Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
User avatar
mikechamp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11774
Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
Location: Southwestern Illinois

Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Post by mikechamp »

These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' writer Steve Adams that occurred on August 12. (If you like him, you can find him on Twitter @Adams_Steve and Bluesky @adams-steve.bsky.social.)

A few questions this week, and I included one bonus Q&A about the Astros being shady (again). Enjoy!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://live.jotcast.com/chat/chat-with ... 22011.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
What is Pittsburgh doing? Trading Hayes looks like starting over. Will Cruz still be around when they're competitive again?

Steve Adams
I don't think dumping the rest of an unwanted Hayes contract constitutes starting over. If they traded Paul Skenes, that would've been starting over.

Cruz only has three years of club control after this one, and I don't expect the Bucs to compete in 2026, so I'd lean toward him being traded before the Pirates are genuinely competitive again, though.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will the Pirates ever call up Bubba Chandler this year?

Steve Adams
After Aug. 15, players no longer have enough days on the calendar to exhaust their rookie status this year. I'm guessing that on 8/20 or so, Chandler is magically ready for the majors, and he'll then head into '26 in position to break camp on the roster and possibly net the Pirates a draft pick via the Prospect Promotion Incentives, depending on ROY voting.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Look ahead to next year for the Brewers --- what might they be seeking in free agency? Do they go with Vaughn at first? Durbin at third? Ortiz at Short? Wait for the middle infield rookies to mature? If they spend any money (always a big if), what night they seek out?

Steve Adams
I just don't expect them to look to spend all that much. Vaughn has all but staked his claim to the 1B job in 2026 with his absurd turnaround. I could see them looking for some left-side infield help, but there aren't many great options out there in that regard anyhow aside from Bregman or Suarez, I suppose, and the Brewers aren't ponying up for either.

I imagine they'll be open to adding a veteran starter on a one-year deal and they'll look for some bench/bullpen upgrades who won't break the bank. They'll at least listen to offers on Freddy Peralta, since he's only signed one more year and that's just what the Brewers do. But in general, I just wouldn't get your hopes up for a big-money acquisition. It's not how they typically operate, and based on how much success they have every year, I'm not really sure it's how they need to operate.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Does Zac Gallen get a QO next year? Fair to assume King and Woodruff do, injuries notwithstanding?

Steve Adams
All three will get qualifying offers.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Have we ever seen a contending team make an acquisition blunder like the Cubs did with Mike Soroka? Velo was trending down on a pitcher who has an injury history and they made the trade anyways?

Steve Adams
The velo dip was pretty notable, but the Cubs were obviously comfortable enough with their review of his medicals.

I don't think their big blunder was necessarily in acquiring Soroka at all, but rather in having him stand as the only real addition to a rotation that's in glaring need of more help.

The Cubs (and Tigers and several others) seem paralyzed by the notion of giving up top prospects in a trade. The entire industry as a whole -- Padres, Mariners and maybe the Phillies excluded -- seems to be in this boat. Front offices are so protective of prospects that it's reached the point of absurdity, in my view.

The number of guys who've gone from untouchable to sell-low trade chips and eventual DFA fodder is staggering. The MLB front office groupthink regarding prospects is so over the top.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Ms have to make a real effort to sign Naylor, right? He’s a perfect fit and they don’t have any real 1B prospects in the system.

Steve Adams
I'm sure they'll make some effort, but I don't know that the lack of high-end 1B prospects in their system means much. The free agent market this year will have Ryan O'Hearn, Pete Alonso, Paul Goldschmidt, Rhys Hoskins, Luis Arraez and, of course, Naylor. Trade market could have Nate Lowe, Ryan Mountcastle, Triston Casas, Alec Burleson and others.
So sure, if they like Naylor well enough, absolutely make a run at keeping him. But I don't think it's any sort of colossal misstep if they decide they don't want to go 4-5 years on him and pivot to something shorter-term.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Cubs need an off season splash especially if they lose Tucker so who do they get? Bellinger reunion or someone else?

Steve Adams
They've got Busch at 1B and an outfield with Pete Crow-Armstrong, Seiya Suzuki, Ian Happ, Owen Caissie and Kevin Alcantara. They clearly didn't want to move Caissie at the deadline.

I don't think they'd shell out five years and $100MM+ for Bellinger. (Someone will) If they make a big move, a more legitimate run at Bregman or a quality rotation arm seems more feasible.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will the Pirates trade Skenes in the off season, or at next year's deadline?

Steve Adams
I doubt either. Probably 2+ years before they get to really considering that (and only if the franchise is still toiling)
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I get teams like to sometimes hide/downplay injuries publicly, but two years in a row now the Astros have had "minor injuries" turn into nearly year long absences. Is this medical malpractice, or simply publicly being shady?

Steve Adams
Houston has for years been the least forthcoming team in the game when it comes to the health of their players. They did recently start (finally) issuing weekly medical updates on their injured guys, however.
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Post Reply