Page 1 of 1

Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: November 25 25, 12:28 am
by mikechamp
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on November 23.

A lot more questions this week, plus 3 bonus questions: one about a former Cardinal, one about the upcoming HoF vote and one about long-term contracts. Enjoy the read!!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/11/ ... at-89.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will the Cardinals target anything specific (i.e. young, controllable pitching over hitting) in the Donovan return? Seems like they have a large list of suitors for him, so they should be able to target what they want.

Mark Polishuk
Probably pitching, but you’re right in that the Cardinals will be getting plenty of good offers. If the best offer of the bunch involves a controllable young bat, the Cards will be open to it.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Thoughts on the Brewers this offseason? Giving Woodruff the QO was not on my bingo card. Will Attanasio finally spend and go get a bat?

Mark Polishuk
Trading a starter for a hitter might be the likelier scenario, given how the Brewers are still working with a limited payroll. Having Woodruff back is a nice bonus for the team, and it makes it perhaps slightly likelier they’ll now be open to moving Peralta, but it’ll naturally still take a huge offer.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If the A’s were willing to move Soderstrom, what would a fair package from the Reds look like?

Mark Polishuk
I’ve written this before, but the ship has almost certainly sailed on the idea of the A’s trading Soderstrom. He was a very strong defensive left fielder, so now there aren’t any questions about how he’ll fit into the Athletics lineup.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Diamondbacks and Pirate lining up for a trade involving Lawlar and young pitching?

Mark Polishuk
That would make a lot of sense for both parties.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Brewers sign Jonah Heim?

Mark Polishuk
Heim should be able to find at least a timeshare with another team, just because the catching market is so thin. Chances are he won’t have to settle for a backup job in Milwaukee or in any other spot with a set #1 catcher.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Woodruff called the Brewers bluff, and now the payroll is more than maxed out. What move can the Brewers make to improve the offense without spending money or reducing payroll from current levels?

Mark Polishuk
If the Brewers were really concerned that Woodruff’s QO was going to throw their payroll out of whack, they wouldn’t have made the offer in the first place. Given how Woodruff pitched in 2025, I think the team is pleased with the idea of having that kind of ace-level upside in the rotation, if (big if) Woodruff can stay healthy.

As mentioned earlier, trading from their rotation depth could be one way for the Brew to add a bat without breaking the bank.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I know the odds or the Reds signing Schwarber are low but let’s say they did. Would he and some bullpen additions be enough to put the Reds as front runners in the division?

Mark Polishuk
“Frontrunners” may be a stretch since by this point, I’m just assuming the Brewers will always figure out a way to win the NL Central.

But obviously sure, having Schwarber alone would put the Reds in very good position to at least back to the postseason.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Which are the Pirates more likely to do…. Sign Schwarber, Extend Griffin, Extend Skenes

Mark Polishuk
Extending Griffin is far and away the likeliest of those three scenarios.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are the Bucs REALLY in on Schwarber?

Mark Polishuk
I’ve got no reason to believe they haven’t been in touch with his agent, or asked what kind of contract Schwarber is looking for. How realistic their chances are remains to be seen, but I can believe Cherington is doing his due diligence.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What does Jim Edmonds have to do to be elected to the HOF? His stats are very good.

Mark Polishuk
Edmonds absolutely needs to land on a veterans committee ballot someday, since I think he has a better case than half the guys on the current ballot.

Still can’t figure out why Lou Whitaker isn’t on the ballot either.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will the REDS actually trade HUNTER GREEN?

Mark Polishuk
Doubt it.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What do you think it would take for the Angels to land Lars Nootbaar?

Mark Polishuk
Nootbaar is a question mark for Opening Day, so if I’m the Angels, I aim for an outfielder without as many health concerns.
https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/10/ ... rgery.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Would the Athletics make sense as an Arenado suitor?

Mark Polishuk
In theory yes, since the A’s are so thin at third base. But I have a hard time seeing Arenado waiving his no-trade clause to play in a minor league ballpark for a team that isn’t yet a contender.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Could you see the Orioles trading Rutschman to the Pirates for pitching?

Mark Polishuk
The O’s value Rutschman highly enough that I don’t see them moving him for anyone Pittsburgh has, unless it was somehow part of a package for Skenes.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I know the Reds won’t be alone, but will they make a push in the Garcia/Bleday/Lowe/Morel market…plus maybe Geno Suarez, or is Geno too much and they go after a couple of the first group?

Mark Polishuk
The past history makes me wonder if Suarez and the Reds could be a fit. He’d be more of a clear-cut upgrade for Cincinnati than anyone from the non-tender crew.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Albert Pujols was a hot candidate to manage a team. Now he isn’t. What happened?

Mark Polishuk
It’s not uncommon for guys to be interviewed for several managerial openings over several years before finally landing a job. Pujols draws more attention because he’s a huge game, naturally, but perhaps thinks just didn’t click for him in this hiring cycle.

Managing in the WBC might raise his profile and make him more of a hotter candidate for next offseason’s round of managerial hirings.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Ryan Helsley becoming a starter? Good idea?

Mark Polishuk
I don’t really get the logic. Helsley has never been a starter in the majors and he hasn’t started at any level since 2019. If I’m the Tigers or any other team thinking about Helsley as a starter, I’d just play it safer and acquire an actual starter.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who’s getting in the HoF this year? Beltran and that’s it?

Mark Polishuk
Beltran likely gets over the 75% line, and Andruw Jones might sneak in as well. I can see the veterans committee electing someone (not Bonds or Clemens, though).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
When will owners wise-up and figure out that these long term contracts that pay players past the age of 34/35 never work out?

Mark Polishuk
Enough of them do work out that teams will always keep making these signings as the price of doing business.
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: November 25 25, 1:06 am
by MrCrowesGarden
I hate when fans adopt the language of "don't work out." If you don't wanna have the out years of a contract, your team is going to be paying way more in AAV. They probably should do that, but it's on the teams to make those offers.