Page 1 of 2

Rant: When referring to Pujols...

Posted: July 17 09, 7:34 pm
by C. Johny
as "arguably" the best player in baseball. Do we still really need to say that? If you say arguably I would love to hear who you think could be better than him right now. He's easily the best player right now and probably in the last three years. I could understand saying that if 2001 Bonds was still playing or A-Rod a few years ago, but come on give the guy his do.

Does this bother anyone else? It's not really that big of a deal I just think he's so much better than everyone else right now it would be nice to hear someone say he's the best player in baseball.

Re: Rant: When referring to Pujols...

Posted: July 17 09, 7:36 pm
by Leroy
He doesn't hit enough triples.

Re: Rant: When referring to Pujols...

Posted: July 17 09, 7:39 pm
by InvincibleCakeEater
He's never even struck a guy out before.

Re: Rant: When referring to Pujols...

Posted: July 17 09, 7:43 pm
by C. Johny
Damn, you both make good points.

Re: Rant: When referring to Pujols...

Posted: July 17 09, 11:58 pm
by Cronos
Babe wins any "best" baseball argument since he could both hit AND pitch, and pretty darn well at that.

I truly believe though that Albert will be known as one of if not the best right-handed hitter in baseball history by the time he's done.

The list is growing shorter by the day as to who you can say is better.

Re: Rant: When referring to Pujols...

Posted: July 18 09, 12:05 am
by C. Johny
I'm not talking about all time. I don't even think you can say he's arguably the best of all time right now. I'm just talking about this year. He's easily the best player in baseball right now and it's not even close. I think he helped my argument after tonights game.

Re: Rant: When referring to Pujols...

Posted: July 18 09, 12:21 am
by haltz

Code: Select all

I truly believe though that Albert will be known as one of if not the best right-handed hitter in baseball history by the time he's done.
Agreed. Here's the RHH OPS+ leadboard through age 29.

Code: Select all

Cnt Player            OPS+   PA  From  To
+----+-----------------+----+-----+----+----+
    1 Rogers Hornsby     178  6617 1915 1926 
    2 Frank Thomas       174  5501 1990 1998 
    3 Albert Pujols      172  5768 2001 2009 
    4 Jimmie Foxx        169  7290 1925 1938 
    5 Dick Allen         164  5481 1963 1972 
    6 Hank Greenberg     160  4670 1930 1941 
    7 Jeff Bagwell       159  5071 1991 1998 
    8 Joe DiMaggio       159  4417 1936 1942 
    9 Willie Mays        158  5957 1951 1961 
   10 Hank Aaron         157  7216 1954 1964 
   11 Manny Ramirez      156  5233 1993 2002 
   12 Mike Piazza        156  4075 1992 1999 
   13 Ralph Kiner        155  5223 1946 1953 
   14 Frank Robinson     154  7089 1956 1966 
   15 Hack Wilson        153  3911 1923 1930 
I knew there was a reason I liked Bagwell and Thomas so much when I was a kid.

Re: Rant: When referring to Pujols...

Posted: July 18 09, 1:08 am
by cardsfansince82
I think most of the "arguably" comes from either Cardinals guys that don't want to appear overly biased or national guys that don't see him play defense every day/don't pay attention to smaller market teams. But there are plenty out there who will admit it. I still can't believe people keep ARod in the discussion. His numbers aren't all that special when they aren't coming with gold glove defense at shortstop and if you look past his homerun totals he's had several mediocre (relatively speaking) years.

haltz-I was randomly looking at Jimmie Foxx's numbers the other day. I know his career was sort of cut short, but he has to be one of the most underrated players ever. People that know baseball history obviously are aware of him, but I would bet a lot of fans today have never even heard of him and he never is mentioned in any discussion of all time greats. He put up some sick numbers and his only fault was that his career happened to overlap with some of the most famous players in history.

Re: Rant: When referring to Pujols...

Posted: July 18 09, 4:09 am
by The Third Man
I saw somebody refer to him as "arguably one of the best hitters in baseball" on another forum, and I was like "wat"

Re: Rant: When referring to Pujols...

Posted: July 18 09, 9:48 am
by Blitzer
Its just announcers being politically correct and trying not to sound biased. If you say "Pujols is THE best player in baseball" you know some yahoo is gonna spew some dumb argument about someone else, but if you say "arguably the best" I dont think there is a soul out there that can debate that.