Page 1 of 4
Me and Yadier Molina
Posted: July 22 07, 8:40 pm
by greenback44
Gosh, that needed to be docellised.
Re: Me and Yadier Molina
Posted: July 22 07, 9:08 pm
by Michael
I feel the same way.
Re: Me and Yadier Molina
Posted: July 22 07, 9:11 pm
by maddash
I agree.
The thing with Yadi is that it's hard to have your cake and eat it too. I really like Yadi. Something about how he plays just makes me smile - I even forked out good money for a Yadi jersey. But I recognize that I can't love Yadi and just ignore the offensive hole he puts this team in. At his best Yadi is a hitter that can be hidden in a lineup, but we can all see that there's no place to hide this year.
So fans are left with a choice - Do they cheer on a player who in the long run may be hurting the team? Or do they hope the Cards makes a move that benefits the team at the expense of one of their favorite players? You can't (at least this year) have your cake and eat it too.
But yeah. This passive-aggressive, stats vs "I just watch the game" crap is getting really old. The divisive, sarcastic, hyperbole-ridden posts are below this board.
Re: Me and Yadier Molina
Posted: July 22 07, 9:50 pm
by Cronos
If Yadi were at any position but a catcher, I would agree that we really could do better. But he is. And he's still young; no he probably won't improve significantly, but he's already shown some improvement for this year(at least he's settled on a batting stance).
It's fair to talk about how he's not that great of a hitter. The only thing I don't like is some(and I'm not singling just you out, Green) just constantly harp on it like he's the worst hitter of all time. He may be the slowest one, I'll grant...
I realize we could do a lot better. He's become kind of a fan favorite, though, and his arm is a weapon whether it outweighs his hitting or not. I really think he brings more to the team than just his batting numbers. But that's an opinion as valid as anyone else's on this board.
Re: Me and Yadier Molina
Posted: July 22 07, 10:01 pm
by sighyoung
maddash wrote:This passive-aggressive, stats vs "I just watch the game" crap is getting really old. The divisive, sarcastic, hyperbole-ridden posts are below this board.
I think jim nicely summed up most posters' opinions, yet the thread dragged on.
Frankly, "passive-aggressive" is too kind an adjective for some of the recent arguments in the Baseball forum. Overwrought and creepy are more accurate terms.
Re: Me and Yadier Molina
Posted: July 22 07, 10:10 pm
by ghostrunner
I hope mine weren't taken as passive aggressive. I think I was pretty direct, and I think it's legit to question where or how we get other players of value when we have so much tied up in a few, and how much we could really expect to gain at catcher. I've said it before - I believe the stats, and I'm ready to make a change whenever Anderson is ready or Yadi becomes expensive.
I guess I'd just like to see some sort of argument about what should be/should have been done instead. Short of that, it doesn't seem worth all the complaints.
Re: Me and Yadier Molina
Posted: July 22 07, 10:24 pm
by dangerous
A few years ago I was hanging out with Bengie and Jose and they told me Yadier could beat them in arm wrestling.
Re: Me and Yadier Molina
Posted: July 22 07, 10:31 pm
by Ace
Does this relate to me?
If so, I would like you explain it to me so I won't do it in the future.
"STFU WRT" What does this mean? Sorry for the ignorance.
Re: Me and Yadier Molina
Posted: July 22 07, 10:43 pm
by haltz
Ace wrote:"STFU WRT" What does this mean? Sorry for the ignorance.
Shut the F Up, With Regard To
I don't think he's talking about you, Ace. To me, the passive-aggressive responses are just the defensive subtle digs that go on about stats around the forum, maybe even in different threads as inside "jokes" or whatever, but clear arguments against the stats or ideas or whatever are never presented. I haven't seen too much of it lately.
Re: Me and Yadier Molina
Posted: July 22 07, 10:45 pm
by Ace
haltz wrote:Ace wrote:"STFU WRT" What does this mean? Sorry for the ignorance.
Shut the F Up, With Regard To
I don't think he's talking about you, Ace. To me, the passive-aggressive responses are just the defensive subtle digs that go on about stats around the forum, maybe even in different threads as inside "jokes" or whatever, but clear arguments against the stats or ideas or whatever are never presented. I haven't seen too much of it lately.
Ok, thanks a lot for clearing that up haltz thats makes a lot of sense now. I now know what he is referring to and I also find it rather annoying.