Page 1 of 4

Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 10:44 am
by KyCardinalFan
Image

I am so tired of hearing this by sports announcers and tv pundits when, given their actual context, usually mean inarguably.

I have noticed this on ESPN broadcasts and said a lot by Dan; for example, a stat will be cited and Dan will say something like, "Given those numbers, he is arguably the best in baseball right now." Right Dan, only an idiot would argue that, because it's obvious - to even a non-stat person like me!

This is just overuse and laziness by people, along the lines of the incorrect "could care less", it's been abbreviated to where it's wrong.

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 10:45 am
by Leroy
No argument here.

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 11:02 am
by thrill
This is arguably the best rant started today.

Another along the same lines is "I could care less."

As in, "I could care less where LeBron James signs."

Really? Are you saying that it would be possible for something to happen to make you care less or are you trying to say, "I couldn't care less?"

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 11:07 am
by planet planet
But aren't they saying that it is arguable for some people? They used to say that all the time when Arod was neck and neck with Albert. I think the habit has just stuck.

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 11:18 am
by vinsanity
Wasn't there an argument based on WAR, positional scarcity and defense Chase Utley was a 'better player'?

In sports it's pretty tough to say that hands down so-and-so is the best player.

Bron puts up better numbers, Kobe wins more rings.

Brady throws more TD's and more Rings than Peyton, but Peyton has better peripherals (I think).

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 11:41 am
by KyCardinalFan
planet pujolsian wrote:But aren't they saying that it is arguable for some people? They used to say that all the time when Arod was neck and neck with Albert. I think the habit has just stuck.
The first few times, I thought this and didn't think much of the comments. But as the season has gone on I have listened more to the context and more often than not their statements are really inarguable.

I'm counting on this rant getting more comments as the season continues and I have made it stick in your head. However, I expect the rants to be more like, "Dammit, KCF! Why'd you make me aware of this!" At the very least, I hope some of you are able to make a drinking game of it.

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 11:53 am
by The Third Man
The best example of this I can think of was when Wikipedia's article on Pujols referred to him as "arguably one of the best hitters in baseball."

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 11:54 am
by vinsanity
The Third Man wrote:The best example of this I can think of was when Wikipedia's article on Pujols referred to him as "arguably one of the best hitters in baseball."
This one makes sense.

He is definitely one of the best hitters in baseball.

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 12:04 pm
by Spider John
vinsanity wrote:
The Third Man wrote:The best example of this I can think of was when Wikipedia's article on Pujols referred to him as "arguably one of the best hitters in baseball."
This one makes sense.

He is definitely one of the best hitters in baseball.
There's no argument that he's one of the best, but Wiki says the fact is arguable.

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 12:06 pm
by vinsanity
Spider John wrote:
vinsanity wrote:
The Third Man wrote:The best example of this I can think of was when Wikipedia's article on Pujols referred to him as "arguably one of the best hitters in baseball."
This one makes sense.

He is definitely one of the best hitters in baseball.
There's no argument that he's one of the best, but Wiki says the fact is arguable.
I meant that one makes sense as part of the rant. My bad.