Page 10 of 12
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 17 09, 11:56 pm
by planet planet
Arthur Dent wrote:docellis wrote:Come on. That isn't what I am saying. I am saying that planning to kill a dog in an extremely violent way is worse than accidentally killing a person.
How about planning to kill a goldfish in an extremely violent way?
Speaking of which, it really grosses me out to be watching Iron Chef and seeing them kill all those fish, mollusks, and squid by ripping into them live with a knife.
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 17 09, 11:57 pm
by PujolJunkie
docellis wrote:G. Keenan wrote:docellis wrote:
But it is not nonsense to expect human beings to refrain from taking lives, brutally, with their hands.
Of course they should refrain from that but that's not what you've been saying in this thread. The implication of what you're saying is that violently killing a goldfish is worse than painlessly murdering a human.
Come on. That isn't what I am saying. I am saying that planning to kill a dog in an extremely violent way is worse than accidentally killing a person.
That is still putting an animal's life and well being over the life and well being of someone's friend or family. If you would honestly rather see Michael Vick go to jail rather than a person who drove drunk and killed someone's son or daughter then you are putting the life of an animal over a human being.
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 18 09, 12:00 am
by Arthur Dent
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 18 09, 12:00 am
by G. Keenan
docellis wrote:G. Keenan wrote:docellis wrote:
But it is not nonsense to expect human beings to refrain from taking lives, brutally, with their hands.
Of course they should refrain from that but that's not what you've been saying in this thread. The implication of what you're saying is that violently killing a goldfish is worse than painlessly murdering a human.
Come on. That isn't what I am saying. I am saying that planning to kill a dog in an extremely violent way is worse than accidentally killing a person.
More disturbing, absolutely. And depending on the type of accident I might agree. I don't think drunk driving is that kind of accident. Driving drunk is a choice someone makes. You choose to operate a dangerous object when you know you have little ability to control it. That isn't an accident.
Hitting a foul ball that hits someone in the face is an accident.
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 18 09, 12:06 am
by wart57
If someone killed my dog intentionally, I think there is a very distinct chance I would go to jail for inflicting serious harm upon them, if someone killed my daughter by driving drunk, I know I would go to jail for inflicting serious ham on them.
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 18 09, 12:13 am
by InvincibleCakeEater
wart57 wrote:If someone killed my dog intentionally, I think there is a very distinct chance I would go to jail for inflicting serious harm upon them, if someone killed my daughter by driving drunk, I know I would go to jail for inflicting serious ham on them.
I feel really bad about this, but your bolded typo made me lol.
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 18 09, 12:15 am
by ghostrunner
InvincibleCakeEater wrote:wart57 wrote:If someone killed my dog intentionally, I think there is a very distinct chance I would go to jail for inflicting serious harm upon them, if someone killed my daughter by driving drunk, I know I would go to jail for inflicting serious ham on them.
I feel really bad about this, but your bolded typo made me lol.
That would be 6 hams, then.
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 18 09, 12:20 am
by wart57
ghostrunner wrote:InvincibleCakeEater wrote:wart57 wrote:If someone killed my dog intentionally, I think there is a very distinct chance I would go to jail for inflicting serious harm upon them, if someone killed my daughter by driving drunk, I know I would go to jail for inflicting serious ham on them.
I feel really bad about this, but your bolded typo made me lol.
That would be 6 hams, then.
[expletive] it, I am going on about an hour of sleep, and I have been up since 4:30 am
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 18 09, 12:20 am
by Arthur Dent
Drunk driving is kind of a weird comparison but Brett Myers was also brought up. Hitting your wife in the face is not an accident.
Re: People protesting signing Vick
Posted: August 18 09, 12:21 am
by InvincibleCakeEater
Arthur Dent wrote:Drunk driving is kind of a weird comparison but Brett Myers was also brought up. Hitting your wife in the face is not an accident.
apparently it is if you've been drinking