Page 1 of 3
Randy Shannon is out
Posted: November 28 10, 9:18 am
by phins
Randy Shannon was fired yesterday after going 28-22 at the U. 24-22 against I-A schools, and 16-16 versus the ACC with Duke in their side of the conference.
Mark May afterwards saying that isn't 2002, Miami thinks too much of themselves. I didn't realize 2002 was that long ago for one, and for two, going 5-7, 7-6, 9-4, 7-5 isn't hard to do.
Larry Coker went 52-9 and was fired, what did Randy think would happen?
Re: Randy Shannon is out
Posted: November 28 10, 10:30 am
by Transmogrified Tiger
So the guy improves in each of his first 3 seasons, then backslides a bit when his starting QB gets hurt and misses nearly half the season, and he's a clear cut candidate for the gallows? I'm sure there are reasons not to like Shannon as a coach, but if you want to look at the macro view like that, it seems pretty hasty to fire him when he doesn't get the chance to coach a team of entirely his players.
Re: Randy Shannon is out
Posted: November 28 10, 12:38 pm
by phins
Transmogrified Tiger wrote:So the guy improves in each of his first 3 seasons, then backslides a bit when his starting QB gets hurt and misses nearly half the season, and he's a clear cut candidate for the gallows? I'm sure there are reasons not to like Shannon as a coach, but if you want to look at the macro view like that, it seems pretty hasty to fire him when he doesn't get the chance to coach a team of entirely his players.
Where has he improved? He loses to inferior teams every year, never competes against ranked teams, and is .500 in a mediocre conference.
This is year four, these are all his players. He lost to Virginia, one of the worst BCS teams in all of football. He lost to a South Florida team with a walk-on true freshman, backup QB playing, at home, on Senior day.
I say again, he is 24-22 against I-A teams AT MIAMI!!!!! He's a terrible game coach, and it showed. Worst coaching record at Miami since 1979. Time to go!
18 starters returning, and he still regressed...I'm baffled you'd say on a macro level he has done a solid job.
Re: Randy Shannon is out
Posted: November 28 10, 12:48 pm
by Transmogrified Tiger
phins wrote:Transmogrified Tiger wrote:So the guy improves in each of his first 3 seasons, then backslides a bit when his starting QB gets hurt and misses nearly half the season, and he's a clear cut candidate for the gallows? I'm sure there are reasons not to like Shannon as a coach, but if you want to look at the macro view like that, it seems pretty hasty to fire him when he doesn't get the chance to coach a team of entirely his players.
Where has he improved? He loses to inferior teams every year, never competes against ranked teams, and is .500 in a mediocre conference.
This is year four, these are all his players. He lost to Virginia, one of the worst BCS teams in all of football. He lost to a South Florida team with a walk-on true freshman, backup QB playing, at home, on Senior day.
I say again, he is 24-22 against I-A teams AT MIAMI!!!!! He's a terrible game coach, and it showed. Worst coaching record at Miami since 1979. Time to go!
18 starters returning, and he still regressed...I'm baffled you'd say on a macro level he has done a solid job.
Is it really much of a stretch to say they probably beat Virginia and South Florida with Harris? That would mean they're an injury away from back to back 9 win seasons with a shot at 10 and the first year of entirely his players next year. Again, I don't know much about Shannon, but using W-L record to justify his firing seems pretty hasty.
Re: Randy Shannon is out
Posted: November 28 10, 1:09 pm
by phins
Did you know Harris played the entire second half against S Florida? Did you know he threw the int at the end of regulation in FG range to send it to OT? It was a coach's decision to play Morris. He's also a better QB according to most within the program. Harris also started the game against Virginia and led them to zero points. He was hurt on, you guessed it, throwing an interception.
Shannon won 7 games against ranked teams in his tenure, only twice did they beat a team that was actually ranked at the end of the season. Virginia Tech, a few years back, and Georgia Tech last year. Oklahoma ended up being a shell of itself, Florida St lost 6 games, and Clemson has a bunch of losses this year.
You had a lot of ifs in your statement. They DID lose those games, and to FAR inferior talent. S Florida had two players on it's team offered a scholarship by Miami (Ryne Giddens and Kayvon Webster), and a true frshman, walk-on QB playing. That team beat Miami on their home field, on Senior Day.
5 wins, one against a I-AA team. 7 wins, one against a I-AA team, 9 wins, with no wins over a team ranked at end of season, and 7 wins, with no wins over a team currently ranked. Lost 48-0 in final Orange Bowl game to Virginia. Lost 42-17 at home against Florida St this year (with Harris), lost by a ton to Ohio State this year (with Harris), and with 18 starters back he continued the NOVEMBER slide. his teams reversed at the end of the year each year, and couldn't beat good teams.
That's pretty damning evidence.
Re: Randy Shannon is out
Posted: November 28 10, 2:28 pm
by clevername
he's also a horrible recruiter in an area where recruits literally fall into your laps.
Sad to see him go.
Re: Randy Shannon is out
Posted: November 28 10, 4:44 pm
by JunkBondTrader
I don't understand the self-righteousness from pundits when a coach gets fired.
Re: Randy Shannon is out
Posted: November 28 10, 6:44 pm
by Lesson
Gruden's going to the U:
http://www.nationalfootballpost.com/Rep ... Miami.html
If Jon Gruden indeed leaves ESPN’s Monday Night Football booth, it may not be for an NFL head coaching job after all.
According to Lake Lewis of Sports Journey Broadcast Network on his Twitter page, the former Oakland Raiders and Tampa Bay Bucs head coach will take over for the dismissed Randy Shannon at Miami.
The reported deal would be worth roughly $3 million per season.
Lewis cited a credible source for the news in another Tweet:
My scoop on Gruden to UM is from a credible source I respect who is a former ESPN radio guy and also another scoop is a UM great. No lies here...
Whether or not the report is true, there’s no question that Miami’s administration is looking to make a splash with this hire, and Gruden would give the Hurricanes a fiery, offensive leader — essentially the opposite of the ousted Shannon.
It obviously seems to be too soon for Miami to have a replacement for Shannon set in stone, and the 'Canes are expected to have a thorough national search. But at the very least, could Gruden be the top contender for the opening?
Re: Randy Shannon is out
Posted: November 28 10, 6:57 pm
by clevername
I wouldn't say that's confirmed yet, but there are rumors out there.
I think it's an interesting choice, but ultimately I don't think he's going to work in the college game. Players had a hard enough time with his system and personality in the NFL, college will be even more difficult for that. He'll get a good recruiting class or two based on his name, but if the players can't actually execute his system he's going to have to actively recruit and charm and word is he's not likely to be so great at that.
If I were Miami I'd be going after a more established college coach like Gary Patterson.
Re: Randy Shannon is out
Posted: November 28 10, 10:58 pm
by cardsfansince82
clevername wrote:he's also a horrible recruiter in an area where recruits literally fall into your laps.
Sad to see him go.
He had arguably the best class in 2008 and solid top 15 classes every other year. Quarterback play and Shannon's ineptitude on gameday have been the problem.