Page 1 of 1

Rant: Article in Time

Posted: November 10 09, 8:03 pm
by Transmogrified Tiger
Waiting to get my haircut today, I saw this nearly month old article. Link

I was stuck between angry and stupefied reading it.

Re: Rant: Article in Time

Posted: November 10 09, 10:11 pm
by Freed Roger
I haven't read the whole article, but from cursory read, sense its about the market risks involved with 401Ks that people are unawares. I think most people in the article thought of it as a pension plan, where there is a guaranty of monthly payout based typically on a % of pay they used to make and based on years of service. But a 401K is not. Its more of a tax deferred savings plan, and one that you can't generally get at until later in life without large penalties, plus taxes.

From my own experience in trying to shepherd our 401Ks thru this economic downturn - managing a 401K is not easy - and I have some background in busn. There are people that have no idea. Investment choices are vague and limited. I'll be damned if I'll read the prosepectuses or anything beyond basic research. Usually I just guess at funds from their names and description.

As someone gets older, the 401K investment mix needs to be rebalanced, more to safer assets, but who remembers that and what is really safe? So when the market turned south, people at retirement age and still had their entire 401Ks in corporate stock funds took major hits.

Thank some higher power that GOP didn't get their desire to privatize Soc Sec into glorified 401Ks. A lot of people would be up [expletive] creek. I like the idea of people taking care of their own financial destiny - but face it, many people just can't and shouldn't be handling their own retirement money. I think of many people that are generally smart in my own family that would have been screwed without their guaranteed pension.

By all means people should participate in a 401K plan especially when there is company matching. But it needs to be managed. Its not a guaranteed retirement fund.

Re: Rant: Article in Time

Posted: November 10 09, 11:00 pm
by lukethedrifter
Too bad we didn't push through privatizing SS.

Re: Rant: Article in Time

Posted: November 11 09, 12:07 am
by StatmanCrothers
i have a 401(k) but apart from that i also put a lot of my savings into treasury bonds, to balance out safe vs. agressive investments. i was very glad of this when the market dipped recently.

stock market = Milton Bradley (tremendous upside but a history of volatility. no guarantees)
bonds = Reggie Sanders (you know what you're getting. it ain't sexy but he won't melt.)

Re: Rant: Article in Time

Posted: November 11 09, 7:34 am
by Joe Shlabotnik
I thank God I have moved around enough that I've been able to take out my 401(k) into a self-directed IRA as I moved from company to company. It has given me both the benefit of employee matching - 100% most of the time, now 50% - while in the 401(k), plus the full control and options available in the IRA.

I don't understand why people CHOOSE (it is a choice!) to remain ignorant of their financial options and the control they need to weild when in 401(k) plans. It was obvious to me when I got into one the first time the 401(k) meant I had to be the one making the decisions and knowing what was going on so I learned. Made mistakes along the way but I learned.

I was late on seeing the NASDAQ bubble and lost a substantial amount in my 401(k) at the time but I learned and the housing bubble did NOT take me by surprise. I have been loaded in commodities and PM's and stable dividend plays and am weathering the storm alright. When the financial system finally pukes up the Smartest Men in the Room who got us into this mess, I'll go agressivelly into growth oriented stocks again. But there's going to be blood in the streets by then I fear.

We'll see.

Re: Rant: Article in Time

Posted: November 11 09, 10:24 am
by Molly
Freed Roger wrote:I like the idea of people taking care of their own financial destiny - but face it, many people just can't and shouldn't be handling their own retirement money.
Only good thing about hubby getting fed up and quitting his last job w/nothing else lined up. It was a struggle for about a year but he had a 401K to roll over so we now have a financial advisor!

Re: Rant: Article in Time

Posted: November 11 09, 10:33 am
by brats&beer
Why do we think it is a right or owed to us to retire anyway? Never saw anywhere where we were guaranteed the ability to retire. We need to realign our perspective here - if you can retire, great. If not, keep working until you can or you kick the ol' bucket.