Page 1 of 3

MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Posted: November 3 25, 12:56 pm
by CardsofSTL

Re: MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Posted: November 3 25, 12:57 pm
by CardsofSTL
It would be typical to vote in Fernando the year after he died.

Re: MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Posted: November 3 25, 1:02 pm
by heyzeus
It's probably time for Bonds and Clemens. Put them in a special wing with displays about steroids and pictures of shrunken balls or whatever.

Re: MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Posted: November 3 25, 1:03 pm
by Popeye_Card
What are the voting rules around this new "contemporary baseball era ballot"? Voted on by peers from their playing era who are already in the HoF?

Hopefully Edmonds gets at least a chance through this process. I think he's more deserving than Jeff Kent, Dale Murphy, or Don Mattingly.

Re: MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Posted: November 3 25, 1:07 pm
by heyzeus
Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
November 3 25, 1:03 pm
What are the voting rules around this new "contemporary baseball era ballot"? Voted on by peers from their playing era who are already in the HoF?

Hopefully Edmonds gets at least a chance through this process. I think he's more deserving than Jeff Kent, Dale Murphy, or Don Mattingly.
100% true. And the less said about Harold Baines, the better.

Re: MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Posted: November 3 25, 1:09 pm
by Popeye_Card
I think they should also give Jose Canseco a shot on this ballot, just for fun.

Re: MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Posted: November 3 25, 1:43 pm
by CardsofSTL
Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
November 3 25, 1:03 pm
What are the voting rules around this new "contemporary baseball era ballot"? Voted on by peers from their playing era who are already in the HoF?

Hopefully Edmonds gets at least a chance through this process. I think he's more deserving than Jeff Kent, Dale Murphy, or Don Mattingly.
The voting committee is formed from a group of 16 Hall of Fame members, executives, and veteran media members, appointed by the Hall of Fame's Board of Directors. They can vote for 0-3 candidates.

To qualify to get on the ballot players had to have played in at least 10 major league seasons, not be on MLB's ineligible list, and have been retired for 16 or more seasons.

The ballot itself is selected by a historical committee appointed by the writers association.

Re: MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Posted: November 3 25, 4:33 pm
by ghostrunner
What came of Rose being made eligible? Did that actually happen or was Manfred just yapping and/or shamed out of following through?

Re: MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Posted: November 3 25, 4:38 pm
by heyzeus
ghostrunner wrote: ↑
November 3 25, 4:33 pm
What came of Rose being made eligible? Did that actually happen or was Manfred just yapping and/or shamed out of following through?
Rose's reinstatement was demanded by the president for unknown reasons, Manfred kowtowed to him, and and both have moved on to other distractions since. Now Rose can continue being dead and not in the Hall of Fame.

Re: MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Posted: November 3 25, 5:02 pm
by CardsofSTL
ghostrunner wrote: ↑
November 3 25, 4:33 pm
What came of Rose being made eligible? Did that actually happen or was Manfred just yapping and/or shamed out of following through?
He still has to be selected to appear on the ballot even if eligible.