St. Louis Blues 2009 Offseason thread.
- JCShutout
- MacGyver of Underwear
- Posts: 13369
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:53 am
- Location: South City
St. Louis Blues 2009 Offseason thread.
Yup, I get right on things.
The Blues pick 17th. That might not sound great, but the kid line was picked 24th, 25th and 26th overall, and Backes like 62nd overall (and MacD undrafted), so you never know.
I think you try to resign Walt with the understanding that he's a third line role player. Drop Hinote, not because he's not useful, but because you can't keep ALL the 4th liners.Then you have:
Kariya-MacD-Boyes
Perron-Berglund-Oshie
FA/Tkachuk-Backes-Steen
Winchester-JayMac-Crombeen/Janssen/King
I think you hold steady with the D. I'm assuming no one will take Brewer, Jackman or McKee off our hands. If they do (or Brewer is still injured), sign one guy, preferably a #5/6 vet type. Drop Woywitka unless Petro and Junlund need to stay down in Peoria to get minutes.
Brewer-EJ
Cola-Jackman
McKee-Polak/Petro/Junlund/Weaver
Sign a decent vet backup goalie, then done. Wait until offseason 2010 to spend when Kariya and McKee are off the books, and Jackman and Brewer are closer to their contract end dates (and maybe more tradeable)
The Blues pick 17th. That might not sound great, but the kid line was picked 24th, 25th and 26th overall, and Backes like 62nd overall (and MacD undrafted), so you never know.
I think you try to resign Walt with the understanding that he's a third line role player. Drop Hinote, not because he's not useful, but because you can't keep ALL the 4th liners.Then you have:
Kariya-MacD-Boyes
Perron-Berglund-Oshie
FA/Tkachuk-Backes-Steen
Winchester-JayMac-Crombeen/Janssen/King
I think you hold steady with the D. I'm assuming no one will take Brewer, Jackman or McKee off our hands. If they do (or Brewer is still injured), sign one guy, preferably a #5/6 vet type. Drop Woywitka unless Petro and Junlund need to stay down in Peoria to get minutes.
Brewer-EJ
Cola-Jackman
McKee-Polak/Petro/Junlund/Weaver
Sign a decent vet backup goalie, then done. Wait until offseason 2010 to spend when Kariya and McKee are off the books, and Jackman and Brewer are closer to their contract end dates (and maybe more tradeable)
- MrCrowesGarden
- 'Burb Boy
- Posts: 24841
- Joined: July 9 06, 11:33 am
- Location: Out of the Loop
Re: St. Louis Blues 2009 Offseason thread.
What about Lars Eller?
- JCShutout
- MacGyver of Underwear
- Posts: 13369
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:53 am
- Location: South City
Re: St. Louis Blues 2009 Offseason thread.
I figured to not worry about him yet, assuming Peoria is a better spot than getting 6-8 minutes on the 4th line. That said, maybe he can take Steen's spot, who knows.MrCrowesGarden wrote:What about Lars Eller?
Should be an interesting summer. What to do with these prospects? I say work them in.
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31100
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: St. Louis Blues 2009 Offseason thread.
I'm kinda on the fence with Walt. I think you bring either him or Winchester back, but not both.
For the draft, I would try to pick a high-upside forward that's 3-4 years away from stepping in. A guy planning on going to college (like Oshie) or along those lines. Because we really don't have a place to stick a guy on the main roster right now. Or go for a goalie.
I think you keep either King or Cam, but not both. My preference is King.
McDonald, Backes, Boyes, Kariya, McClement, Oshie, Berglund, Perron are shoo-in forwards. That's 8 of the 12 spots. I think Steen is a keeper for his D and occasional offensive flair. One of the spots probably should be taken up by a goon (King/Cam) OR an agitator (???), depending on who you want to skate that night. Perhaps Crombeen and/or Winchester should be retained to take over that agitator role. Both have the tendency to get under the other team's skin, and aren't stiffs out there. That leaves 2 spots for Eller, Walt (if re-signed), a different prospect, a different FA, or the other of Crombeen/Winchester.
The D should probably just be kept as is. Plan on EJ, Jackman, McKee, Polak, and CC being available. With Brewer's injury, you don't know if and how he'll be able to return. I think that's a good enough core to get Jello comfortably into the rotation in Brewer's spot, or in the spot of one of the guys that have difficulty staying on the ice sometimes (CC, McKee). If Weaver is OK with hanging on the roster and being a healthy scratch most games, keep him around too. I don't know that Junland is a good enough prospect that we *need* to find him playing time.
All this said, I wouldn't mind a deal packaging a few bodies for a top-flight forward. I'd tag Backes, McDonald, Oshie, Berglund, EJ as untouchables. I wouldn't give the rest away, but I'd listen for the right deal.
For the draft, I would try to pick a high-upside forward that's 3-4 years away from stepping in. A guy planning on going to college (like Oshie) or along those lines. Because we really don't have a place to stick a guy on the main roster right now. Or go for a goalie.
I think you keep either King or Cam, but not both. My preference is King.
McDonald, Backes, Boyes, Kariya, McClement, Oshie, Berglund, Perron are shoo-in forwards. That's 8 of the 12 spots. I think Steen is a keeper for his D and occasional offensive flair. One of the spots probably should be taken up by a goon (King/Cam) OR an agitator (???), depending on who you want to skate that night. Perhaps Crombeen and/or Winchester should be retained to take over that agitator role. Both have the tendency to get under the other team's skin, and aren't stiffs out there. That leaves 2 spots for Eller, Walt (if re-signed), a different prospect, a different FA, or the other of Crombeen/Winchester.
The D should probably just be kept as is. Plan on EJ, Jackman, McKee, Polak, and CC being available. With Brewer's injury, you don't know if and how he'll be able to return. I think that's a good enough core to get Jello comfortably into the rotation in Brewer's spot, or in the spot of one of the guys that have difficulty staying on the ice sometimes (CC, McKee). If Weaver is OK with hanging on the roster and being a healthy scratch most games, keep him around too. I don't know that Junland is a good enough prospect that we *need* to find him playing time.
All this said, I wouldn't mind a deal packaging a few bodies for a top-flight forward. I'd tag Backes, McDonald, Oshie, Berglund, EJ as untouchables. I wouldn't give the rest away, but I'd listen for the right deal.
-
TimeForGuinness
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 20007
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm
Re: St. Louis Blues 2009 Offseason thread.
Great post. I want to echo your draft pick selection, I think that's the proper way to go: Young forward or goalie.Popeye_Card wrote:I'm kinda on the fence with Walt. I think you bring either him or Winchester back, but not both.
For the draft, I would try to pick a high-upside forward that's 3-4 years away from stepping in. A guy planning on going to college (like Oshie) or along those lines. Because we really don't have a place to stick a guy on the main roster right now. Or go for a goalie.
I think you keep either King or Cam, but not both. My preference is King.
McDonald, Backes, Boyes, Kariya, McClement, Oshie, Berglund, Perron are shoo-in forwards. That's 8 of the 12 spots. I think Steen is a keeper for his D and occasional offensive flair. One of the spots probably should be taken up by a goon (King/Cam) OR an agitator (???), depending on who you want to skate that night. Perhaps Crombeen and/or Winchester should be retained to take over that agitator role. Both have the tendency to get under the other team's skin, and aren't stiffs out there. That leaves 2 spots for Eller, Walt (if re-signed), a different prospect, a different FA, or the other of Crombeen/Winchester.
The D should probably just be kept as is. Plan on EJ, Jackman, McKee, Polak, and CC being available. With Brewer's injury, you don't know if and how he'll be able to return. I think that's a good enough core to get Jello comfortably into the rotation in Brewer's spot, or in the spot of one of the guys that have difficulty staying on the ice sometimes (CC, McKee). If Weaver is OK with hanging on the roster and being a healthy scratch most games, keep him around too. I don't know that Junland is a good enough prospect that we *need* to find him playing time.
All this said, I wouldn't mind a deal packaging a few bodies for a top-flight forward. I'd tag Backes, McDonald, Oshie, Berglund, EJ as untouchables. I wouldn't give the rest away, but I'd listen for the right deal.
- thrill
- bronoun enthusiast
- Posts: 30539
- Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
- Location: barely online
Re: St. Louis Blues 2009 Offseason thread.
Best player available since there will be no obvious superstar pick.
Also, I'm not sure anyone on this roster should be untouchable.
Also, I'm not sure anyone on this roster should be untouchable.
-
TimeForGuinness
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 20007
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm
Re: St. Louis Blues 2009 Offseason thread.
I can somewhat agree mainly because of how deep the farm is, but I'd really like our kids to develop here.thrill wrote:Also, I'm not sure anyone on this roster should be untouchable.
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31100
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: St. Louis Blues 2009 Offseason thread.
True I guess. But unless the trade target is a 100% bona fide superstar, you'd just be giving up high-end talent to receive high-end talent. I know what you're saying--guys like Backes and McDonald aren't high-end talent, and aren't likely to grow into it. I personally don't trade Backes because it's tough to find a power forward like that. The guy led the team in hits by a large margin, led in PIM by a large margin, and still was one of the scoring leaders. If you find a guy like that, you don't give him up for peanuts. He's likely going to be added to the US Olympic squad. For McDonald, unless you got an equal playmaker in return, I don't think you give up a guy like him either.thrill wrote: Also, I'm not sure anyone on this roster should be untouchable.
Giving up Berglund, Oshie, or EJ before they're close to their ceilings would be a big mistake, IMO. Some might lump Perron into that group, but I think he's closer to his final ceiling than these guys are. I will say that Perron played an excellent game last night--he was impressive, wheras Berglund and Oshie were nowhere to be seen in the entire series.
-
TimeForGuinness
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 20007
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm
Re: St. Louis Blues 2009 Offseason thread.
The kid line also needs to put on about 20 lbs of muscle each...we're getting blown off the puck too easily.
- thrill
- bronoun enthusiast
- Posts: 30539
- Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
- Location: barely online
Re: St. Louis Blues 2009 Offseason thread.
The guys you listed aren't worth even discussing trade scenarios about until something comes to the table. They aren't untouchable, but you certainly don't actively shop them. If a name like Malkin, Luongo, etc is mentioned then you think about it.
