Page 1 of 3
Hockey fights and head injuries
Posted: March 13 11, 5:57 pm
by PujolJunkie
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/sports/h ... 428/page1/
Opinion article, obviously, but I'm really torn on the whole article. Physicality is a part of any sport. Period. That's why it's a sport.
The author is a former NHL goaltender as well. Whether that's notable or not.
Re: Hockey fights and head injuries
Posted: March 14 11, 10:22 am
by lukethedrifter
PujolJunkie wrote:http://www.theglobeandmail.com/sports/h ... 428/page1/
Opinion article, obviously, but I'm really torn on the whole article. Physicality is a part of any sport. Period. That's why it's a sport.
The author is a former NHL goaltender as well. Whether that's notable or not.
I can't believe they made the Aztecs quit playing that basketball-like game where they cut off a guy's head and tried to throw it through a hoop. And that PC decision to end the fun and games at the Coliseum, Christians vs lions, etc. Ridiculous.
Re: Hockey fights and head injuries
Posted: March 14 11, 10:27 am
by thrill
Fighting is illegal on almost every level other than the NHL. Get rid of it. It does nothing that the sport couldn't live without.
Re: Hockey fights and head injuries
Posted: March 14 11, 11:00 am
by longhornbaseball
thrill wrote:Fighting is illegal on almost every level other than the NHL. Get rid of it. It does nothing that the sport couldn't live without.
Fighting is great when David Backes or Chris Stewart fight. I could live without super Cammy trying to justify his roster spot in staged, right after the puck is dropped BS.
Being all kinds of awesome is a given, obviously, but is my new avatar too NSFW.
Re: Hockey fights and head injuries
Posted: March 14 11, 11:02 am
by lukethedrifter
longhornbaseball wrote:thrill wrote:Fighting is illegal on almost every level other than the NHL. Get rid of it. It does nothing that the sport couldn't live without.
Fighting is great when David Backes or Chris Stewart fight. I could live without super Cammy trying to justify his roster spot in staged, right after the puck is dropped BS.
But if you know it's causing guys permanent brain injury even though it's great, are you willing to give it up?
Re: Hockey fights and head injuries
Posted: March 14 11, 11:05 am
by longhornbaseball
lukethedrifter wrote:But if you know it's causing guys permanent brain injury even though it's great, are you willing to give it up?
I don't think a fight every 20 games or so is enough to give someone permanent brain damage. Like I said, I could live without "enforcers." I don't know how you'd take away the bad fighting and leave the good, though.
Re: Hockey fights and head injuries
Posted: March 14 11, 11:06 am
by thrill
longhornbaseball wrote:Fighting is great when David Backes or Chris Stewart fight.
Yeah I love it when a guy who can score can also hit and fight his own fights, but my enjoyment of the game wouldn't lessen one bit if it was gone.
The argument is that it's a way to police dirty hits, but as evidenced by Perron, Crosby etc, they still happen.
Re: Hockey fights and head injuries
Posted: March 14 11, 11:31 am
by lukethedrifter
longhornbaseball wrote:lukethedrifter wrote:But if you know it's causing guys permanent brain injury even though it's great, are you willing to give it up?
I don't think a fight every 20 games or so is enough to give someone permanent brain damage. Like I said, I could live without "enforcers." I don't know how you'd take away the bad fighting and leave the good, though.
Right. But what I'm saying is if they learn that it- fighting 4 to 6 x/season- really does contribute significantly to permanent brain damage then as a fan are you willing to concede?
I think you have to look at it that way. And I'm not saying that it does, just that one has to be willing to give if the evidence says it's just too dangerous.
Re: Hockey fights and head injuries
Posted: March 14 11, 12:39 pm
by jim
FIghting in hockey ruins the sport imo. It's so stupid that they allow it to continue.
Re: Hockey fights and head injuries
Posted: March 14 11, 2:29 pm
by Hungary Jack
I don't mind fighting in the NHL, provided the guys who are supposed to fight do the fighting. It's like getting a bonus boxing match thrown in the with the hockey game.