Page 1 of 4

New Baseball America list of top 10 Cards prospects

Posted: January 7 26, 3:35 pm
by heyzeus

Re: New Baseball America list of top 10 Cards prospects

Posted: January 7 26, 4:23 pm
by phins
Baez, Ixan, Crooks are higher than I'd have them.

Re: New Baseball America list of top 10 Cards prospects

Posted: January 7 26, 5:10 pm
by HardcoreCardsFan
The rest of them, for anyone interested:

11. Yhoiker Fajardo
12. Yairo Padilla
13. Ryan Mitchell
14. Tekoah Roby
15. Tink Hence
16. Jesus Baez
17. Nathan Church
18. Cooper Hjerpe
19. Cade Crossland
20. Deniel Ortiz
21. Brycen Mautz
22. Braden Davis
23. Jack Gurevitch
24. Frank Elissalt
25. Nate Dohm
26. Bryan Torres
27. Zach Levenson
28. Chase Davis
29. Matt Pushard
30. Blake Aita

Re: New Baseball America list of top 10 Cards prospects

Posted: January 7 26, 5:48 pm
by st.lewis11
phins wrote: ↑
January 7 26, 4:23 pm
Baez, Ixan, Crooks are higher than I'd have them.
Just curious; how would you rank our top 10?

Re: New Baseball America list of top 10 Cards prospects

Posted: January 7 26, 5:51 pm
by WAR God
Chase Davis - #28

Re: New Baseball America list of top 10 Cards prospects

Posted: January 7 26, 8:31 pm
by heyzeus
WAR God wrote: ↑
January 7 26, 5:51 pm
Chase Davis - #28
Oof. But also…yeah.

Re: New Baseball America list of top 10 Cards prospects

Posted: January 8 26, 5:18 am
by WAR God
We need Tink to make the team out of ST.

Re: New Baseball America list of top 10 Cards prospects

Posted: January 8 26, 6:03 am
by phins
WAR God wrote: ↑
January 7 26, 5:51 pm
Chase Davis - #28
Prospects break your heart.

Re: New Baseball America list of top 10 Cards prospects

Posted: January 8 26, 6:13 am
by phins
st.lewis11 wrote: ↑
January 7 26, 5:48 pm
phins wrote: ↑
January 7 26, 4:23 pm
Baez, Ixan, Crooks are higher than I'd have them.
Just curious; how would you rank our top 10?
This is pretty top of head and not a lot of process/statistical rigor:

1. JJ
2. Doyle
3. Rodriguez
4. Mathews
5. Bernal
6. Clarke
7. Josh Baez
8. Tink Hence
9. Tanner Franklin
10. Yholker Fajardo

Re: New Baseball America list of top 10 Cards prospects

Posted: January 8 26, 6:17 am
by phins
HardcoreCardsFan wrote: ↑
January 7 26, 5:10 pm
The rest of them, for anyone interested:

11. Yhoiker Fajardo
12. Yairo Padilla
13. Ryan Mitchell
14. Tekoah Roby
15. Tink Hence
16. Jesus Baez
17. Nathan Church
18. Cooper Hjerpe
19. Cade Crossland
20. Deniel Ortiz
21. Brycen Mautz
22. Braden Davis
23. Jack Gurevitch
24. Frank Elissalt
25. Nate Dohm
26. Bryan Torres
27. Zach Levenson
28. Chase Davis
29. Matt Pushard
30. Blake Aita
With the pure stuff that Chen Wei-Len has, I'm quite surprised they don't have him listed.

Cardinals have a deep farm system, and after the top four you have various flavors of reasons those prospects could pop or reasons why they'll never be above replacement.

Baseball America used to overrate relievers, but when you look at what effective relievers get on the trade market these days, they might now be underrating them.