Page 1 of 2
Concert rant
Posted: October 14 09, 8:04 pm
by Spider John
I went to a benefit concert for the Country Music Hall of Fame in Nashville last night, and it inspired me to post this rant, although these things have bothered me for years.
If I pay my money to hear you sing, then I want you to sing. Don't be pointing the mike at the crowd and letting them sing a verse or two.
Also, I want to hear your songs sung at the same tempo as on the CD, and using the same words. A particular verse may have a special meaning to someone, until you decide to change it to something we've never heard before.
So if anyone here is a touring recording artist then straighten up, sing your songs yourself, and do them the way you cut them. Thank you.
Re: Concert rant
Posted: October 14 09, 8:08 pm
by lukethedrifter
Who did you see?
I don't necessarily agree with your Rant. The way I see it is if you are a dynamic live performer, I say go to town. Sing it however you like, get the crowd involved, adapt and interpret. But if you do that [expletive] because your lazy and don't want to put forth the effort then [expletive] you.
Re: Concert rant
Posted: October 14 09, 8:43 pm
by Spider John
Keith Urban did an hour with his band, with Brad Paisley coming out to do a song during that set. Then the house band of A-list nashville musicians came out, along with Vince Gill. They backed Little Big Town, Dierks Bentley, Lady Antebellum, Jason Aldean, Faith Hill and Taylor Swift for two songs each, with a grand finale of everyone doiong "Lay Down Sally". taped for televison, had a crowd of about 14,000, with all proceeds going to the Country Music Hall Of Fame. Not much of what I would call real country music , but it wasn't a bad evening. My 15 year old daughter and her friend loved it.
Re: Concert rant
Posted: October 14 09, 8:47 pm
by lukethedrifter
Sounds like you were better off hearing the crowd sing.
Re: Concert rant
Posted: October 14 09, 8:56 pm
by Spider John
As I said, not my idea of country music.
I have noticed that some older singers will let the crowd sing when they get to notes they used to hit but can't anymore. I saw Sammy Hagar last summer, and he had to let the crowd sing a lot.
Re: Concert rant
Posted: October 15 09, 7:00 am
by tscards
Are you dissing Sammy 'Cabo Wabo' Hagar?? [-X
Re: Concert rant
Posted: October 15 09, 7:21 am
by Spider John
tscards wrote:Are you dissing Sammy 'Cabo Wabo' Hagar?? [-X
Sammy, like me, is having to make some concessions to age.
I did get to see Nicole Kidman hanging stage-side while her man was on.
Re: Concert rant
Posted: October 15 09, 3:22 pm
by TheoSqua
I disagree. If i want to hear the same lyrics and tempo with nothing changed then i'll go listen to the records i've already bought.
I go to a live show to see just that, a show. Reminds me of when I was given a ticket to go see Creed. Yeah, they sounded good. But the entire band just stood there and played every song note for note identically to the record. Some people loved that I guess, but for me it's like they're just replicated the record like zombies, i want to see some excitement, energy, interaction with the crowd, etc. Make it a concert, not a recital.
Some bands can over-do this and spend half the concert talking/ad-libbing, which is even worse. What do you expect, though? Think of some of these bands that have been around 20-30 years playing the same singles at the end of their concert. If they didn't change stuff up and have some fun with it they'd be terribly bored and tired of playing the same thing over and over and you'd probably enjoy the concert even less.
Re: Concert rant
Posted: October 15 09, 3:56 pm
by lukethedrifter
TheoSqua wrote: I was given a ticket to go see Creed. Yeah, they sounded good.
Is that possible?
/picking on Creed is easy
Re: Concert rant
Posted: October 15 09, 4:02 pm
by TheoSqua
lukethedrifter wrote:TheoSqua wrote: I was given a ticket to go see Creed. Yeah, they sounded good.
Is that possible?
/picking on Creed is easy
Creed has some very good music they just put one fairly sucky album and one really really sucky album which the radio played the hell out of between all of it.