Page 1 of 5

America: The Story of Us

Posted: April 25 10, 7:44 pm
by G. Keenan
Hmm. I've been looking forward to this for a few weeks but so far instead of historians we've heard from Colin Powell, Donald Trump, Rudy Giuliani, Michael Douglas, Aaron Sorkin and that random dude from Future Weapons. WTF? I really don't care what the likes of Donald Trump and Rudy Giuliani think about American "character," especially as it existed 250-300 years ago.

Real scholars please.

Re: America: The Story of Us

Posted: April 25 10, 8:41 pm
by InvincibleCakeEater
I think I just saw the Geico caveman.

Re: America: The Story of Us

Posted: April 25 10, 8:45 pm
by Freed Roger
saw the ad -is this the history show with CGI?

Re: America: The Story of Us

Posted: April 25 10, 8:46 pm
by JackofDiamonds
I've been disappointed so far. This is your 3rd grade history book in HD.

Re: America: The Story of Us

Posted: April 25 10, 8:47 pm
by G. Keenan
Freed Roger wrote:saw the ad -is this the history show with CGI?
Yeah, there's lots of gimmicky effects.

Re: America: The Story of Us

Posted: April 25 10, 8:58 pm
by Freed Roger
I think I saw this series back as a youngster in the 70s

[youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kfM1t9o4 ... re=related][/youtube]


Image

Re: America: The Story of Us

Posted: April 25 10, 9:50 pm
by Tambourine Man
Yeesh, this is pretty awful. I had it pegged as "must see" and JOD summed it up about right.

Now if it ends with Ryan Braun coming out of the closet, the show can totally redeem itself.

Re: America: The Story of Us

Posted: April 26 10, 7:54 am
by Fat Strat
Colin Powell, Donald Trump, Rudy Giuliani, Michael Douglas, Aaron Sorkin and that random dude from Future Weapons. WTF? I really don't care what the likes of Donald Trump and Rudy Giuliani think about American "character," especially as it existed 250-300 years ago.
Michael Douglas is world's foremost authority on early American settlers. Everyone knows this.



I agree that it's stupid to have these celebrities on there. I do think the show is otherwise ok. The CGI is annoying, but hopefully they'll limit it to stuff they can't really shoot. The history is pretty 5th grade, but I guess I expected that and it doesn't bother me.

Re: America: The Story of Us

Posted: April 26 10, 9:12 am
by Spider John
I especially enjoyed the underwater view of the keels of the British ships coming toward America.

It's as if they are playing to the lowest common denominator of intelligence.

Re: America: The Story of Us

Posted: April 26 10, 11:45 am
by Hungary Jack
Maybe the series is saying that Americans are a bunch of dumb celebrity idol-worshipping sycophants who possess the intellect of a soap opera hero with a world view spawned from wild west cinema of black hats and white hats.