Page 1 of 2
City Government
Posted: April 9 09, 3:11 pm
by Hungary Jack
We filed a claim against the city for water damage when a city contractor performed a sewer lining project that went awry. We had sewer backup on several occasions due to a blocked private drain that resulted from the connection being blocked.
The doofus from the city called me today to inform me that the claim was denied. He asserted that the city was not responsible for the work done by its contractors. I'm no attorney, but this is ridiculous. He then tried to convince me that the city was not responsible for damages that occur on its property.
Where do these idiots come from? Is there any way to send them back to the idiot farm?
Re: City Government
Posted: April 9 09, 3:12 pm
by Michael
So what are you going to do?
Re: City Government
Posted: April 9 09, 3:17 pm
by Hungary Jack
Mrs. Jack and I may hire an attorney to pursue this. Damages are up to $10,000, though insurance covered most. I am tempted to pursue this just out of principal. It chaps my testes that this government thinks it is exempt from responsibility.
Re: City Government
Posted: April 9 09, 3:18 pm
by Popeye_Card
They're probably not idiots. They probably figure that most people won't bother to take the city to court over the matter, and the city saves money.
Re: City Government
Posted: April 9 09, 3:29 pm
by PujolJunkie
Gee. Let me take a stab at it. The contractor was from a foreign country.
Re: City Government
Posted: April 9 09, 3:31 pm
by sighyoung
PujolJunkie wrote:Gee. Let me take a stab at it. The contractor was from a foreign country.
No, just another of Hungary's enraged neighbors.
Re: City Government
Posted: April 9 09, 3:40 pm
by cpebbles
Any Jewish neighbors whose kids you could enlist as paralegals?
Re: City Government
Posted: April 9 09, 3:42 pm
by PujolJunkie
Did you hire a Mexican neighbor to clean up the mess and fix the problem?
Or maybe an Italian duo?
Did they look like this?

Re: City Government
Posted: April 9 09, 4:00 pm
by stlouie_lipp
I certainly would encourage you to speak with an attorney, because sometimes settling is cheaper than fighting for the city. However, it would be an expensive fight for you as well, and your insurance carrier would likely have subordination rights to any money you do recover. On top of that, the city has the Local Governmental and Governmental Employees Tort Immunity Act on its side. Here's a link:
http://www.ilga.gov/legislation/ilcs/il ... munity+Act.
Re: City Government
Posted: April 9 09, 4:19 pm
by Hungary Jack
Thanks Louie. That's helpful. At a glance, it appears that property damage arising from contractor negligence is not covered under this provision. But this is far beyond my expertise. We'll see what our attorney friend says.
Btw, our attorney friend is Assyrian.