Page 1 of 2

LTTP: The Sopranos

Posted: August 24 10, 5:17 pm
by The Third Man
I decided to catch up with the rest of the world and watch The Sopranos. The only other TV serial drama I've ever watched is The Wire. I liked it enough to blitz through the series in about 2.5 weeks. I'll get some complaints out of the way first:

-Too many useless or underdeveloped subplots, not enough of an overall arc. Sometimes it felt meandering and aimless, and too self-contained on an episode-to-episode basis. This also led to some bloat - it ran, what, 90 episodes, and probably could've been 70 to 75 if it were tightened up.
-Too repetitive of its own format: new character shows up, causes problems, dies, etc. This led to - for me - some big character deaths not resonating as strongly as you'd hope.
-The dream sequences. Some were good (and I really liked the coma ones), but too many were trite and shallow, and led to obnoxious psychoanalytic exposition during the scenes with Melfi.

Other than that...fantastic. Great performances across the board, tons of memorable characters, a good balance of family drama and mob stuff, lots of comedy, etc.

That second-to-last episode was as gut-wrenching as anything I'd ever seen - everything finally coming to a close and they really made things feel utterly despairing. I had no problems with the infamous ending, but I knew it (or at least, the cut-to-black aspect of it) going in, so that might shade my impression. Still, I liked it.

Re: LTTP: The Sopranos

Posted: August 24 10, 5:20 pm
by Popeye_Card
TV shows spanning multiple years (almost a decade for Sopranos?), multiple writers, etc. probably suffer a bit from the bloat you speak of whenever you sit down and try to watch them all in a short time frame. Watching them spaced a week apart by episode, and years apart by season--it isn't nearly as noticable.

Re: LTTP: The Sopranos

Posted: August 24 10, 5:30 pm
by The Third Man
That's true. On the other hand, I never felt that way about The Wire, but a lot of people consider that the gold-standard of TV so I'm probably being unfair. Again, I have little TV drama experience so that's the only baseline comparison I can really make.

Nitpicking, though. Great show.

Re: LTTP: The Sopranos

Posted: August 24 10, 5:32 pm
by JackofDiamonds
The Third Man wrote:That's true. On the other hand, I never felt that way about The Wire, but a lot of people consider that the gold-standard of TV so I'm probably being unfair. Again, I have little TV drama experience so that's the only baseline comparison I can really make.

Nitpicking, though. Great show.
The Wire was planned out in its entirety by one writer though, right?

Re: LTTP: The Sopranos

Posted: August 24 10, 5:52 pm
by G. Keenan
JackofDiamonds wrote:
The Third Man wrote:That's true. On the other hand, I never felt that way about The Wire, but a lot of people consider that the gold-standard of TV so I'm probably being unfair. Again, I have little TV drama experience so that's the only baseline comparison I can really make.

Nitpicking, though. Great show.
The Wire was planned out in its entirety by one writer though, right?
Not as far as I know. The show had lots of different writers. David Simon and Ed Burns wrote the majority of the episodes but a quick look at IMDB shows 9 other writers who combined contributed to 44 episodes.

Re: LTTP: The Sopranos

Posted: August 24 10, 5:57 pm
by JackofDiamonds
G. Keenan wrote:
JackofDiamonds wrote:
The Third Man wrote:That's true. On the other hand, I never felt that way about The Wire, but a lot of people consider that the gold-standard of TV so I'm probably being unfair. Again, I have little TV drama experience so that's the only baseline comparison I can really make.

Nitpicking, though. Great show.
The Wire was planned out in its entirety by one writer though, right?
Not as far as I know. The show had lots of different writers. David Simon and Ed Burns wrote the majority of the episodes but a quick look at IMDB shows 9 other writers who combined wrote 44 episodes.
Sorry, I am not being clear. David Simon crafted the story line from start to finish, wrote the majority of the episodes with Burns, and then worked with the other writers for the other 44. Simon had a storyline established before the series started, as opposed to the Sopranos, which appeared to be more ad-hoc.

Re: LTTP: The Sopranos

Posted: August 24 10, 6:04 pm
by G. Keenan
JackofDiamonds wrote:
G. Keenan wrote:
JackofDiamonds wrote:
The Third Man wrote:That's true. On the other hand, I never felt that way about The Wire, but a lot of people consider that the gold-standard of TV so I'm probably being unfair. Again, I have little TV drama experience so that's the only baseline comparison I can really make.

Nitpicking, though. Great show.
The Wire was planned out in its entirety by one writer though, right?
Not as far as I know. The show had lots of different writers. David Simon and Ed Burns wrote the majority of the episodes but a quick look at IMDB shows 9 other writers who combined wrote 44 episodes.
Sorry, I am not being clear. David Simon crafted the story line from start to finish, wrote the majority of the episodes with Burns, and then worked with the other writers for the other 44. Simon had a storyline established before the series started, as opposed to the Sopranos, which appeared to be more ad-hoc.
Gotcha. Agreed, The Wire definitely benefited from having a well conceived story arc and narrative goals to begin with. Most shows just see how long they can stay on the air and do whatever it takes to prolong that and, naturally, the quality suffers.

Re: LTTP: The Sopranos

Posted: August 24 10, 6:21 pm
by JL21
Gotcha. Agreed, The Wire definitely benefited from having a well conceived story arc and narrative goals to begin with. Most shows just see how long they can stay on the air and do whatever it takes to prolong that and, naturally, the quality suffers.
That's where Breaking Bad is right now. If they do it just right, they can have four incredible seasons- maybe five- and ride off into the sunset as one of the best shows around. Or... they can bloat and get six seasons and cheapen the quality. Vince Gilligan has hinted strongly that he doesn't want to do that. As it stands, for me anyway, it's quickly approaching The Sopranos as my favorite show.

Re: LTTP: The Sopranos

Posted: August 24 10, 6:38 pm
by thrill
G. Keenan wrote:
JackofDiamonds wrote:
G. Keenan wrote:
JackofDiamonds wrote:
The Third Man wrote:That's true. On the other hand, I never felt that way about The Wire, but a lot of people consider that the gold-standard of TV so I'm probably being unfair. Again, I have little TV drama experience so that's the only baseline comparison I can really make.

Nitpicking, though. Great show.
The Wire was planned out in its entirety by one writer though, right?
Not as far as I know. The show had lots of different writers. David Simon and Ed Burns wrote the majority of the episodes but a quick look at IMDB shows 9 other writers who combined wrote 44 episodes.
Sorry, I am not being clear. David Simon crafted the story line from start to finish, wrote the majority of the episodes with Burns, and then worked with the other writers for the other 44. Simon had a storyline established before the series started, as opposed to the Sopranos, which appeared to be more ad-hoc.
Gotcha. Agreed, The Wire definitely benefited from having a well conceived story arc and narrative goals to begin with. Most shows just see how long they can stay on the air and do whatever it takes to prolong that and, naturally, the quality suffers.
Dennis Lehane wrote on The Wire too. That's an impressive staff.

Re: LTTP: The Sopranos

Posted: August 24 10, 8:11 pm
by lukethedrifter
I don't think using lots of different writers and not knowing how long your series is going to last is an excuse for plot lines that simply fade away and others with gaping holes. The Sopranos was a flawed yet fantastic and groundbreaking TV series.