Page 1 of 1

'09 v. '10 US Budget

Posted: October 21 10, 9:42 am
by planet planet
I was reading this article and I found the part about Bush's approved '09 budget being $122 billion more than Obama's approved '10 budget interesting. Is this true? What kind of hairs are they splitting or what is that statement omitting? I just find it hard to believe.

Re: '09 v. '10 US Budget

Posted: October 21 10, 10:58 am
by Arthur Dent
The article seems to confuse total spending and the deficit though both are down in 2010. You can look all this up easily here:

http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/

The deficit was reduced $119 billion from 2009 to 2010 and total spending decreased $62 billion.

Never, never, never trust conventional wisdom in politics. Recall that the TARP was a Bush program. That said, the TARP money should not really be considered like other budget items as the government purchased assets with the money and is getting a large part of it back on sale.

Re: '09 v. '10 US Budget

Posted: October 21 10, 12:17 pm
by planet planet
Arthur Dent wrote:The article seems to confuse total spending and the deficit though both are down in 2010. You can look all this up easily here:

http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/

The deficit was reduced $119 billion from 2009 to 2010 and total spending decreased $62 billion.

Never, never, never trust conventional wisdom in politics. Recall that the TARP was a Bush program. That said, the TARP money should not really be considered like other budget items as the government purchased assets with the money and is getting a large part of it back on sale.
If I were running for office, you could be my Karl Rove any day, AD.

Re: '09 v. '10 US Budget

Posted: October 21 10, 3:21 pm
by AdmiralKird
Arthur Dent wrote: Never, never, never trust conventional wisdom in politics. Recall that the TARP was a Bush program. That said, the TARP money should not really be considered like other budget items as the government purchased assets with the money and is getting a large part of it back on sale.
Large Part? It had earned itself back plus interest - and this was during the Spring. Not only interest, but above average rates of return normally unobtainable by a governmental entity.

Re: '09 v. '10 US Budget

Posted: October 21 10, 3:44 pm
by cpebbles
AdmiralKird wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote: Never, never, never trust conventional wisdom in politics. Recall that the TARP was a Bush program. That said, the TARP money should not really be considered like other budget items as the government purchased assets with the money and is getting a large part of it back on sale.
Large Part? It had earned itself back plus interest - and this was during the Spring. Not only interest, but above average rates of return normally unobtainable by a governmental entity.
It was profitable, if you ignore the money pumped into the auto industry, the GSEs, and intangible "stimulus" projects which helped greatly to keep the banks from officially going insolvent, and the inflationary effects of the massive amounts of currency the government put into circulation.