Page 1 of 2

Another Town Ranking list

Posted: October 27 10, 2:18 pm
by Freed Roger
And this time its Forbes Best Small Towns to Raise A Family.


Rant:
IMO lists such as these can be pretty much useless. Way too many intangibles or stats not factored in.
I see no weight given to recreational opportunities -parks, trails, arts, etc. Or what about proximity to larger cities that have an airport of substance, and the perks of the larger town's sports, hospitals, rec, and art venues. Isn't their a better measurement of quality of education than HS grad rates? Unemployment rates seem pretty cut and dried - but one town they mention in the article has low unemployment thanks to their prison jobs. No mention of crime rates -especially crimes related to children.

Rave -My old hometown made the list!

Re: Another Town Ranking list

Posted: October 27 10, 2:26 pm
by sighyoung
I look at a list like that and wonder, "Would those towns really welcome us?" I could be wrong, but I suspect many wouldn't.

Re: Another Town Ranking list

Posted: October 27 10, 2:39 pm
by Freed Roger
from the comments section to article.
Posted by rojoe10 | 10/26/10 11:17 PM EDT
I LIVE IN A SMALL TOWN IN MS,KOSCIUSKO,MS WE HAVE A GOOD POLICE DEPEMENT,AND FIRE DEPT,TOO, GOOD PLACE TO,RASE YOUR KIDS,CRIME, IS DOWN IN OURS CITY,WE HAVE GOOD SCHOOL,AND PARK,TO IT WAS VOTE THE #1 TOWN IN THE UNITED STATES TO LIVE,R,C,

Re: Another Town Ranking list

Posted: October 27 10, 2:41 pm
by thrill
Wisconsin and Michigan represent hard.

Re: Another Town Ranking list

Posted: October 27 10, 3:15 pm
by Radbird
sighyoung wrote:I look at a list like that and wonder, "Would those towns really welcome us?" I could be wrong, but I suspect many wouldn't.
Interesting question, sigh. Wisconsin is pretty lilly white once you get outside Milwaukee (and to a lesser extent, Madison). The demographics for my wife's hometown up in the Northwoods is 97.8% White (with 1.0% of that Hispanic), 0.2% Black, 0.8 % Native American, 0.4 % Asian, 0.8% two or more races. That said, I have sensed about the same level of intolerance there that I find in Denver or St. Louis (and granted, as much as someone can who is part of the 98% majority could determine that). The only group that I've heard vocally bashed with any regularity up there are the Hmong Asian population and those revolve around hunting incidents.

5 shooting incidents, 1 fatality in Wisconsin deer hunt

Hunter kills six, wounds two after tree-stand dispute

Re: Another Town Ranking list

Posted: October 27 10, 6:21 pm
by KyCardinalFan
sighyoung wrote:I look at a list like that and wonder, "Would those towns really welcome us?" I could be wrong, but I suspect many wouldn't.
Not even Frankfort?!

Re: Another Town Ranking list

Posted: October 27 10, 7:07 pm
by JL21
I've been to more than half of the cities on that list. The only two that have me scratching my head a bit are Warsaw, IN and Dubuque. Glad to see Mankato get some love.

Re: Another Town Ranking list

Posted: October 27 10, 7:11 pm
by sighyoung
KyCardinalFan wrote:
sighyoung wrote:I look at a list like that and wonder, "Would those towns really welcome us?" I could be wrong, but I suspect many wouldn't.
Not even Frankfort?!
I wondered about Frankfort. My parents met there when they attended Kentucky State University. I really don't know.

Re: Another Town Ranking list

Posted: October 27 10, 9:18 pm
by KyCardinalFan
Actually, I don't know about Frankfort either. My sister works there but lives in Louisville. The first time she got a job in Frankfort, she was preparing to move there and had a bunch of coworkers say to not move there, most people commute from Lexington or Louisville.

Re: Another Town Ranking list

Posted: October 28 10, 9:02 am
by lukethedrifter
Least-Heat Moon said Frankfort was a lovely town.