Page 1 of 4
Bad Brewpubs
Posted: October 20 08, 3:07 pm
by Hungary Jack
One almost always expects a brewpub to offer full-flavored, distinctive, crafted brews and a food menu that complements the beer. After a weekend backpack trip in a place called Nordhouse Dunes Wilderness, I was gravely disappointed by the Jamesport Brewery in Ludington, Michigan. I tried a Kolsch, found it flat and tinny, sent it back for an Altbier, which I found flat and tinny. This is not what one wants after two nights of eating rehydrated stew and sleeping on the ground.
Re: Bad Brewpubs
Posted: October 20 08, 3:30 pm
by Popeye_Card
There are so many bad ones out there now that you learn to really appreciate the good/great ones.
St. Louis has a gem with Schlafly (both locations). We've got some duds though too.
What I don't like is if somebody tries a different beer at one of the bad ones, it sucks and they never want to try one again. I wish the bad establishments would warn the patron that their beers suck, and are not representative of the style.
Re: Bad Brewpubs
Posted: October 20 08, 3:31 pm
by thrill
4 Peaks in Tempe is amazing.
Re: Bad Brewpubs
Posted: October 20 08, 3:40 pm
by maddash
Popeye_Card wrote:There are so many bad ones out there now that you learn to really appreciate the good/great ones.
St. Louis has a gem with Schlafly (both locations). We've got some duds though too.
What I don't like is if somebody tries a different beer at one of the bad ones, it sucks and they never want to try one again. I wish the bad establishments would warn the patron that their beers suck, and are not representative of the style.
Square One Brewery is bad. Really bad.
It's kind of a cool place to hang out at though.
Re: Bad Brewpubs
Posted: October 20 08, 3:45 pm
by TabascoElvis
Hungary Jack wrote:One almost always expects a brewpub to offer full-flavored, distinctive, crafted brews and a food menu that complements the beer. After a weekend backpack trip in a place called Nordhouse Dunes Wilderness, I was gravely disappointed by the Jamesport Brewery in Ludington, Michigan. I tried a Kolsch, found it flat and tinny, sent it back for an Altbier, which I found flat and tinny. This is not what one wants after two nights of eating rehydrated stew and sleeping on the ground.
Whatever you do, don't stop at Saugatuck Brewing in Douglas, when you're driving through that neck of the woods. I have a feeling their flat would make your experience seem fizzy. If there's such a thing as anti-carbonation, they've perfected it. Stop in Holland and hit New Holland instead. And PM me first... I'm craving a BBQ chicken pizza.
Re: Bad Brewpubs
Posted: October 20 08, 3:46 pm
by Popeye_Card
maddash wrote:Popeye_Card wrote:There are so many bad ones out there now that you learn to really appreciate the good/great ones.
St. Louis has a gem with Schlafly (both locations). We've got some duds though too.
What I don't like is if somebody tries a different beer at one of the bad ones, it sucks and they never want to try one again. I wish the bad establishments would warn the patron that their beers suck, and are not representative of the style.
Square One Brewery is bad. Really bad.
It's kind of a cool place to hang out at though.
The food is fairly good, for the relatively low price.
But the beer is really, really bad. Yet I have had some people tell me that they like Square One, but not Schlafly. I can only shake my head in disbelief.
Re: Bad Brewpubs
Posted: October 20 08, 3:54 pm
by G. Keenan
To be honest I think Schlafly is just OK.
Re: Bad Brewpubs
Posted: October 20 08, 3:54 pm
by Arthur Dent
Speaking of brewpubs, thanks to HJ for recommending the Dillon Dam Brewery in Colorado. Amazing. If you're passing within, say, a 100 mile radius of Dillon, CO, you owe it to yourself to check it out.
Re: Bad Brewpubs
Posted: October 20 08, 3:59 pm
by Popeye_Card
G. Keenan wrote:To be honest I think Schlafly is just OK.
Most of their standard beers are indeed just OK. But some of their specialty brews are outstanding. And that's not just me. Beer advocate agrees.
Re: Bad Brewpubs
Posted: October 20 08, 4:09 pm
by G. Keenan
Popeye_Card wrote:G. Keenan wrote:To be honest I think Schlafly is just OK.
Most of their standard beers are indeed just OK. But some of their specialty brews are outstanding. And that's not just me. Beer advocate agrees.
Yeah, those are the ones I'm referring to. I haven't tried their specialty beers.
I still love the Tap Room, btw.