Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
User avatar
mikechamp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11774
Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
Location: Southwestern Illinois

Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by mikechamp »

These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on August 9.

It's been a while since he's had a chat, so he held two over the weekend. This is the 1st. I included 1 bonus question about his favorite trade deadline move. Enjoy the reads!!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/08/ ... at-66.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
I just want to say, the team with the best record right now has a starting outfield of Issac Collins, Blake Perkins, and Sal Frelick... this team is absolutely wild.

Mark Polishuk
Credit to those outfielders for all playing well, and to the Brewers organization in general for (once again) figuring out a way to remain contenders.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are the Reds chasing rainbows?

Mark Polishuk
The Reds have an opening here with the Mets struggling and the Cubs to some extent just treading water over the last few weeks. Cincinnati’s trade deadline moves were pretty interesting, and I think the team still had it in them to make a run down the stretch.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are the Cardinals a better team without Arenado?

Mark Polishuk
Since Arenado isn’t offering much at this point beyond good defense, probably yes.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What will it take for the Reds to truly acquire a player that helps them offensively this winter/offseason? And when will the media begin calling out their ownership/front office?

Mark Polishuk
In my view, the Cincinnati beat writers have been plenty critical of the team’s moves, or lack thereof.

The Reds have a lot of money coming off the books this winter, so even with arb raises cutting into that figure to some extent, there’s room for the team to make at least one pricey addition. If such a move is made, it simply has to be for a productive player (i.e. not the Jeimer Candelario signing), given the team’s budget limitations. Adding one proper full-time outfielder rather than relying on the platoons would also be a good way to solidify matters.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
As a diehard Pirates fan (I will take your pity please), is it wrong for me to want to trade Skenes now? I want him in Pittsburgh forever but the reality is that isn’t going to happen and I don’t want to see his career ruined by the inept organization. Plus the haul back is the best bet to land 3 future major league bats in the lineup.

Mark Polishuk
It’s an unfortunate state of affairs that fans are so resigned to having a generational talent on their team seem like an inevitable departure. I wonder how many Pirates fans share this poster’s view, in the sense that the Bucs might as well sell high on him now rather than delaying the inevitable.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Would the Reds trade Hector Rodriguez for Ward this offseason?

Mark Polishuk
Ward is the kind of everyday player that would be a nice fit in Cincy, except I’m not sure Rodriguez would be the ideal trade piece. H-Rod himself could be part of the answer in the Reds’ outfield as early as next season.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Would it make any sense for the Cards to sign DJ? Yankees are paying him through next year and he could help JJ at 2B, plus the Arenado friendship. Arenado needs to stay in the StL and enter the HoF with a Cards cap.

Mark Polishuk
For a Cardinals team that’s prioritizing playing time for younger talent, signing LeMahieu wouldn’t make any sense.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Agree or disagree: Buying at the trade deadline is a trap for most teams. Deadline trades usually don’t move the needle much and are more likely to harm than hurt; for every Yoenis Cespedes that comes in and saves a season, there are five Pete Crow-Armstrongs.

Mark Polishuk
Pretty much every World Series champion of the last umpteen years has been helped by a deadline acquisition. Would some of these teams have won a ring without that deadline pickup? Maybe, but we’ll never know, and flags fly forever.

It’s a “trap” in the sense that only one team wins every year, but I don’t view anything short of a championship as making a deadline push “not worth it” in most cases.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What was your favorite deadline move?

Mark Polishuk
I really liked the Phillies getting Duran. They paid a big cost, but having a star closer immediately solves a big roster problem.
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Post Reply