GatewayRedbirds.com

Would you do this deal?

I'd be trading JJ Hardy and Soriano for BJ Upton,Hanley Ramirez and Curtis Granderson.

hmm.....

Depends on the rest of your team. That's an intriguing one.

I'll post my team.

Here's my team:


C Víctor Martínez

1B Carlos Delgado

1B Rich Aurilia

2B Freddy Sánchez

3B Chad Tracy

SS Juan Uribe
CI Scott Rolen

MI Rafael Furcal

IF J.J. Hardy

OF Moisés Alou
OF Ken Griffey Jr.

OF Magglio Ordóñez

OF Alfonso Soriano
OF Brad Hawpe

Util Sean Casey
BN Jason Varitek

BN Aubrey Huff
-
BN Jim Edmonds
(
BN Chris B. Young



SP John Smoltz
-
SP Tom Gorzelanny
(-
SP Tim Wakefield
(
RP Dan Wheeler

RP David Aardsma
(
P Chris Capuano
(
P A.J. Burnett
(
BN Jason Hirsh
(
BN Nate Robertson



DL Chris Carpenter

DL Tom Gordon

Na. Its an even trade..so why do you want to do it? Just for the sake of doing it? Hold your cards till later.

I'm still not sure. I'm leaning toward yes, just because you're getting 3 guys you can start for two guys that you can start, and you would be upgrading positions that I see as weaknesses on your club, specifically 2nd base.

Fat Strat wrote:I'm still not sure. I'm leaning toward yes, just because you're getting 3 guys you can start for two guys that you can start, and you would be upgrading positions that I see as weaknesses on your club, specifically 2nd base.

i would have to agere with this analysis...


thats a tough one though....the trade itself does seem pretty fair, but then its just a matter of what you want yer team to look like...

The reason that I would do this deal is because it's a keeper league and I'm in last place. I'm already 40 games out. I'm looking forward to next year and I'm hoping to change up my team because I finished in last, last year also.

If it's a keeper pull the trigger.