Page 1 of 1

Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Posted: September 9 25, 1:19 pm
by mikechamp
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' writer Steve Adams that occurred on September 9. (If you like him, you can find him on Twitter @Adams_Steve and Bluesky @adams-steve.bsky.social.)

One more question than last week, and no bonus Q&As yet again. Enjoy!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://live.jotcast.com/chat/chat-with ... 22290.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Every time Ryan Helsley gets shelled with the Mets, his prospects for a big free agent contract fade. Looking like a 1-year pillow contract for a team desperate for a closer, like the Orioles, right?

Steve Adams
His stock was already down after a good-not-great run in St. Louis this year (still don't know why they didn't trade him in the winter). It comes down to a matter of preference for him, probably. I'm sure plenty of teams would love to "buy low" on a weighty one-year deal (still worth $10MM+). Helsley could go that route, try to rebound, and look for the big long-term deal next winter. But he's already 31 (32 next July), and if he takes another step back, his chances of a lucrative long-term deal are shot.

There are probably teams still willing to bet on the stuff and track record to put forth two- and three-year deals with more modest AAVs than he'd have gotten with a typical Helsley season. Does he want to go like 1/15 and try again, or would he take 2/26 or 3/30 and max out right now?

Those are the scenarios I expect he'll have to weigh.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is there any chance the Pirates DON'T bring Don Kelly back next year? If so, what would be their reason not to? He's managed the team to a 0.491 win % as opposed to Shelty's 0.316%.

Steve Adams
At this point, I'd be surprised if he's not back. Your mileage may vary on whether that's a good or bad thing, but I'm kind of in the "it doesn't matter all that much as long as Nutting owns this team," honestly.

At the very least, I don't think Kelly has done anything to hurt his chances of keeping the job for a few years beyond the current season.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Bregman will surely opt out, does he stay or go? What does his next contract look like?

Steve Adams
Yeah I don't see any way he passes on the opt-out, barring some awful injury here in the final few weeks.

Red Sox will be in the mix to keep him. Cubs, Tigers, Jays, Phillies all seem like viable alternatives. (I'd say Mariners, but they just don't spend at this level on free agents under Dipoto)

A five-year deal in the $160-170MM range feels safe/conservative, but I wouldn't entirely rule out six years and $30MM+ annually.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Would Donovan and Nootbaar be enough for Woo from the Mariners this offseason? Or is more likely Donovan and a prospect?

Steve Adams
Donovan/Noot isn't even in the ballpark. And unless that unnamed prospect is like ... JJ Wetherholt, I don't think "Donovan + prospect" gets it done either. Four cheap years of a proven playoff-caliber starter like Woo is going to be priced exorbitantly on the trade market, even if you think he's more like a very strong No. 2 than a true No. 1/ace (which is where I'm at).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will Woodruff receive and reject a qualifying offer?

Steve Adams
Yeah.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
OK now that we know Volpe isn't the answer, do the Yankees trade him in the offseason?

Steve Adams
It wouldn't shock me. I'd have said the Braves are a good fit before they claimed Kim, but they would be if Kim decides to opt out and test the market. Tigers, Marlins, Nats, Pirates... there are plenty of young clubs that I think would be pretty intrigued with a buy-low scenario there, and he's still young enough that he'd net a real return.

Side note: remember all the "The Yankees can't trade either Peraza or Volpe" talk a few years ago? Teams should be more willing to trade prospects than they are (and that extends well beyond the Bronx)
-----------------------------------------------------------------
JoJo and O'Brian have pitched well this year. Historically, between the two O'Brian would be the pick as JoJo is a lefty. In 2026, how do you foresee the Cards managing their closers?

Steve Adams
I would imagine that with one year of control remaining, JoJo Romero is getting traded this offseason. Riley O'Brien will be in the 'pen next year, but I would imagine a good bit of roster turnover in St. Louis this winter, so I expect the late-inning relief corps to look pretty different
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Could Lodolo be on the move this coming offseason with two years of control?

Steve Adams
I could see the Reds listening, for sure. I don't think they'll necessarily shop him outright, but with Greene, Burns, Abbott, Lowder, Singer and Petty all around, plus Aguiar and Williamson still in the org and mending from injury, there's decent pitching depth.

Moving Singer is the safer bet, since he only has one pricey year of control left, but Lodolo would net a better return
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Where will the Cardinals stand next year with Jordan Walker, Thomas Saggese, and their pitching prospects?

Steve Adams
As I alluded to earlier, I think there'll be plenty of changes to the roster this winter. Walker, Gorman, Saggese, Graceffo, Nootbaar, Herrera ... a lot of the formerly young core seems like it'll be very much available. The Cards have gotten tons of looks at this group over the years, and while it's hard to sell low on some formerly well-regarded prospects, it's easier when the guy making the trades isn't the one who drafted/acquired them. I think Chaim Bloom will have a pretty active winter.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Keep hearing Kyle Tucker to Dodgers next year? Your thoughts?

Steve Adams
I think it's natural that a lot of people would predict the top free agent to sign with the biggest-spending team, but outside of players in very unique circumstances (Ohtani, Yamamoto), the Dodgers haven't spent like this in free agency. They usually offer shorter-term deals with higher annual rates.

They're also pretty deep in OF, with Pages, Teoscar, Edman, Zyhir Hope, Josue De Paula. Could always try to dump the final couple years of Teoscar, but the Dodgers don't stand as the best or most logical Tucker pick to me.
-----------------------------------------------------------------