My wife called me at work last Thursday to tell me the car died. I was in a meeting, so I was somewhat distracted. I told her to call AAA and get it towed to our normal, trustworthy mechanic. On the way home from work, it dawned on me the car may still be under warranty (it is a 2009 Nissan Versa). The same thought occurred to the mechanic. He looked into it, and it was under warranty. At first glance, he suspected the problem was a failed fuel pump, but wasn’t sure. He felt we should have it towed to the dealer to have them diagnose it and fix it since it was under warranty. This is where things go haywire.
My wife called the dealer, and they told her it was not covered by warranty. So then the mechanic called the dealer, and they got the same story. Page 4 of the owner’s manual specifically states that the fuel pump is covered by the powertrain warranty. Yes, it actually says the words “Fuel Pump” right there in black and white. So then the mechanic called the other Nissan dealer across town, and they said “Yes, bring it in, the fuel pump is covered.” WTF???
Now, there is 2nd story that happened in parallel with this. It gets worse. We also purchased a service agreement from the dealer back when we bought the car. (Aside: I clearly remember declining this service agreement when I bought the car, but then they greatly lowered the price and basically begged me to take it, so I caved). By this time, I was home from work and started digging up the info on this service agreement. Turns out it is supposed to be valid until 2014. I called the 800 information number. They tell me it is ALSO supposed to cover parts like fuel pumps. So, hey, we've got 2 things that should cover it, right? This one has a $100 deductible and EMERGENCY ROADSIDE ASSISTANCE. They told me to call the emergency number and have the car towed to the dealer, and it would be taken care of.
By this time it was 7:00PM, and our car was still at our mechanic. During this whole time, he did some additional diagnosis, and verified that it was in fact the fuel pump. In the morning, we call the roadside assistance number to have it towed to the other dealer across town. We wait on the phone for 30 minutes. No answer. This is supposed to be the “emergency” number right??? So, we gave up and called AAA again. They agreed to do it, even though it was an unusual situation.
So I called back the information number for the service agreement to give them an earful about their “emergency” service. During the conversation, we revisit the repair that is needed, and I got a completely different story about what it would cover than I did the night before. They say the fuel pump won't be covered, either now. WTF??? I was livid. I informed them that I will be asking for a refund on the service agreement, since it is clearly worthless.
We picked the car up from the other dealer across town last night. The repair was in fact covered by warranty. So it cost us nothing, other than the 2 towing bills. This other dealer may have won themselves a new customer!
Rant: car repair run-around
- pioneer98
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 22007
- Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
- Location: High A Minors
- Fat_Bulldog
- likes to grate his own cheese
- Posts: 12883
- Joined: May 9 06, 12:41 pm
- Location: Drunk
Re: Rant: car repair run-around
Why a dealer wouldn't honor a service agreement from the manufacturer is beyond me. They get retail repair costs refunded to them from the manufacturer.
The service advisor at dealer #1 should be fired.
The service advisor at dealer #1 should be fired.
- IMADreamer
- Has an anecdote about a townie he overheard.
- Posts: 12911
- Joined: December 6 10, 1:09 am
- Location: Illinois
Re: Rant: car repair run-around
It is a car dealers job to bend you over and break it off in your ass any way they can. Whether it be the service department or sales that's their number one goal.
- pioneer98
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 22007
- Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
- Location: High A Minors
Re: Rant: car repair run-around
I got clarification from the service agreement people - their explanation is that this particular repair should have been covered by the powertrain warranty. So their screw ups were not explaining that very well in the fist place and then not answering their emergency service number.
I went into the dealership today and explained the mess to them. It was the manager and assistant manager (both men). They wanted to know who told us it wouldn't be covered. I didn't get the name, but it was a woman. I bet whoever this woman was got chewed out. They gave me some free service credit. I also asked, and they said I could cancel that service agreement if I wanted to, and at least get a refund for the amount that is left on it. They tried to talk me out of it. I want to think about that some more before I decide.
We are lucky this incident didn't cost us much. It was just the hassle. And it's also knowing that next time, it could be more expensive if they screw up again.
I went into the dealership today and explained the mess to them. It was the manager and assistant manager (both men). They wanted to know who told us it wouldn't be covered. I didn't get the name, but it was a woman. I bet whoever this woman was got chewed out. They gave me some free service credit. I also asked, and they said I could cancel that service agreement if I wanted to, and at least get a refund for the amount that is left on it. They tried to talk me out of it. I want to think about that some more before I decide.
We are lucky this incident didn't cost us much. It was just the hassle. And it's also knowing that next time, it could be more expensive if they screw up again.

