three-man rotations
Posted: October 26 09, 11:23 am
I don't like the idea of a three-man rotation. I know that CC Sabathia threw four consecutive short-rest games last year, but they weren't against the Angels. The only way I would be in favor of the three-man rotation is if they're down going in to game four. Then I think it makes sense. If they're up 2-1 or 3-0, I think they should pitch Chad Gaudin. The risk for the Yankees in pitching Sabathia in Game 4, if they're up 2-1 and he loses, they'll have Burnett pitching in the most critical game of their career. It could swing the series dramatically in the other direction. I think players should be set up to succeed, not fail, and the track record for pitchers starting on short rest is not very good.