Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments
Posted: September 23 25, 2:11 pm
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on September 21.
The Reds' fans were very inquisitive this time. No bonus questions this time. Enjoy the read!!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/09/ ... at-77.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
With this hot streak, do the Reds squeak their way into the playoffs?
Mark Polishuk
Cincinnati is in a wild card spot right now, by dint of holding the tiebreaker over the Mets. The Reds’ final six games are against the Pirates, and against a Brewers team that will probably be resting guys. So, the Reds’ fate is in their own hands, and it helps that the Mets have just been spiraling.
I think I wrote just in last week’s chat that the Reds had really missed an opportunity to take hold of the wild card race. Clearly they read the Weekend Chat and were so enraged that they went on this winning streak!
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will Austin Hays' option be picked up by the Reds this year?
Mark Polishuk
It’s a $12MM mutual option with a $1MM buyout. Mutual options are virtually never exercised by both sides, so Hays will head to free agency again.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will Sonny Gray agree to waive his no trade clause with a rebuild coming?
Mark Polishuk
He wasn’t willing to waive it last year when it also seemed like a rebuild was coming, so I’d lean towards Gray returning. If he indicated he was willing to be moved, I can see the Cards exploring deals. Susan Slusser recently reported that the Giants have Gray on their offseason trade radar, and laid out some plausible reasons why Gray might be willing to approve a deal to San Francisco in particular.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Rangers HAVE to sign either Tucker, Schwarber, or Bregman right? Get a proven hitter to help Seager and Langford in that lineup.
Mark Polishuk
Assuming that Texas indeed stayed under the tax line and reset their taxpayer status, I can see them making (or trying to make) one big splash.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Rank from most to least likely to resign with their current team: Alonso, Schwarber, Bregman, and Tucker.
Mark Polishuk
Schwarber, Bregman, Alonso, and then a big gap before Tucker. I’d guess Schwarber staying in Philly is borderline probable given how the organization loves him, and Tucker is almost definitely leaving Chicago.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Any chance Braves trade Acuna? Would look good in right field for the Cubs?
Mark Polishuk
There’s zero chance Acuna is traded. Why would the Braves do that?
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do the Pirates take a big swing trade wise in the offseason? Maybe trade for Taylor Ward by giving up some of their insane pitching depth?
Mark Polishuk
Ward is set for free agency following the 2026 season, so I’m not sure if the Bucs want to give up one of their prized young arms for just one year of his services.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What is it going to take for the Cubs to fire everyone?
Mark Polishuk
They’ve made the playoffs and will finish with the third or fourth best record in the National League. Hoyer just signed an extension two months ago. Counsell is under contract through 2028.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Thoughts on Cherington’s comments? Any free agents/trades Pirates could go/make after this offseason?
Mark Polishuk
If not necessarily Taylor Ward, getting 2-3 experienced and proven bats would be a huge help. Since we can’t assume the Pirates will spend to sign anyone notable, that puts the onus on Cherington to trade a controllable young pitcher for a controllable young hitter, and hope to score much bigger than the Priester-for-Yorke swap.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Can you name a catcher season you would take over 2025 Cal Raleigh?
Mark Polishuk
Probably some Josh Gibson years, but that might literally be it in all of baseball history. Just an incredible year for Raleigh.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who ya got for NL ROY?
Mark Polishuk
Off the top of my head, Cade Horton, but I’d have to double-check all the numbers.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
No matter how it turns out (hopefully for the better), isn’t it still obvious the Reds HAVE to improve the offense in the off-season? How often do we have to face this before they actually do anything?
Mark Polishuk
Agreed. With the pitching becoming such a strength, adding some real bats could make Cincinnati into a big threat quickly (if they aren’t already).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Naylor to the Reds? Or is he staying where he is?
Mark Polishuk
Naylor would be a very nice boost to the Cincinnati offense, but I’m not sure if the Reds are willing to meet his asking price.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Reds' fans were very inquisitive this time. No bonus questions this time. Enjoy the read!!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/09/ ... at-77.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
With this hot streak, do the Reds squeak their way into the playoffs?
Mark Polishuk
Cincinnati is in a wild card spot right now, by dint of holding the tiebreaker over the Mets. The Reds’ final six games are against the Pirates, and against a Brewers team that will probably be resting guys. So, the Reds’ fate is in their own hands, and it helps that the Mets have just been spiraling.
I think I wrote just in last week’s chat that the Reds had really missed an opportunity to take hold of the wild card race. Clearly they read the Weekend Chat and were so enraged that they went on this winning streak!
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will Austin Hays' option be picked up by the Reds this year?
Mark Polishuk
It’s a $12MM mutual option with a $1MM buyout. Mutual options are virtually never exercised by both sides, so Hays will head to free agency again.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will Sonny Gray agree to waive his no trade clause with a rebuild coming?
Mark Polishuk
He wasn’t willing to waive it last year when it also seemed like a rebuild was coming, so I’d lean towards Gray returning. If he indicated he was willing to be moved, I can see the Cards exploring deals. Susan Slusser recently reported that the Giants have Gray on their offseason trade radar, and laid out some plausible reasons why Gray might be willing to approve a deal to San Francisco in particular.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Rangers HAVE to sign either Tucker, Schwarber, or Bregman right? Get a proven hitter to help Seager and Langford in that lineup.
Mark Polishuk
Assuming that Texas indeed stayed under the tax line and reset their taxpayer status, I can see them making (or trying to make) one big splash.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Rank from most to least likely to resign with their current team: Alonso, Schwarber, Bregman, and Tucker.
Mark Polishuk
Schwarber, Bregman, Alonso, and then a big gap before Tucker. I’d guess Schwarber staying in Philly is borderline probable given how the organization loves him, and Tucker is almost definitely leaving Chicago.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Any chance Braves trade Acuna? Would look good in right field for the Cubs?
Mark Polishuk
There’s zero chance Acuna is traded. Why would the Braves do that?
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do the Pirates take a big swing trade wise in the offseason? Maybe trade for Taylor Ward by giving up some of their insane pitching depth?
Mark Polishuk
Ward is set for free agency following the 2026 season, so I’m not sure if the Bucs want to give up one of their prized young arms for just one year of his services.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What is it going to take for the Cubs to fire everyone?
Mark Polishuk
They’ve made the playoffs and will finish with the third or fourth best record in the National League. Hoyer just signed an extension two months ago. Counsell is under contract through 2028.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Thoughts on Cherington’s comments? Any free agents/trades Pirates could go/make after this offseason?
Mark Polishuk
If not necessarily Taylor Ward, getting 2-3 experienced and proven bats would be a huge help. Since we can’t assume the Pirates will spend to sign anyone notable, that puts the onus on Cherington to trade a controllable young pitcher for a controllable young hitter, and hope to score much bigger than the Priester-for-Yorke swap.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Can you name a catcher season you would take over 2025 Cal Raleigh?
Mark Polishuk
Probably some Josh Gibson years, but that might literally be it in all of baseball history. Just an incredible year for Raleigh.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who ya got for NL ROY?
Mark Polishuk
Off the top of my head, Cade Horton, but I’d have to double-check all the numbers.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
No matter how it turns out (hopefully for the better), isn’t it still obvious the Reds HAVE to improve the offense in the off-season? How often do we have to face this before they actually do anything?
Mark Polishuk
Agreed. With the pitching becoming such a strength, adding some real bats could make Cincinnati into a big threat quickly (if they aren’t already).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Naylor to the Reds? Or is he staying where he is?
Mark Polishuk
Naylor would be a very nice boost to the Cincinnati offense, but I’m not sure if the Reds are willing to meet his asking price.
-----------------------------------------------------------------