There is a reason we haven't been able to find a good SS yet...it's hard to do. There are just not too many players who have the athleticism, arm strength, and bat to play SS at the major league level. You also have to remember, the person must be right handed, so that thins the pool even more.
Hopefully one of these years we can either trade for one, or get one of these guys to develop into an actual above average SS. Kozma has a chance to be a league average SS, and that would be a massive upgrade to what we've had.
robbotis wrote:Who is the last league average SS the Cards farm system has produced?
Ozzie, Clayton, Eckstein, & Renteria were traded for.
Jack Wilson, but he's below league average (despite making $7.5 million this season--wow).
EDIT: This post reminds me that in the late 90's, we were "loaded" with fringe MI prospects much like we are now with fringe OF prospects. Kennedy, Butler, Wolfe, Polanco, Wilson, Ozuna, etc. Not much came of most of those guys.
phinstd wrote:Did we develop Templeton? I thought he was league average-ish. To be clear, I wasn't born when we had him, or was infant-like...
Tyler Greene has a much higher ceiling than Kozma, but Kozma is more likely to reach his.
For his career, Templeton sucked. While w/ the Cards he was league average. So, I guess he would be the last. 1 SS in 30 years? Not impressive.
While looking this up I see how allergic to walking Templeton was. 5 seasons of playing everyday and a total of 87 walks in 2889 plate appearances! A season high of 22!
phinstd wrote:There is a reason we haven't been able to find a good SS yet...it's hard to do. There are just not too many players who have the athleticism, arm strength, and bat to play SS at the major league level. You also have to remember, the person must be right handed, so that thins the pool even more.
Hopefully one of these years we can either trade for one, or get one of these guys to develop into an actual above average SS. Kozma has a chance to be a league average SS, and that would be a massive upgrade to what we've had.
Yeah, if you're Jeff Luhnow and you want avoid discussions of Scott Boras and money, then this is what you're supposed to say to defend the Kozma pick. That collection of tools is hard to find, and it's probably underrated, since there's nothing to hang your hat on, as there would be with somebody like Wallace. It would be nice if Kozma's hands are better than what I saw last year. It would be even nicer if he turned into something like Polanco or Kennedy (Angels version), among the aforementioned former Cardinal prospects. The complete lack of progress in the power department bothers me; I thought his swing looked worse in July than it did in April, and now I'm left to think that my crappy scouting wasn't quite so crappy.