Page 1 of 3

College Football players are trying unionize

Posted: January 28 14, 10:31 am
by go birds

Re: College Football players are trying unionize

Posted: January 28 14, 7:51 pm
by Vidor
Go get 'em, kids.

Re: College Football players are trying unionize

Posted: January 30 14, 10:01 am
by pioneer98
This will be fascinating to watch how it plays out. I know they aren’t even asking for pay, yet. But who gets all the money from the conference TV networks (like the Big Ten Network)? It just seems like everyone is swimming in money except the kids actually playing the sports.

Since these kids aren’t getting paid it opens up this huge temptation to pay them to lure them in, especially the ones who are dirt poor to begin with. And since they can’t pay them, they do all kinds of other shady crap for them instead. Just acknowledge reality that these kids are worth millions and pay them accordingly. This “student-athlete” crap is dumb.

Re: College Football players are trying unionize

Posted: January 30 14, 10:04 am
by Jocephus
i get what yer saying, the players are bringing in tons of money and not seeing any of it...but i would hate, and i dont know why, to see the disappearance of the "student-athlete"...education should come first (again i realize the dynamic has changed tremendously for college sports and it may not be possible to be a "student-athlete" anymore)...but thats the idea of going to college, getting a degree...

Re: College Football players are trying unionize

Posted: January 30 14, 10:44 am
by ndistops
If players want to be paid for playing sports alone and there's a market for that, it should be on the pro leagues to make it happen, not on colleges and universities. Colleges weren't the ones who made the 'minimum 3 years out of high school' rule.

Re: College Football players are trying unionize

Posted: January 30 14, 10:46 am
by AWvsCBsteeeerike3
Jocephus wrote:...but thats the idea of going to college, getting a degree...
I'd argue the idea of going to college is to get a job.

Re: College Football players are trying unionize

Posted: January 30 14, 10:49 am
by Jocephus
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:
Jocephus wrote:...but thats the idea of going to college, getting a degree...
I'd argue the idea of going to college is to get a job.
that'd be an argument in semantics.

Re: College Football players are trying unionize

Posted: January 30 14, 10:50 am
by pioneer98
Jocephus wrote:i get what yer saying, the players are bringing in tons of money and not seeing any of it...but i would hate, and i dont know why, to see the disappearance of the "student-athlete"...education should come first (again i realize the dynamic has changed tremendously for college sports and it may not be possible to be a "student-athlete" anymore)...but thats the idea of going to college, getting a degree...
Yeah I agree with you that education is more important. Remind me: what on Earth does playing football have to do with getting a college degree again? Something like 99.7% of students on a typical big D1 football campus don't play football. Yet, so many college resources are dedicated to football. Colleges can give lip service that education is the more important thing, but their actions say otherwise. This is why players get caught having others take tests for them, professors are pressured to give them good grades, etc. And occasionally players, boosters and administrators are caught doing much, much worse than fudging grades. It all just seems like a giant charade to me.

Re: College Football players are trying unionize

Posted: January 30 14, 10:58 am
by pioneer98
In Europe, there is a union for *students*. Yes, just random joe blow Engineering and English majors can join a union. They don't even have to be part of a multi-billion dollar industry.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Students'_Union

If education is so important, maybe they should start one of these!

Re: College Football players are trying unionize

Posted: January 30 14, 11:07 am
by Jocephus
i agree that it is, more or less, a charade anymore (particularly with the powerhouses)...but i mean, it was *meant* to be an extra curricular activity (i know you know that) for a student

i certainly don't have a solution. it'd be nice to say "just let 'em go pro" after high school or cut back on the intensity of NCAA sports but then i'd hate for athletically gifted students who's only opportunity for higher education is thru sports to be spurned, particularly if they're good enough for college but not pros, which i would guess is like, 95% of college athletes. and, the general public likes their sports, their traditions, etc.

it'd be nice if the almighty dollar wasn't the most important factor in the room but, as usual, it is.