Page 1 of 3

Batting the pitcher 8th gets the Cards again

Posted: April 27 10, 8:19 pm
by Its about time
If Carp is batting where he should be Ryan would have been up with the bases loaded and Carp would still be pitching.I bet nobody will question Tony about this either

Re: Batting the pitcher 8th gets the Cards again

Posted: April 27 10, 8:21 pm
by lukethedrifter
Its about time wrote:If Carp is batting where he should be Ryan would have been up with the bases loaded and Carp would still be pitching.I bet nobody will question Tony about this either

Go back to sleep.

Re: Batting the pitcher 8th gets the Cards again

Posted: April 27 10, 8:22 pm
by Its about time
Wow thanks for posting Mrs. Larussa

Re: Batting the pitcher 8th gets the Cards again

Posted: April 27 10, 8:23 pm
by stlouie_lipp
crickets...

Re: Batting the pitcher 8th gets the Cards again

Posted: April 27 10, 8:27 pm
by lukethedrifter
lukethedrifter wrote:
Its about time wrote:If Carp is batting where he should be Ryan would have been up with the bases loaded and Carp would still be pitching.I bet nobody will question Tony about this either

Go back to sleep.

http://gatewayredbirds.com/forum/viewto ... =9&t=40447

Re: Batting the pitcher 8th gets the Cards again

Posted: April 27 10, 8:44 pm
by obucard
But would Carp have led off the inning with a single?

Re: Batting the pitcher 8th gets the Cards again

Posted: April 27 10, 9:04 pm
by TheoSqua
It makes sense, i'm not sure why people hate the idea.

It effectively puts Albert in the 4th spot in the lineup, but allows him to bat in the 1st inning.

Just pretend like the game is starting with the #2 hitter and you'll feel better.

Re: Batting the pitcher 8th gets the Cards again

Posted: April 27 10, 9:14 pm
by haltz
Obviously it's not going to be a good thing every time through the order, but it's a net positive. If you've already made up your mind that it's a bad thing and don't want to look at the evidence saying it's a good thing, you can easily point out every situation where it doesn't work out in your favor. You'll spend a lot of time doing this because the difference in hitting the pitcher 8th vs 9th is marginal.

Re: Batting the pitcher 8th gets the Cards again

Posted: April 27 10, 9:17 pm
by AWvsCBsteeeerike3
I agree, also, Mark McGwire is a horrible hitting coach. Look at his biggest proponents (Ryan, Skip, Holliday and Freese). For [expletive] sake, they're all underperforming and Skip and Ryan are under the freaking Mendoza line.

Hello, when is management going to wake up and get some coaches that know what they're doing. I mean, HELLO!

Re: Batting the pitcher 8th gets the Cards again

Posted: April 27 10, 9:18 pm
by Hungary Jack
If the Hindenburg had been filled with helium instead of hydrogen...