Page 1 of 1
US obliviousness
Posted: February 26 10, 2:38 pm
by G. Keenan
This article makes me so angry.
The Travel Promotion Act calls for a nonprofit Corporation for Travel Promotion that will promote the United States as a travel destination and explain travel and security policies to international visitors.
A $10 fee charged to visitors from countries included in the Visa Waiver Program will partially fund the public-private organization. These visitors will pay the fee every two years when they register online using the Department of Homeland Security's Electronic System for Travel Authorization.
As an American citizen it is already bad enough that upon returning home you're treated with nothing but suspicion and contempt by US Customs and Border Patrol. As a foreigner, with all the fingerprint and biometric stuff they make you do, I can only imagine that entering the US at one of our airports is not a particularly humane experience. To top it off, all of this increased border "security" still fails to keep obvious terrorists like the Christmas bomber from getting on planes. For eight years we pissed all over our good image around the world and turned our country into a fortress of equal opportunity suspicion. And now we wonder why international tourism is down so much!
The answer? Create a govt. agency to "promote" the US as a tourist destination by explaining the security and customs procedures that are such a turn off in the first place. How to pay for this agency? Make Visa waiver tourists (the good tourists) pay a fee when they complete a Department of Homeland Security form before even getting on a plane to the US -- a form which didn't used to exist and is no doubt the latest manifestation of our security apparatus's fondness for gathering far more data than it can actually make sense of, i.e., worthless information.
This is the answer to boosting tourism? Making tourists pay to have they very system explained to them that deters them from visiting the US in the first place.
Re: US obliviousness
Posted: February 26 10, 4:26 pm
by Leroy
You just don't get it, do you?
Re: US obliviousness
Posted: February 26 10, 7:54 pm
by thrill
US Customs is the worst I've had to deal with in my limited experience, but it wasn't only because of the bureaucratic, misguided policies, but also because they were by far the stupidest, laziest mf'ers to ever stamp my passport. I had a better time trying to explain to a Hungarian woman who spoke little english how I lost my boarding pass 30 minutes before my flight than I did getting back into O'Hare.
Re: US obliviousness
Posted: February 28 10, 9:54 pm
by Hungary Jack
Most of my experiences with US immigration and customs officials have been fine, though I do recall one prickly fellow a few years back after returning from Singapore and Malaysia.
At the risk of overthinking it, I do wonder about the long-term prognosis for our country when I go to places like Singapore, Malaysia and Thailand and work with students from India, China and Korea and see the youth and entrepreneurial energy of these people, along with governments that, though dysfunctional at times, seem to be making real efforts to develop their economies in sustainable ways (OK, China is debatable on this) .
In the US, an aging domestic population and anti-immigration sentiments are a recipe for long-term economic decline. Our country needs immigrants to remain economically vibrant, and not for cheap domestic labor to mow my lawn and make my margaritas, but for starting businesses and/or going to school to contribute in the areas science, education, engineering, law, etc.
I think our nation and our government needs to be much more open to change and adopting new technologies, policies, and ways of living, rather than preserving the status quo, which seems to be the predominant political force at work in Congress nowadays.
Re: US obliviousness
Posted: February 28 10, 10:02 pm
by planet planet
Hungary Jack wrote:Most of my experiences with US immigration and customs officials have been fine, though I do recall one prickly fellow a few years back after returning from Singapore and Malaysia.
At the risk of overthinking it, I do wonder about the long-term prognosis for our country when I go to places like Singapore, Malaysia and Thailand and work with students from India, China and Korea and see the youth and entrepreneurial energy of these people, along with governments that, though dysfunctional at times, seem to be making real efforts to develop their economies in sustainable ways (OK, China is debatable on this) .
In the US, an aging domestic population and anti-immigration sentiments are a recipe for long-term economic decline. Our country needs immigrants to remain economically vibrant, and not for cheap domestic labor to mow my lawn and make my margaritas, but for starting businesses and/or going to school to contribute in the areas science, education, engineering, law, etc.
I think our nation and our government needs to be much more open to change and adopting new technologies, policies, and ways of living, rather than preserving the status quo, which seems to be the predominant political force at work in Congress nowadays.
Really? You might disagree with the no. of immigrants granted visas, but assimilating newcomers is one of the most sustainable US qualities. Little pockets and/or temporary ebbs and flows of xenophobia doesn't change that. And compared to the rich world, our aging population is less of an issue, primarily because of our relatively high birth rate.
Re: US obliviousness
Posted: February 28 10, 10:28 pm
by Radbird
My daughter said coming home from Europe through Customs at Dulles last week was terrible. Very disorganized, lines without signs or people telling you where to go and then snippy agents when you asked questions or guessed wrong. She said it was hard for her to figure it out as an American, and guessed some of the foreign arrivees, based on some of the faces she saw, were having a really rough time.
Re: US obliviousness
Posted: March 1 10, 2:51 am
by Hungary Jack
planet pujolsian wrote:Hungary Jack wrote:Most of my experiences with US immigration and customs officials have been fine, though I do recall one prickly fellow a few years back after returning from Singapore and Malaysia.
At the risk of overthinking it, I do wonder about the long-term prognosis for our country when I go to places like Singapore, Malaysia and Thailand and work with students from India, China and Korea and see the youth and entrepreneurial energy of these people, along with governments that, though dysfunctional at times, seem to be making real efforts to develop their economies in sustainable ways (OK, China is debatable on this) .
In the US, an aging domestic population and anti-immigration sentiments are a recipe for long-term economic decline. Our country needs immigrants to remain economically vibrant, and not for cheap domestic labor to mow my lawn and make my margaritas, but for starting businesses and/or going to school to contribute in the areas science, education, engineering, law, etc.
I think our nation and our government needs to be much more open to change and adopting new technologies, policies, and ways of living, rather than preserving the status quo, which seems to be the predominant political force at work in Congress nowadays.
Really? You might disagree with the no. of immigrants granted visas, but assimilating newcomers is one of the most sustainable US qualities. Little pockets and/or temporary ebbs and flows of xenophobia doesn't change that. And compared to the rich world, our aging population is less of an issue, primarily because of our relatively high birth rate.
I agree that most newcomers assimilate quite well, though I am sure there are those who would argue the contrary. And it is a great part of this country. And while our national birthrate is still well ahead of most developed nations, it is up only slightly from historic lows reached at the beginning of the last decade. This, with increasing lifespans, puts increasing pressure on public pension systems.
My main concern is the relative lack of economic vitality I see in the US compared with Asia's developing nations. It is mostly anecdotal, but the huge consumer markets of India and Asia will soon give these nations advantages that the US enjoyed for several decades.
Re: US obliviousness
Posted: March 1 10, 10:27 am
by AdmiralKird
Yes, but Asia is going to need increasing supplies of energy and water if it expects to maintain this growth rate. Not sure where they're going to get it.
Re: US obliviousness
Posted: March 1 10, 8:34 pm
by Hungary Jack
AdmiralKird wrote:Yes, but Asia is going to need increasing supplies of energy and water if it expects to maintain this growth rate. Not sure where they're going to get it.
I think they will be able to deal with these problems, in part because they don't have entrenched interests like they do here in the states.
One of the business plans I looked at in Singapore was a 5MW solar plant in the state of Tamil Nadu in India. The government was about ready to award licenses for up to 50 MW of solar power, and one of my students hoped to obtain it. He claimed he could be opertional within 6 months.