Page 1 of 1

Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: October 27 25, 1:27 pm
by mikechamp
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on October 26.

A good amount of questions this week, but no bonus questions. Enjoy the read!!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/10/ ... at-83.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Reds trading front of line pitcher this off-season?

Mark Polishuk
If by “front of the line” you mean Greene, Abbott, or Lodolo, probably not. Petty and Burns likely aren’t going anywhere either, so Singer might be the most realistic starter Cincinnati would deal to obtain some real hitting help.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
You’re the GM of the Pirates, and Bob Nutting has told you he intends to raise the payroll as high as $210 million in 2026 (don’t laugh!). What moves do you make this offseason to put PIT in contention?

Mark Polishuk
First I get up off the ground, since that news would’ve caused me to faint.

Then, heck, sign Tucker, sign Schwarber, go all out on bats.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What routes do you see the Red Sox taking? I feel there are a million different ways they could go. I feel signing Tucker then trading both Duran and Abreu in two different trades for pitching is the way to go.

Mark Polishuk
This seems a touch complicated when the Sox could just trade one OF for a pitcher, and then perhaps sign another arm. Tucker probably won’t be on Boston’s radar when the Sox already have so much in the outfield pipeline.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who should Bloom go after in free agency, but also remain in rebuild territory?

Mark Polishuk
The Cardinals’ free agent targets will probably be veterans on one-year deals, with the idea being that St. Louis could then potentially flip them at the deadline. They don’t want to block any of their young players to any great extent, but signing a starting pitcher to eat innings and act as an experienced leader for the kids makes sense, especially if Gray is moved.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Where do you see Freddy Peralta next year?

Mark Polishuk
On Opening Day, Freddy Peralta will be playing for….

The Brewers (27.7% | 102 votes)

Another team (72.2% | 265 votes)

Total Votes: 367

I totally see the logic in trading Peralta, but I’d lean more towards him staying put. The fact that Peralta is making just $8MM is such a big help to the Brewers’ budget and their rotation that it would be a really huge offer to get Arnold to pull the trigger on a deal.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What would Tyler Soderstrom cost in a trade? Sox need some power bats. I also can see Rhys Hoskins as a good fit on a 1 yesr deal.

Mark Polishuk
Signing Hoskins is a far, far likelier scenario than the A’s dealing away a controllable talent like Soderstrom. The LF experiment with Soderstrom worked out far better than expected, so the A’s suddenly have no logjam between him, Rooker, and Kurtz.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think the Dodgers will go out and get some OF help this offseason or give one of their young minor league studs a chance to come up and play LF?

Mark Polishuk
You can’t rule LA out on a big signing like Tucker just because they’re one of the few teams in that spending tier. But, I can see the Dodgers being a bit cagier and looking to add an outfielder who is controlled just for 2026. Perhaps a Conforto-esque free agent on a one-year deal, except obviously with the hope that this player produces way more than Conforto did.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Where do the Cards start? Fire sale and see what’s left? Not sure the fan base will give it 3 years. The past two generations of fans have never experienced this.

Mark Polishuk
You’re selling the STL fans short, since there have been tons of questions/comments in these chats alone over the last few years from Cardinals supporters wanting to blow things up. A rebuild is at least a direction, rather than the team spending 2024-25 largely treading water.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are the Cubs willing to take on salary to trade Ian Happ? Is Happ willing to waive his no trade clause to play left field in hometown of Pittsburgh?

Mark Polishuk
Happ is making $18MM, and he is coming off a very solid year. The Cubs probably don’t feel they should have to take on money in any trade, plus Happ probably won’t be too keen on waiving his no-trade protection. And, if he is, it’s hard to see him leaving a contender to join the woeful Bucs (hometown pride notwithstanding).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Brady Singer for Wilyer Abreu as the two main pieces make sense for both teams? I like Abreu in Cincy better than what it would take to get Duran. Seems like a better candidate to hit 30 HRs too.

Mark Polishuk
Singer is a free agent next winter, so the Red Sox would want a more controllable pitcher if they’re giving up Abreu.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you see a scenario where the Pirates trade Joey Bart? He had a bad year and he can’t field. Henry Davis at every day sounds better plus Rafael Flores and maybe a Shawn Ross. Tell me your thoughts? What do they do if they trade Bart?

1. Call up Shawn Ross.
2. Henry Davis Everyday and flores backup.
3. Sign a free Agent and let Spring decide

Mark Polishuk
What’s up with the Pirates and all their catchers with two first names? Henry Davis, Joey Bart, Shawn Ross, Omar Alfonzo, Rafael Flores….well, maybe not that last one, but come on, surely there’s someone in the world with “Flores” as a first name

Anyway, onto the actual question! I agree that Bart might be moved, as giving Davis another big dose of playing time seems like a more important big-picture decision.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do starting pitchers like Quintana and Jordan Montgomery make sense for the Cards rotation this season or will they target lesser starters? Thanks.

Mark Polishuk
Both make some sense, though Montgomery is recovering from Tommy John surgery and won’t be back until closer to midseason.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I remember B Gibson pitching a no-hitter, Torre batting .363, Whitey ball in the eighties. Pujols departing was a major blow, but nothing was like being told we would not compete in 2025. Being told we are losers does not sit in the midwest and I would rather find something else to do than watch.

Mark Polishuk
I don’t doubt that many Cards fans share your opinion, given the lower attendance numbers this season. But, if the Cards actually had gone ahead with more of a proper rebuild last winter, at least you could’ve said “ok, this stinks, but at least I can see that they’re trying to get better.”

Having a 2025 campaign that was basically a year of stasis made little sense to me, and probably added to the discord amongst the St. Louis fanbase.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who is the best option for the Royals to trade for to shore up their outfield needs this offseason? Or do they go the free agent route?

Mark Polishuk
Since the Royals have a need in both LF and 2B, Brendan Donovan might be the best fit since he can play either position (or toggle between the two).
-----------------------------------------------------------------