, AD. From a legal standpoint, the Supreme Court has more or less articulated that "live" begins at the stage of viability - that is, the stage of development of the embryo where the medical community generally agrees the fetus could exist outside of the womb. It's not a perfect definition, but it's something that has a rational basis.

i have a lot of problems with that definition, and abortion in general. I have a few friends and a relative who have lost their babies to miscarriage this year, generally after 1-3 months of pregnancy. To them, they lost their baby, and it's a deeply saddening loss. I know other people who have had or considered abortions at 1 to 3 months, and to do so, they and the courts do not consider that fetus to have been a "life." I have trouble reconciling the two scenarios. The only difference is how the potential parents feel about the fetus.

My general pro-choice stance is far more tempered than it was before this became less of an abstract subject for me.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by lukethedrifter »

heyzeus wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:Isn't defining "life" just semantic? The word can be formally defined to be whatever you like. The real question is what forms deserve protection and at what point. People don't agree on that, and defining life is really no help.

Personally, I don't see an unfertilized egg as completely different than a fertilized one. Both represent potential babies. Fertilization is just one of the many steps in the continuous development process. I really don't know if there is any well defined point where a group of cells turn into something that must be protected.
I agree with you, AD. From a legal standpoint, the Supreme Court has more or less articulated that "live" begins at the stage of viability - that is, the stage of development of the embryo where the medical community generally agrees the fetus could exist outside of the womb. It's not a perfect definition, but it's something that has a rational basis.

i have a lot of problems with that definition, and abortion in general. I have a few friends and a relative who have lost their babies to miscarriage this year, generally after 1-3 months of pregnancy. To them, they lost their baby, and it's a deeply saddening loss. I know other people who have had or considered abortions at 1 to 3 months, and to do so, they and the courts do not consider that fetus to have been a "life." I have trouble reconciling the two scenarios. The only difference is how the potential parents feel about the fetus.

My general pro-choice stance is far more tempered than it was before this became less of an abstract subject for me.
I think it's relevant to understand that many miscarriages if not most early miscarriages occur because the fetuses are not viable.
During the first trimester, the most common cause of miscarriage is chromosomal abnormality - meaning that something is not correct with the baby's chromosomes. Most chromosomal abnormalities are the cause of a faulty egg or sperm cell, or are due to a problem at the time that the zygote went through the division process. Other causes for miscarriage include (but are not limited to):

* Hormonal problems, infections or maternal health problems
* Lifestyle (i.e. smoking, drug use, malnutrition, excessive caffeine and exposure to radiation or toxic substances)
* Implantation of the egg into the uterine lining does not occur properly
* Maternal age
* Maternal trauma

User avatar
wart57
just can't quit you.
Posts: 25076
Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
Location: Lost

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by wart57 »

docellis wrote:
wart57 wrote:
docellis wrote:
wart57 wrote: I never siad it was always the case. I guess since I am not a woman I can't have an opinion. Sorry to be a bother to all you women out there.
Well, it is pretty consistent for you to take a statement to the extreme.
I dissagree with you. You did say since I was not a woman I could not understand. That seems pretty extreme to me.
So you DO understand what it is like to be a woman?
Do you know what it is like to be a man? If not, using your logic, you should not be able to have an opinion on a mans subject, oh wait, that would be sexist.

This is my final comment on the entire thing. If you think you are mature enough to have sex, you need to be prepaired for the consequences.
I have never said that people who have abortions are evil, or that it was an easy descision for them, but someone needs to talk for the innocent lives involved.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by cards2468 »

I don't know the statistic, nor have a reference too it, but I was told that many areas saw a drop in crime following abortion being allowed. Maybe somebody could confirm or disprove this, but as terrible as it is, there is a benefit to having less "unwanted children". I do think abortion is wrong, but I really don't see how we're fit as a society to outlaw it until we work to prevent the need for abortion and work to find good alternatives readily available to people all the while educating people on these methods and alternatives. Every time there's an abortion, it's not just a wrong doing by the people directly involved, but also a wrong doing by our society. Until we can bring society to a point where there's no need for abortion clinics, it should stay legal.

Back to the protesters, it's disgusting and invasive to everybody no matter what stance you take. Their point is that being disgusted should prove it's wrong, but what really separates this from terrorism? Terrorism isn't designed to kill everybody, it's designed to scare everybody into changing their ways. Posting disgusting images might not be physically hurting anybody (unless the jerking reaction you get while driving and seeing it causes you to wreck) but it's designed to disgust and scare people into following their direction. Like I said, I'm not really pro-choice, and I do believe abortion is wrong, but their methods of getting their point across is wrong and disturbing.

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by TimeForGuinness »

heyzeus wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:Isn't defining "life" just semantic? The word can be formally defined to be whatever you like. The real question is what forms deserve protection and at what point. People don't agree on that, and defining life is really no help.

Personally, I don't see an unfertilized egg as completely different than a fertilized one. Both represent potential babies. Fertilization is just one of the many steps in the continuous development process. I really don't know if there is any well defined point where a group of cells turn into something that must be protected.
I agree with you, AD. From a legal standpoint, the Supreme Court has more or less articulated that "live" begins at the stage of viability - that is, the stage of development of the embryo where the medical community generally agrees the fetus could exist outside of the womb. It's not a perfect definition, but it's something that has a rational basis.

i have a lot of problems with that definition, and abortion in general. I have a few friends and a relative who have lost their babies to miscarriage this year, generally after 1-3 months of pregnancy. To them, they lost their baby, and it's a deeply saddening loss. I know other people who have had or considered abortions at 1 to 3 months, and to do so, they and the courts do not consider that fetus to have been a "life." I have trouble reconciling the two scenarios. The only difference is how the potential parents feel about the fetus.

My general pro-choice stance is far more tempered than it was before this became less of an abstract subject for me.
I hear ya...it's definitely a hard subject...but I respect that the freedom of that choice is available, just like I respect the freedom to protest that choice.

The longer I live, the more I realize the world isn't black and white...it's just gray...and you just have to make the best choice with what you have at the time.

User avatar
docellis
America's Most Beloved Twitter Joke Thief
Posts: 24741
Joined: April 18 06, 6:54 pm

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by docellis »

wart57 wrote:Do you know what it is like to be a man? If not, using your logic, you should not be able to have an opinion on a mans subject, oh wait, that would be sexist.

This is my final comment on the entire thing. If you think you are mature enough to have sex, you need to be prepaired for the consequences.
I have never said that people who have abortions are evil, or that it was an easy descision for them, but someone needs to talk for the innocent lives involved.
I never said I knew what it was like to be a man - but that is irrelevant to the discussion since men can't have abortions.

Jocephus
99% conan clips
Posts: 64992
Joined: April 18 06, 5:14 pm

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by Jocephus »

docellis wrote:
wart57 wrote:Do you know what it is like to be a man? If not, using your logic, you should not be able to have an opinion on a mans subject, oh wait, that would be sexist.

This is my final comment on the entire thing. If you think you are mature enough to have sex, you need to be prepaired for the consequences.
I have never said that people who have abortions are evil, or that it was an easy descision for them, but someone needs to talk for the innocent lives involved.
I never said I knew what it was like to be a man - but that is irrelevant to the discussion since men can't have abortions.
dont be so sure about that doc

Image

Post Reply